News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by ladon86 on Sunday April 03, 2011 @11:14AM (#2402886)
Is this real? Everyone sounds like an obvious caricature of themselves.
Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by _delirium on Sunday April 03, 2011 @01:28PM (#2403252)
The lack of any mention of these chats in any historical literature I can find is also suspicious. I could imagine the transcripts being lost until now, but if indeed Ronald Reagan, Edward Said, and Jane Fonda had an ARPANet chat in 1975, I would've expected to be able to find at least one person having mentioned it!

Additional reason: the supposed discoverers are media artists, and this project was presented at a new-media art festival, rather than, say, a history conference (and no mention of how the transcripts may have been unearthed, or from where). Feels very much like a media-art project.

Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by ladon86 on Sunday April 03, 2011 @02:32PM (#2403431)
Absolutely, and the script almost has a sort of story arc as they await the arrival of Jane Fonda. It feels play-like.
Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by hugh3 on Sunday April 03, 2011 @07:33PM (#2404542)
Not just a play, but a fairly bad play.

Another objection: it's 1976. Would these folks have even known how to type? Governor Reagan wouldn't be complaining about the difficulty of typing, he'd have one of his secretaries come in and type while he dictates.

Also also, I just don't see Ronald Reagan agreeing to take time out to chat with Edward Said and Hanoi Jane at all.

Also also also, Reagan would be funnier.

Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by zokier on Sunday April 03, 2011 @11:00PM (#2405141)
I think it's fiction and attempts to be an art piece. It's presented at galleries, not in museums. Vol II mentions: "Featuring guest collaborator Khwezi Gule, a curator, artist and writer" (emphasis mine). Also all other people working on the site seem to be artists, not historians or techies.

Why they can't mention that somewhere on the page is beyond me.

Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by sunchild on Sunday April 03, 2011 @06:06PM (#2404253)
It reads like a terrible script from one of those "House on the Hill" type of movies. I keep waiting for the evil mastermind to introduce himself and explain why he's brought everyone together.

And, at the same time, it also sounds a whole lot like every chat and message board I've ever been in.

Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by rbanffy on Sunday April 03, 2011 @11:28AM (#2402925)
It's plausible. They were approaching a new technology they barely understood and knew they were being watched and recorded.

And, while on IRC, I most probably look like an obvious caricature of myself ;-)

Re:ARPANET dialogues - fictional chat logs by hollerith on Sunday April 03, 2011 @04:56PM (#2403973)
No it is not plausible. It is extremely unlikely that this is anything other than a hoax.