News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by modeless on Friday April 01, 2011 @02:44PM (#2397467)
The problem is that 24 FPS is now part of the Hollywood "look". 24 FPS is associated with high quality high budget productions in people's minds; 60 FPS looks like a home movie or low-budget TV sitcom. It may take a while to change people's perceptions.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by seanalltogether on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:50PM (#2397733)
Sitcoms and soap operas look the way they do because of lighting. I won't disagree that 24 fps has something to do with the 'film' look, but I think camera lens, filters, and lighting affect the look of the movie more then the framerate.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by encoderer on Saturday April 02, 2011 @07:26AM (#2399710)
I'm just a layperson when it comes to film but I want to respectfully disagree with the assertion that it's all about lighting.

A friend recently picked-up an LED "3D" tv. Now, I always thought the 3D is a BS gimmick, and I still do, though I will conceed that it does work far better than I ever thought it would. Which is, not at all.

But the TV -- a samsung -- had a feature that reminds me a bit of up-converting, however it's used on every input, even 1080P from the blu ray. I googled it at the time but the gist is that it, on 2D mode, it computes deltas between frames and inserts new ones to make the image seem more fluid.

IT LOOKED LIKE TRASH!

It made everything look soap-opera or like a documentary. It messed up the depth of field. Sure, things were hyper-crisp but alarmingly so. It made it look cheap. Now, there's a setting buried in the control panel to tweak or disable that, but this is how it came from the factory, and i thought it was un-watchable.

So it's not merely lighting.

One last thought which is I actually think the perception of higher quality shots in films has a lot to do with stedicam which of course will be the same at 60fps. But that's just a guess.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by peng on Saturday April 02, 2011 @09:35AM (#2399868)
This is a straw man. Interpolated tweening frames are not the same as actual frames with new content.

It may look like trash, but--then again--so do upscaled images.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by Raphael on Saturday April 02, 2011 @11:45AM (#2400133)
His observation suggests that higher frame rate, with different content in each frame, does achieve the soap opera look. If the interpolation is advanced enough, it may be arriving at something close to what the extra frame would have been.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by encoderer on Saturday April 02, 2011 @11:42AM (#2400127)
A "straw man" ? I didn't know this was a debate. Besides, I think you missed my point: That it's not just about lighting.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by georgieporgie on Saturday April 02, 2011 @03:20PM (#2400723)
But seanalltogether never said it was just about lighting. He mentioned, "camera lens, filters, and lighting."

Your dissection of what is wrong with Samsung's interpolation had nothing whatsoever to do with seanalltogether's comment.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by encoderer on Saturday April 02, 2011 @06:46PM (#2401189)
Does Saturday bring out the debaters? What is this? "Sitcoms and soap operas look the way they do because of lighting."

Now come back at me with some word-by-word, point-by-point dissection, but i'm done, this isn't worth it.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by 9999 on Saturday April 02, 2011 @08:44PM (#2401396)
"It messed up the depth of field."

Absolutely preposterous. Depth of field is a function of lens focal length, aperture, and sensor size. There is no way that Samsung's TV could in any way effect the depth of field of the original recording. If it could, then it would be a magical motherfucking TV.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by encoderer on Sunday April 03, 2011 @05:35AM (#2402269)
You ought to watch the TV before wetting the bed over it. Go to a Best Buy and have a look.

Because as much as you clearly know about film tech more than I do, you seem to be lacking a slight amount of common sense: What's happening there is processing of a digital signal. Specifically, the TV is creating frames for you to create the illusion of smoother video. And what this effect does, is it appears to flatten the shot.

What your slashdot-worthy post overlooks is that you're speaking from your limited knowledge of film. However, in this TV, there's a feature that lets you apply this setting to just half the screen, so you can see them both, side by side, and tweak as you wish.

Just like in life, there's no amount of theoretical education than can make-up for actually being there, for actually having hands-on.

