Today I'd argue that the growing lifespan is used as an argument to make people work longer, which means in worse physical conditions. The "Work until your death" motto (the curse of people living in poverty) is not great for a healthy and attractive society. Questioning it ends up in a heated political/societal/philosophical discussion pretty quickly. And we're definitely not heading in the healthy direction: not because we don't want to shift the medical institution, but because we need a more profound society change. From a purely economical PoV, it's great that people die before around the beginning retirement, from a societal PoV it's a disaster.
You’re mistaking average for median life expectancy. People lived to older ages in the past. But lots of babies died, so the average life expectancy was way down. Add a lot of zeros to a number series and it gets pretty low.
Ancient comedy even had a stock character, sexex iratus: angry old man. Certainly there are many more very old people now, but it wasn’t something totally unknown.
The aging of people has also coincided with a decline in our physical health and diets. Strength is declining year on year: we have grip strength measures for college age students since the 1980s and it is a steady decline. Diets are worse, people are much fatter and with more health problems such as type 2 diabetes.
One of the theories of alzheimers is that it is a form of diabetes. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2769828/
Certainly it is correlated with type 2 diabetes, and with obesity in mid life. (Not in late life, but this may be because sudden weight loss is a precursor of alzheimers https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6205180/)
Have a look at this chart. Japan has one of the oldest populations in the world, and yet its alzheimers death rate is less than 6x that of the usa: https://www.worldlifeexpectancy.com/cause-of-death/alzheimer...
There is more to this than just age. Our lifestyles increasingly leave us hobbled by ailments at young ages, and the medical system patches it up and lets us live through them longer. But this expresses in much more old age morbidity than would otherwise be biologically necessary.
Overall, we observed little evidence of causal associations between glycaemia and cognition, structural brain and dementia phenotypes.
https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.07.20094110v... is the correct url
It's worth pursuing longevity science if we can help more people age this way.
We're not close to fixing this, and barring some tectonic shift in our capabilities, probably won't see substantial change within our lifetimes. But to take the stance that death and aging are acceptable seems so medieval to me.
I wish I had more time to pull up references for you, but I believe that the answer to your question is "yes" -- extending people's life through intervention usually gives people more years of quality life and usually has little effect on the number of years of poor quality life.
The breakthrough here is in a diagnostic test for Alzheimer's. You are making a generalization based on the assumption that this information will ultimately extend life rather than improve the quality of life. For jurisdictions that allow medical assistance with dying, this information can plausibly result in the opposite effect.
What's the proposal here? That we retire for ages 25-50, and then (re)enter the workforce to pay society back?
We have a few factors that have greatly attributed to this increase in life and increase in mental illnesses: decrease in tobacco (specifically smoking) use, increase in processed food eating, increase in life sustaining medicines, decrease in overall activity.
Tobacco: on one hand we know that smoking raises chances of having a shorter life span as it really accelerates cellular inflammation and deterioration. (1) On the other the stimulant aspect of nicotine helps the brain continue to stay active and helps resist atrophy. Personally, I notice more and more people I interact with on antidepressants. My parents and grandparents generations probably suffered the same levels of depression (more or less) but moderated this with smoking.
Processed Foods: Modern processed foods started to flood grocery stores after the Second World War and became the staples of the American diet. Natural fats were replaced with unnatural and chemical based preservatives were put in many goods to increase shelf life. We know empirically that these foods also (like smoking tobacco) increase all cause mortality. Alzheimer’s prevention advice typically advocates for a diet removing such items. (2)
Better Medicine & Decrease in Activity: these two factors may need no introduction but we know that the older we get the less stem cells we have and the worse our cellular health is overall. Moderate Exercise helps slow the death of such cells. (3) Again, this is circumstantial, but all of the people I personally know with Alzheimer’s and other amyloid plaque based diseases did not lead active lifestyles and I would define their lifestyles as quite sedentary.
(1) https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4098701/
(2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alzheimer's#Epidemiology
(3) https://www.google.com/amp/s/time.com/4776345/exercise-aging...
I have the feeling that our modern medical obsession with keeping the body alive for so long is leading to negative outcomes. The rate of Alzheimer's diagnoses increases dramatically after about age 70[1]. In the US, we began to see the average life expectancy increase past 70 in the 1950s, and is now approaching 80[2]. As a result, I think the current crop of people who are alive are among the first to see the effects of truly advanced age. Prior to the 1950s, longer life was always seen as a good thing: you had more time to enjoy relative good health. Since few people lived into their 70s and beyond, we didn't see the "bad things" coming. Now that people are living into their 70s and beyond, we start to see the horrible effects of advanced age. So the question, which again I don't put forward with much conviction: is continuing to put forward the preservation of life worth it given the extreme decline in quality of life that we see past the age of 70? The gut answer is "obviously yes," but I think we are the first people to have to truly grapple with this question, as we watch our elders mentally fall to pieces while their bodies chug along. Is that gut answer just the result of centuries of trying to get past year 70? Now that we're past it, should we re-evaluate? I have a very close relative in his late 60s going through Alzheimer's right now. Would it truly be worse if he had passed away a couple years ago?
I don't know.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alzheimer's#Epidemiology
[2] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/life...