(1) The CCP is a secretive, authoritarian government with an established disregard for human rights. (2) China already imposes draconian restrictions on American (and EU!) companies, far in excess of the proposed restrictions on TikTok, e.g. forced "joint ventures" with Chinese firms resulting in wholesale theft of IP. (3) Unlike the EU, China is involved in a wide-reaching and pre-existing geopolitical power struggle with the US.
I'm not sure there are recent examples of US actions that even compare in scale or scope.
-- edit:
This also doesn't even get into the scale of the nation state cyber espionage activities. If you work in any government agency, or work with the government, your networks are under constant attacks.
Big claims like that's require evidence? Do you have any? The UN human rights commissioner has been repeatedly invited to Xinjiang for years yet still hasn't gone.
Why are a large group of Muslim countries publicly supporting China's efforts in the region to reduce extremism?[1]
The more you look past the sabre rattlers the shakier all this supposedly common knowledge looks. Trace it back far enough and it all leads to Adrian Zenz, whom the BBC called a "world leading expert on Xinjiang", except Zenz can't read or speak Chinese, he's an Evangelical missionary whose "scientific" paper on Xinjiang that's so often quoted by the media contains strange Bible references, his published books are on how to survive the coming rapture and contain lot of bigoted statements against homosexuals.
Just wondering if Zenz is your source here?
2019: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/01/china-visit-xinjiang-...
2020: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-xinjiang-rights-idU...
[1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-xinjiang-rights-idU...
Secondly IRAQ war or Afghanistan regime changes kill MILLIONS. Gitmo. Hypocritical at best. CIA has funded guerilla efforts to sabotage BRI if you want to know what that truly is about
Uh, no it's not. It's not even covered by one of the treaties banning weapons that the US hasn't signed up to (such as the cluster munition or landmine treaties).
If you disagree with me, please cite precisely which clause of which treaty prohibits the use of depleted uranium in weapons.
https://voelkerrechtsblog.org/the-use-of-depleted-uranium-mu...
You brought up the legal status. Then you were shown to be incorrect and are now trying to change the topic.
The downvoting here is, I assume, largely because it's sanctimonious whataboutism. And in general, you're combining two logical fallacies (both the sanctimonious part and the whataboutism), and many such lists can tend to delve into "I'm cherry-picking only the evidence that I want to see and ignoring anything that disagrees with my viewpoint."
It is amusing to me what is not on this list. I'm surprised there's no mention of Smedley Butler's War is a Racket, or Noah Chomsky's well-known views on the Vietnam War and the US media's involvement with it. I'm especially bemused by the lack of any mention to the drone assassination program, most tied to Obama--perhaps because every media mention of it inevitably criticizes it, so it doesn't work well as a "your government is doing evil stuff that you don't know about" example?
The context of discussion here is the parent comment asking whether there are recent examples of US actions that even compare in scale or scope. So, it's a little weird to screech about whataboutism when those examples are provided.
Meanwhile, it would take multiple books to list all of the known US atrocities, so I just picked a small sample there.
I remember that in WW2 both the Nazis and U.S. put people in camps, so they must have been morally equivalent.
It’s quite frankly baffling that people can’t see why one of the most popular social media platforms wouldn’t be considered a national security risk, especially after what we saw during the last presidential election.
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/qjd8bq/how-to-survive-a-n...
I have no dog in this fight, but isn't there at least a little evidence that TikTok may be collecting data on a large scale? I haven't been following it all that closely, but I thought that's what the original bans for military members was about.
Edit: So, yes, but that’s ok because others were too.
There's a gigantic list of apps that were revealed to be accessing things like the clipboard in iOS 14. I just installed the beta, and I found that my credit union's app reads the clipboard every time I open it. My third-party reddit app does the same thing.
TikTok doing it isn't really even news. There are dozens to hundreds of apps doing it, and it's likely a bug.
Any time a firm, app, or organization does something to offend or inconvenience the man, he launches an attack against it. There's certainly a pattern of this behaviour.
But it's nothing new really, just happened to become a "mainstream headline" now. Another thing that most people don't even realise, is that on android, every app can access the clipboard. Many apps do it continually, even in the background.
I think I have some past comments here on HN explaining more about how I restrict this type of behaviour if you're interested.
By default TikTok requires no permissions and doesn't even ask for a phone number to register.
It is kind of easy to build a user data profile on Android because the user doesn't even know that all of these datapoints can be gathered without any permissions. The actual implememtation of the permission system really is more "for show" imo.
Pretty sure EU car manufacturers like Daimler or VW would like to buy up Tesla's European operations for cheap. Just need the government to simply declare them to be a national security threat and force them to sell or lose access to the largest market on the planet.