News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by ncallaway on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:44PM (#24046006)
Here's the thing, though. Wrongful termination lawsuits aren't "proof beyond a reasonable doubt". Most civil actions—including wrongful termination—need to show a "preponderance of evidence". That is, you need to convince a jury that the claim is more likely to be true than not true (e.g. 51%).

So, assuming you have evidence of the chain of events:

- Group shares salary openly - Employer says: "you cannot do that", someone responds: "You can't say that", employer: "oh, ok" - Group continues sharing salary - Employer shortly thereafter fires 2 members that had shared their salary citing other reasons ("You had 2 1-minute late attendance events within the last 2 weeks")

If I'm on that jury, if that's all the evidence presented, that gets me to a "preponderance of evidence" that the termination was wrongful. At that point, I would need to see some evidence from the employer that the attendance events leading to the firing was not pretextual.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by gibba999 on Monday August 03, 2020 @10:51PM (#24046049)
Here's the other thing though. Law suits are expensive. Law suits burn bridges (you'll never get a recommendation from an employer you've sued). Law suits prevent future jobs (would you hire someone who sued a previous employer?). And wrongful termination isn't the end.

And things are rarely black-and-white. If your boss thinks you're a douche, it will hurt your career. If your next performance review is a 7 instead of a 9, that might not lead to termination now, but it prevents career growth, and gets you sacked next layoff.

I don't think anyone would every get laid off JUST for sharing salary info, but it would push a lot of people over the edge.

All I'm saying is be careful about how you do it.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by shandor on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:15AM (#24046877)
> Law suits are expensive

Don't know about the US, but in countries with strong (or existing) worker unions the unions would jump at that kind of case to help the employee with expenses, legal counsel, and what have you.

Unions definitely have their problems, but keeping the employers on their toes about actually breaking the law is one of their big benefits.

Of course all that doesn't help with all the other things you brought up, so there's that.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by shim__ on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @06:12AM (#24048428)
A unionized workforce isn't likely to have this problem, since they would all be working under the same union contract being paid the same.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by dukeyukey on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @07:48AM (#24048982)
That very much depends on the type of union. For example, the union that exists for tech workers in the UK (https://prospect.org.uk/tech-workers/) provides legal support, advice and other professional help to it's members, but doesn't get involved in negotiation unless you ask, and even then they do it on an individual basis, based on your skills and employer requirements.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by tptacek on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @01:03AM (#24046801)
Here's the other other thing, though: lawsuits are expensive. Employers settle them routinely. I've seen frivolous suits settled for real money, just to get them out of the way. Legal expense probably scares most employers a lot more than it scares former employees.

Getting fired for sharing salary information is not high up on my list of concerns, in part for that reason.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by JamesBarney on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @02:31AM (#24047266)
On the other end there are companies that fight every lawsuit tooth and nail, even if it's more costly and they know they're going to lose because they don't want to get a reputation as easy pickings among employment lawyers.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by Gamemaster1379 on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @03:00AM (#24047425)
100% confirm these exist. When I first came to California, I worked for a computer repair shop in Sacramento as my first gig with a "budding software division". Place was a bait and switch on what they had me doing. Market took a downturn just after I moved so I was stuck in the job. They pressured me into doing full on software architecture but paid me like an intern for it.

Eventually went from bad to worse. It was so stressful it caused a condition of mine to flair up. Long story short, I was vomiting blood and stomach acid on the daily in the mornings. Work from home would have accommodated me but they refused because the CEO was an asshole. He let others work from home as a "favor", but wouldn't meet medical needs.

After giving me more than one death threat, I finally quit and sued. Pro bono, of course, since I had no money.

They hired the most expensive defense firm in California to take the case over what would have been a $5-$10k settlement. My lawyer was unbelievably startled by this, and immediately dropped the case after.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by bdowling on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @05:33PM (#24054726)
> After giving me more than one death threat, I finally quit and sued.

Threatening to kill you is probably another claim beyond failing to reasonably accommodate your medical condition. It may also be a criminal threat that a prosecutor would be interested in. I would think that would strengthen your case.

> Pro bono, of course, since I had no money.

> ... My lawyer was unbelievably startled by this, and immediately dropped the case after.

Depending on what type of pro bono attorney you had, that may have been reasonable. For free legal aid type attorneys, litigation is out of the scope of what they can help with.

What you probably wanted was a lawyer who would take the case on a contingent fee basis. That means that they don't get paid anything unless you win, but if you do win they take 30-40%. Many plaintiff-side personal injury and employment lawyers like to work contingency because if they're good at it they can make way more money than an attorney working for an hourly rate. It's often a good deal for the plaintiffs too because they may get 60-70% of a much larger settlement amount.

It sounds like you got some bad advice.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by JamesBarney on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @05:58PM (#24054929)
Most employment lawyers would be very reluctant to take a case like this for 5-10k.

Litigating against a company like the one he described would cost more than he would make even if he was paid on 100% contingency fee.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by bdowling on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @10:40PM (#24056764)
> Most employment lawyers would be very reluctant to take a case like this for 5-10k.

We don't know the actual value of the case. The defendants seemed to think that it was worth hiring "the most expensive defense firm in California".

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by JamesBarney on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @01:34PM (#24063347)
You're right we know very little facts about the case, but gamemaster and his lawyer did and came to the conclusion it was a 5-10k case. So without any other evidence why should we assume that estimate is wrong?
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by bdowling on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @05:14PM (#24065657)
> So without any other evidence why should we assume that estimate is wrong?

