News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zoom Security Exploit: Cracking private meeting passwords by ziddoap on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @01:49PM (#23989591)
If a website stores passwords in cleartext instead of hashes, would you have the same response?

This isn't fancy stuff. This doesn't require tens of thousands of dollars in code-audits or pentests to come to light. It's literally the absolute basics of password management. There should be no need to "convince a PM".

Rate limiting, not silently truncating passwords, not setting an extremely low and arbitrary maximum on password length... All of this stuff is as basic as hashing a password.

Re:Zoom Security Exploit: Cracking private meeting passwords by nitrogen on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @05:27PM (#23991767)
I'm saying I've been in exactly that position in many companies. Spent all of my social capital to get password hashes fixed, or a hacked DB audited, or circuit breakers, or rate limits, alerts, admin and monitoring tools, etc. It's really easy to preach here on HN. Saying it's an uphill battle "out there" is a drastic understatement.
Re:Zoom Security Exploit: Cracking private meeting passwords by ziddoap on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @06:09PM (#23992133)
I get where you're coming from, I do these types of engagements often. I just wanted to highlight the difference between "Please spend $25,000 on this pentest engagement" and "Don't set a maximum password length of 10" or "Don't set the default password to be 6 digits".

One is an investment and requires convincing a PM or C-Suite. The other two are some of the most basic concepts possible (literally first semester, if not first week of CS) in the design of anything that has to do with a password.

Re:Zoom Security Exploit: Cracking private meeting passwords by nitrogen on Wednesday July 29, 2020 @06:30PM (#23992299)
The other two are some of the most basic concepts possible (literally first semester, if not first week of CS) in the design of anything that has to do with a password.

There are still ways this can fail: e.g. tech lead on a team full of good but uninformed bootcamp devs with an absentee manager and a domineering PM, run as a democracy when only a minority have (formal or self-taught) CS education. If the PM doesn't like your recommendation they'll get one of the bootcampers to do a crappy job without telling you.