News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by uluyol on Thursday July 30, 2020 @11:41PM (#24005424)
Google just wants to eliminate any remaining trust users have in them, don't they?

Every feature they remove, they do because it is a burden on feature velocity or maintenance. Fine, but why are they so bad at weighing it against long term trust? At this point, I expect the search box to search, Gmail to send emails, YouTube to host videos, maps to do navigation, and docs to edit docs. One core feature per platform, all other features will probably be dropped sooner or later.

It's a bad look, Google.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by dodobirdlord on Thursday July 30, 2020 @11:54PM (#24005486)
They’re getting hammered from the left for insufficient moderation of content, and from the right for overly aggressive moderation of content. It’s a lose-lose where the only real option is to remove extraneous features that enable users to upload content visible to others. Even if there was a standard of moderation that would satisfy everyone, there’s too much to moderate.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by reaperducer on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:06AM (#24005537)
Even if there was a standard of moderation that would satisfy everyone, there’s too much to moderate.

If only Google had a half a trillion dollars to spend on something other that spying on people. And if only there were 35 million people out of work.

But, alas, poor sweet simple Google cannot possibly lie in the bed it made.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by at_a_remove on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:10AM (#24005554)
Ah, so in this version you have thirty-five million people who could agree on what is offensive. That's a daunting task without the "million" involved to begin with.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by reaperducer on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:43AM (#24005738)
in this version you have thirty-five million people who could agree on what is offensive

Yes, because that's literally what the parent posited in his scenario:

"Even if there was a standard of moderation that would satisfy everyone"

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by VLM on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:15AM (#24008256)
The point is not to censor to match current sensibilities but to censor to push society in a direction. It doesn't matter if almost everyone hates what they're selling as long as they eventually push hard enough to sell it. They are, after all, an advertising company at heart.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by eyelidlessness on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:28AM (#24005661)
When you get hired as a regulation enforcer in any other scenario, it’s not your opinion but the actual regulations that determine your recourse. If it’s up to the opinions of the enforcement regime, that’s because the rules are unclear or opaque.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by creato on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:16AM (#24006183)
The fact that you believe something like content moderation can be boiled down to some hard and fast regulations, let alone a set of regulations that people could agree on, is honestly kind of scary.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by at_a_remove on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:04AM (#24005838)
I've been on various forums with "moderation standards." The different moderators still have different approaches and different reputations for being a soft touch or heavy-handed. Human moderators, despite having standards or guidelines in front of them, are not consistent. When confronted about it, they will cite interpretations, "reading the room," discretion, and so on.

We have seen this scenario play out in censorship standards, various authorities, and so on over the decades. It never works as intended.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by MattGaiser on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:20AM (#24005610)
Google made the bed for free and others wanted to pee in it. The rest blamed Google for the bed having pee in it and demanded they do something, including post 24 hour guards around the bed.

I would take the bed away too.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by mdoms on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:27AM (#24005658)
Ah yes, YouTube, that product that Google made and that doesn't bring them any revenue. Two things that are definitely true.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by rrdharan on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:58AM (#24005808)
You realize that revenue and profit are distinct?

Uber has massive revenues as do many other capital intensive businesses. That doesn't make them profitable.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by fakedang on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:18AM (#24005914)
Last time I checked, YouTube ads were a very profitable business.

The parent to your comment chose revenue likely to note that Google makes money from the bed ie. it's not a service given away for free.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by martinpw on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:32AM (#24006241)
Where did you check this? AFAIK YouTube profits (if any) are not broken out anywhere. At least not as of early this year:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/02/03/google-still-isnt-telling-us...

Alphabet said YouTube ad revenue in the first quarter reached $4.7 billion, while cloud sales came in at $2.6 billion. The company broke those numbers out for the first time, but it’s still not disclosing profit figures for the units.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by NoOneNew on Friday July 31, 2020 @07:09AM (#24007513)
Yea, but anyone that owns a small business understands how you hide profit so you get taxed less.

Given how quickly and easily the axe comes down on sub par Google products, I highly doubt they'd keep YouTube if it wasn't profitable.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by root_axis on Friday July 31, 2020 @11:54AM (#24009948)
Is the definition of the word "free" another casualty of this era? It's literally free...
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by MattGaiser on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:31AM (#24005978)
The bed referred to the community generated subtitles, not YouTube overall.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by spc476 on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:37AM (#24006850)
Some math shows that can't work. Half a trillion to 35 million is US$15,000 per person.

For one year. And people will complain that US$15,000 is not enough to live on.

What happens in year two?

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by TheOtherHobbes on Friday July 31, 2020 @06:39AM (#24007369)
Google goes bust?

That's not likely, is it?

Does Google have no concept of how YouTube drives ad sales and other synergies? Or of how much goodwill is worth?

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by spc476 on Saturday August 01, 2020 @06:21PM (#24024398)
Does any company make $500,000,000 a year?
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by crawsome on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:11AM (#24005564)
That's a different argument. The justification for the removal was spam, no?
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by dodobirdlord on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:17AM (#24005898)
This seems in line with other recent actions like disabling comments on broad swaths of YouTube videos. The given reason may be spam but it looks like there’s a pattern of surface area reduction.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by raxxorrax on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:06AM (#24005850)
I have the demand that they stop their abusive tracking. Would they ever do that? No. So I guess they want to become TV to pacify advertisers.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by specialist on Friday July 31, 2020 @09:04AM (#24008198)
Core problem is coupling "virality" and moderation. They're incompatible goals.