We shouldn't assume that the estimate was accurate either, for a couple of reasons:

First, the defendant definitely has more information (e.g., manager's employment records). More information usually leads to a more accurate valuation. And the defendant seems to have valued the case higher because it hired the expensive defense attorney.

Second, Gamemaster's attorney dropped the case, probably because they lacked the required experience with these types of employment cases. If they lacked the required experience to handle the case, then they probably weren't qualified to give an accurate valuation either.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by JamesBarney on Thursday August 06, 2020 @01:42PM (#24073417)
You're reading a lot into his comment and making a lot of assumptions.

1. Defendant had more information

2. The extra information was so important it would increase the value of the case 50x (there are not very many pieces of information in an employment suit that would increase a payout by 50x that an employee wouldn't know about)

3. They hired a very expensive attorney because of this reason.(as opposed to for intimidation reasons)

4. Gamemasters attorney was inexperienced.

5. Gamemaster's attorney's lack of experience caused him to drop the case.

6. Gamemaster's attorney's lack of experience also led him not be able to give an accurate valuation.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by bdowling on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @12:49AM (#24117265)
You're right that we don't have a whole lot of information and shouldn't make assumptions. To that point, the number Gamemaster gave could have been an amount that he personally would have settled for and not a number that his attorney came up with.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by kasey_junk on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @07:11PM (#24055510)
I’m not sure how you made that determination. I’m no employment lawyer and facts differ by locality, but where I am there are tons of contingent lawyers who’d take that case just based on discovery costs.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by JamesBarney on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @09:32PM (#24056395)
I'm acquaintances with two employment lawyers and they talk shop when they're together. Their hourly rates are 300-500ish so 5,000-10,000 is 20ish hours of work. For that amount of work they are looking for an employer who is risk averse , and an employee who emotionally has moved on and is just looking for a little extra cash.

If the employer is legally aggressive or the employee is looking for a fight they would never take a case like that.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by blaser-waffle on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @12:57PM (#24062975)
> Here's the other thing though. Law suits are expensive.

Maybe. Depends on the state, the complaint, and the lawyer. Several states allow/force the loser to pay legal fees, to allow small-fry folks with legit complaints to fight against larger orgs with money to spend.

Lawyers may also take cases on contingency, or you may be able to find legal aid / pro-bono / reduced rates.

There are also lots of levers available via state or provincial labor boards. These will vary greatly, and may not replace a lawyer or lawsuit -- but some will.

> Law suits burn bridges (you'll never get a recommendation from an employer you've sued).

They already fired you for reasons that are "wrongful" -- the bridges are already burned. Were they going to give you a good recommendation before the lawsuit? Probably not. Maybe they didn't, and that's why there are lawyers involved.

> Law suits prevent future jobs (would you hire someone who sued a previous employer?). And wrongful termination isn't the end.

Depends on the role and hiring pool.

For roles that are harder to fill, or situations where I'm willing to take a good hard look at the candidate then maybe. Like, these are public records, and if I'm on the fence I could always just get a copy of those records. Plus there is plenty of shitty behavior on the part of employers -- no shortage of stories about it here on HN -- so I'm willing to give a qualified candidate the benefit of the doubt.

Totally agree with your point if this is for a role where I get 500-1000+ resumes -- plenty of talent out there, so why settle for someone who picked a fight?

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by perl4ever on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:43PM (#24046336)
One thing to consider before defending your rights in court, is that it's going to be public record forever. The cost and the chance of losing might not even be your biggest concerns.

I don't know how many employers check that sort of thing, but I know that if you sue your landlord in NYC, no matter how justified, once it shows up in public records nobody will rent to you. I know this because I ran across court documents where the court matter-of-factly acknowledged it.

This sort of thing is why I think frivolous lawsuits are greatly exaggerated.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by 1123581321 on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:36PM (#24046296)
You would get that evidence from the employer in every case, whether or not the termination was a retaliation.
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by manigandham on Monday August 03, 2020 @11:38PM (#24046309)
Are you assuming a company that does that would not have evidence ready?
Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by ncallaway on Tuesday August 04, 2020 @12:00AM (#24046434)
It depends what you mean by the company would have the evidence ready.

I'm positive the company would have evidence that the terminated individuals were late by 1 minute on two separate occasions. But the company might also have evidence that other employees were also late and not terminated.

You can pretty easily create an evidentiary trail that "Person X did thing Y, and was then terminated". What's harder is creating an evidentiary trail that "Other people at the company are also regularly terminated for thing Y".

If the company really does fire every employee that has two 1-minute tardiness', then it's going to be a real struggle to claim the firing was pretextual. If this firing is the first time the company has fired someone for those reasons, the company is in real trouble.

Re:Blizzard workers share salaries in revolt over wage dispa... by perl4ever on Thursday August 06, 2020 @08:19PM (#24076758)
I think they simply don't do it quite that way. If halfway competent.

Instead, when someone wants to get rid of an employee for a reason that might not be legitimate, they write them up for about a dozen vague and contradictory things, and then present it as a "sign or be fired on the spot" thing, whereupon the employee signs, either because they convince themselves they can salvage the situation, or they just need more time to job hunt.

Then after a little while, they do it again, so it fits into the normal framework of someone being put on a PIP and failing to improve.

When they quit or are fired, it's essentially impossible to challenge, because it wasn't just one or two tiny things, it was a whole list of BS, and the employee signed their name to it to buy time. Or at least it's intimidating enough I think few people would consider suing.