News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by eastendguy on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:11AM (#24007529)
Reporter A spends 50 hours researching and writing about a topic. She publishes it on her own blog.

Now I scrape this text (as summary) and display it on my own "Latest news" blog and the original author does often not even get a click-through. I do not think that is fair towards the original author.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by dmortin on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:34AM (#24007673)
If the reporter lives from ads on her blog then she needs traffic, because more traffic is more income.

So bringig traffic to the blog is a big value, so she should pay for this service. But she doesn't, because search engines are free.

News sites can block google and other bots any time on their sites with robots.txt, but they don't because they want the traffic for free, while they even demand money from those who bring the traffic.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by La1n on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:21AM (#24008298)
>News sites can block google and other bots any time on their sites with robots.txt, but they don't because they want the traffic for free, while they even demand money from those who bring the traffic.

I was feeling different about this topic until you brought this up. I think this is a really good argument. Yes, google scrapes and gets value from what they scrape without paying, however you can block this as a publisher if you don't want this.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by ketzu on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:56AM (#24008595)
The problem these attempts try to adress is that it's not a real choice: doing that would likely end your business, while boycotting would have little effect on google/Facebook. So it's a power struggle where one side doesn't really have a choice, because the other side has all the power.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by vageli on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:48AM (#24009093)
> So it's a power struggle where one side doesn't really have a choice, because the other side has all the power.

You do have a choice though. You can choose not to use google ads and stop performing SEO and drive business in alternative ways. Further, there are more search engines than just google. If your business model depends on google it may be time to rethink that strategy. Any competent marketing strategy would rely on diversified channels anyway.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by eberkund on Friday July 31, 2020 @11:59AM (#24010000)
The search engines also receive value in being an index or directory that people can use to lookup articles. The situation here is somewhat unique because Google is in a position to reap all of the benefit from this relationship by just scraping the content and displaying it directly to the user.

A comparable scenario would be something like the phone book or yelp where these directories have value to users but they simply refer users to the businesses advertising in the directory.

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by vertis on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:30AM (#24007649)
Same reporter "borrows" a photo/video editorially and doesn't pay the creator[0][1].

[0]: http://gakuran.com/daily-mail-used-my-photos-without-permiss... [1]: https://expertphotography.com/the-daily-mail-stole-my-photos... (Note this guy eventually got paid by chasing)

Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by diffeomorphism on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:04AM (#24008194)
That would be copyright infringement and is already illegal. Not the topic of discussion.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by CM30 on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:00AM (#24008163)
Isn't that pretty much all news works? After all, investigations are a rarity, and most stories in media outlets are basically sourced/paraphrased from elsewhere. If one site/network/paper finds something interesting like this, you bet anything that every other outlet will have their own story on the subject online in the next few minutes.

To some degree it's also how aggregator sites like Reddit and Hacker News work. Maybe even with anti paywall methods, archivers, etc getting the story in plain text format.

[dead]
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by mafuy on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:35AM (#24007676)
I can't even downvote on this site, but I think it is because your post seems to say Google News copies news without a link to the source, which is not the case.
Re:Australia to make Facebook, Google pay for news by iso1631 on Friday July 31, 2020 @08:06AM (#24007839)
It seem blatent copyright infringement to me.