Re:The ‘solar canals’ making smart use of India’s space
by soperj on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:19PM
(#24073115)
It's not a one time cost is what I'm saying.
The trees in the forest that is flooded decompose slowly, and release methane the entire time.
Specifically to BC, the entire ecosystem also got screwed, the fish in tributaries, up and down from the dams have mercury poisoning.
Re:The ‘solar canals’ making smart use of India’s space
by marcosdumay on Thursday August 06, 2020 @05:01PM
(#24075427)
It is a constant amount emitted, for generating power during the entire lifetime of the plant. While fossil fuel plants emit an amount that is proportional to the power they generate.
That's a bad comparison. You can't simply compare them without any context.
Hydro has a one-time high carbon cost, while fossil fuels have a small ongoing cost. You can't simply state that one is better than the other, you need at minimum to restrict the comparison into a time-frame.
(By the way, nobody does a large hydro project without first cleaning out the previous vegetation nowadays. Historical data isn't good either.)