The CA tax is waived in just a few cases. For example, some types of corporations (not LLCs) are exempt in the first year, and an LLC that is dissolved before the first year and meets other requirements may also be exempt.
Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer.
Reference: http://www.ftb.ca.gov/FORMS/misc/1063.pdf
(Also, we're lucky to have contributors like grellas in the HN community. Thanks.)
The franchise tax for foreign corporations is heavily dependent on having a physical nexus to California, such as offices, employees, or equipment located within California borders. For example, registering as a Nevada company but headquartering in Santa Monica would result in the imposition of a franchise tax. While this situation is quite common, it usually has the nasty side effect of subjecting the business to nasty tax penalties for not paying franchise taxes they thought did not apply.
The franchise tax is waived for domestic S-Corporations in their first year of existence, unless they are profitable. LLCs are required to pay the franchise tax whether or not they dissolve in the first year unless they were never a going concern (i.o.w., they never actually did any business).
I believe that at least at one time (early '90s, when I got this information from my corporations professor in law school--maybe it is different now), Delaware was basically a rocket docket for complex corporation cases, such as shareholder lawsuits against large public companies. That was one of the attractions of them for large public companies, which might be worth adding to your FAQ. Who wants their cool merger delayed by many years over a suit from grumpy shareholders?
http://techrights.org/2009/05/02/microsoft-evading-tax-irela...
(I couldn't find the original, less biased account, but it's been well documented)
My limited company has cost about £50 in administration and set-up fees so far. But the cost of learning enough stuff not to get myself in trouble has probably been tens of hours of otherwise billable time, plus the ever present risk of doing something wrong.
The problem is that it can be hard to know what is actually difficult, and what is easy but just expensive because not many people know how to do it. It would be nice if somewhere there was a definitive guide to what is worth doing yourself for any given hourly rate.
E.g. if your time is worth £50/hr then doing your own company set up is worth it, but you should hand off pay roll taxes to a professional. If your time is worth £100 an hour, then you should do these three things to cut cost a little, then outsource the rest.
There is an incredibly simple tax calculator at (http://www.corp.delaware.gov/frtaxcalc.shtml) that makes it obvious that there are two alternative methods of calculation with vastly different outcomes in terms of tax liability.
If you're going to bypass using a lawyer or tax advisor, you need to do your homework. Franchise tax for a C Corp with, say, 10MM shares at no par value and no assets should be about $150.
In general, many/most "startups" don't need to incorporate until one of a handful of triggers fire, such incoming investment, upside valuation event on the horizon, tax reasons, launch to the public, especially if the project/site/app is risky in terms of liability, some others.
Like many other real options (the option to incorporate or not, then where, in this case), it's often better not to exercise them early (except for the special reasons that mean otherwise).
As for legal issues - contracts are handled internationally all the time with ease. But liability issues vary dramatically from state to state and even more from country to country.
For a start up, unless the nature of the business is very liability intense, I would focus on the tax issues. As this article has shown, tax can be really, really expensive.
As a lawyer, I would have to say that you should do it by the book and dissolve the entity. I have, however, had a variety of clients over the years who left a Delaware corporation to die without dissolving it and they have not had trailing personal liabilities as a result of the accrued corporate franchise taxes (of course, it is a different matter if the corporation earned a net profit and has an obligation to file income taxes - in that case, failure to file can cause serious problems for the corporation and for its management).
The $89K tax bill is typical of any Delaware corporation that has large numbers of authorized shares, even with a low par value. This often proves a shock to unsuspecting founders who file a do-it-yourself entity without understanding the issues. However, in almost all cases involving an early stage startup, you can deal with this easily by using the alternative valuation method tied to value of assets in the company. Use of the alternative method usually reduces the franchise tax to a very low level. It is easy to find out how to use the alternative method (forms and instructions are available online through the Delaware Secretary of State).
It seems that you needed to set up the entity in order to try to manage the issues with your co-founder and so the choice to set up a corporation was not really a mistake. The choice to set it up in Delaware for a simple situation can be a mistake, in my judgment, but I am probably in the minority among startup lawyers on this issue in believing that a home-state incorporation in the interests of keeping things simple can be and often is the best choice for founders (see http://grellas.com/faq_business_startup_002.html). It is no disgrace for a Silicon Valley startup to incorporate in California, even for a public company (no less than Apple itself is a California corporation). Had you done a home-state incorporation, you would have avoided the hassles with the $89K tax bill, as most states besides Delaware states have a fixed, low amount that you pay every year as a minimum franchise tax (in California, $800).
Incorporation is definitely not for everyone. When and if to incorporate can be tricky questions. I also have outlined a few of the factors to guide that decision as well (http://grellas.com/faq_business_startup_007.html).
There are a good number of early-stage startups that really can't easily afford professional fees and so the answer is not to use a lawyer in all cases to incorporate. But, even if you can't afford a lawyer, it is always worth consulting with one for strategic advice on incorporating before you do so. Such a first consultation is dirt cheap in most cases, and sometimes free. The modest amount paid is well worth it just to be alerted to the main issues and pitfalls involved in setting up an entity. Thus, while it was probably not a mistake in itself to set up your corporation, it likely was a big mistake to do so without some guidance of this type (I had made this comment in connection with your original piece as well - http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1924719).
Sorry to hear about the business failure. I know the HN community often stresses what a valuable learning experience this can be but there is no denying that it is a very painful affair by any measure.