Remove the gamification and few would care that moderation lags.

The platforms try to mitigate virality with automated moderation. Anything to preserve that ad revenue.

The only societal fix is to slow down or break the engagement feedback loops. Something the platforms won't do voluntarily.

[dead]
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by dodobirdlord on Friday July 31, 2020 @01:20AM (#24005924)
I didn’t say that there’s any legitimacy to the attacks from the right. But nonetheless they exist and they are a waste of resources to address and are a convenient excuse for a hostile government administration to harass the company.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by wwweston on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:24AM (#24006208)
Fair enough!
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by claudiawerner on Friday July 31, 2020 @10:21AM (#24008811)
>Lots of people really have no principled philosophy of free speech beyond wanting their own privileged.

And similarly, a lot of people do have a principled philosophy of free speech, but it is built upon shaky grounds that are empirically or morally dubious or otherwise.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by LMYahooTFY on Friday July 31, 2020 @02:07AM (#24006147)
I think the issue of the right wing of politics being underrepresented in "the media" is deeply convoluted, too much to so easily dismiss entirely.

If "the media" only includes Fox, MSNBC, and CNN, then it's fairly even.

If "the media" also includes Hollywood and Silicon Valley, it becomes far less popular clear.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by acituan on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:27AM (#24005652)
> Fine, but why are they so bad at weighing it against long term trust?

I want to remind the loss aversion and status quo bias. We tend to evaluate losses more important than they are, which is why for example it is hard to throw seldom used things away.

That said, why should feature removal mean automatic loss of trust? Because this feature is not important to me personally, it actually increases my trust that they can reorient their focus instead of churning man-hours on a feature just because it existed. Now I get it, it was an important feature for some people, and next day they might remove a feature that I find important, but in aggregate they clearly weighed its usage/perceived importance against removal decision.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by uluyol on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:46PM (#24013814)
Never heard the name "status quo bias" before, thanks for bringing that up.

I don't really care about this particular feature, but I do care about the trend. Why should a feature be sunset? It seems like this must be because of (a) bugs/maintenance burden or (b) a poor design or one that is mismatched with the current product direction. The fact that Google sunsets so many features and products suggests that both of these happen with high frequency. (b) is especially worrying, why can't they spend time before launching to figure out what they're going to do and commit to it? They aren't a small startup, they've got tons of resources. I'm sure they're trying, but whatever they're doing is not working, in my opinion.

For the record, I'm not a Google hater, but this is just so frustrating to watch as a user.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by acituan on Friday July 31, 2020 @05:33PM (#24014441)
I totally sympathize with the frustration, and experience that as a user too. But I would like to suggest that digital product design is usually a moving target, based on constantly changing consumer engagement, competition and other market conditions, so they have to follow a dynamic, adaptive strategy. Now, could they commit on a feature despite these, yes of course, but that too many of such commitments will have a cost to us users in terms of lack of new innovation.

I imagine this picture; a “tech-smith” is building an elaborate, complicated machinery and we as the users are watching it, clapping to it, interacting with it. Some are asking “this machine should have bells”, some go “it should have whistles”, and the techsmith wants to add and remove those based on those parameters. In reality, no one knows what the final machine should look like and no one knows how exactly they will use it. So there is a sweet spot in which unexpected changes are budgeted for so that it can change to conform better to what we want and what we find useful as we gain experience with the machine. Which means sometimes the techsmith will need to go “you know what, I’m going to take this bell away because not many are using it and it is causing me problems, and instead I’ll use the materials and energy to add these extra wheels” even after having invested a lot to that bell initially (which is laudible, because they are also fighting against their own sunken cost fallacy).

This should be familiar to software engineers; “why the requirements were not perfect before I started writing the software” doesn’t work well in real life. In reality as the engineer and the user gain more experience with the system that is gradually emerging, they acquire new participatory knowledge of that system and that causes a change in requirements, in a dynamical, reciprocal fashion. (Which is one of the reasons why waterfall processes are not as popular today for most products). I think the same goes at a higher scale, if not complexity, for these comnplicated machinery big tech builds that is used by billions of people.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by MattGaiser on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:18AM (#24005593)
Except for the majority of users, eliminating spam and unmoderated content is far higher on the priority list than maintaining relatively niche features.

Whether it be Reddit or Facebook to YouTube, people are demanding security and greater tech company control over features.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by dathinab on Friday July 31, 2020 @12:47AM (#24005766)
But if you remove spam videos from yt is it still a niche feature?

I don't need captions that often but if I do not then half of them are community provided in my experience.

This is (unintentionally) again hitting against videos with useful content, compared to this endless slew of pointless (and often content wise incorrect) click bait videos.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by root_axis on Friday July 31, 2020 @11:57AM (#24009978)
This is an HN bubble framing. The masses that enjoy YouTube don't "trust" google, YouTube is just another large entertainment platform among many, "trust" never enters the equation, its just an entertainment website.
Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by uluyol on Friday July 31, 2020 @04:51PM (#24013879)
Google has a brand, just like other companies e.g. BMW and Costco. We associate these with things like "reliable", and "cheap", and "luxury".

I think "high feature churn" will become a part of Google's brand.

Re:YouTube: Community contributions will be discontinued acr... by smart_jackal on Thursday July 30, 2020 @11:44PM (#24005442)
They are indirectly helping the community by prodding them to look for decentralized alternatives like peertube, lbry, etc. every now and then. They can't say it outright as they have to care about shareholder and corporate interests, etc. but even they know where the future lies internally!