So really, save the hyperbole.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by georgieporgie on Sunday April 03, 2011 @04:07AM (#2402142)
Uh, you started a debate, then got mad at people for responding in like manner. I don't understand. Go back and reread your post, it was both confrontational and of low technical quality.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by seanalltogether on Saturday April 02, 2011 @01:32PM (#2400419)
The reason it looks like trash is not because it's a higher frame rate, it looks like trash because it's removing natural motion blur from the image.

This actually makes it more like a video game in which discreet images are generated from the world, instead of natural film/digital sensor in which millions of photons are captured for a short duration.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by vetinari on Saturday April 02, 2011 @03:40AM (#2399477)
That's what I always used to think, until few years ago. Then a new crop of TVs came and it started to mess up the movies. The movie looked like a soap opera. It turned out, that it was caused by a feature that increases fps and inserts interpolated frames (every manufacturer calls it differently). After turning it off, the movies look like movies again.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by ciupicri on Friday April 01, 2011 @06:56PM (#2398453)
I have always asked myself why films made for television look different than the ones made for cinema. Thank you for the explanation!
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by nitrogen on Friday April 01, 2011 @11:39PM (#2399051)
Not to mention dynamic range/gamut, gamma, etc.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by electromagnetic on Friday April 01, 2011 @05:46PM (#2398223)
No, the Hollywood "look" is having tens/hundreds of millions of dollars to dump. TV looks low-budget because it is low budget. But there's a big difference between real low budget TV and simply TV.

Honestly, download an original British or Canadian drama show that doesn't get carried in the US and you'll see low budget. You'll see horrific, unwatchable direction.

I'm sorry, but give Sam Raimi a video camera with any frame rate and there's a significant chance he'll produce a blockbuster with it. I mean Oliver Stone released big budget movies using Super8!

The Hollywood "look" is genericness, because like everything else about Hollywood the studios are whole-heartedly fearful of anything that might stop someone watching a film, and in doing so turn people off watching films by lacking originality from plot to cast to cameras.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by RVK on Friday April 01, 2011 @07:04PM (#2398476)
I can't speak for Canadian TV but primetime British dramas are generally technically excellent - for instance, this year's Oscar winner for Best Director, Tom Hooper, has directed episodes of Cold Feet, EastEnders and Byker Grove.

Practically nothing that doesn't feature US accents and locations is picked up by the networks - sometimes period co-productions sneak in, as long as there's pretty frocks and no swearing.

You're missing Misfits, for instance, which is the best show on TV...

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by electromagnetic on Friday April 01, 2011 @10:00PM (#2398877)
I'm not arguing against you, I'm from the UK and there are some great shows. Skins has been technically excellent since its onset, I even got my wife (Canadian) watching it. Shameless is another example. Even shows like Hollyoaks (if it's still on) are technically great, I actually thought their quality of shooting (the clearness of camera positioning, etc.) was better than shows like 24 were managing and it's a rolling-production with 1 week to film an episode and 3 episodes airing a week.

I'm talking, look at the first episode of Primeval. It was atrocious across the board from acting to directing and 3D graphics; especially for reaching an audience of ~6.8 million. Compare that to the outstanding production qualities of Stargate Universe that only got ~2.3 million in a 5x bigger market.

My example are shows like the Canadian Flashpoint, which despite a decent budget and getting 1 million viewers can just be awful. The stories often have little reasoning behind them (shit literally just happens), the direction can often be gaudy by trying to make grand shots and just utterly failing. It often feels cold, like they're not using close-ups right. I often find this in many British shows too, comedies and traditional dramas not so much, but especially a lot of the police shows can be awful.

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by RVK on Saturday April 02, 2011 @01:58PM (#2400508)
OK, Primeval is not great - but it is well-researched: most of the monsters in the show are not known prehistoric creatures, for example, which makes sense given the long gaps in the fossil record. And the rendering is excellent - it's just that the creatures have a limited interaction with the real environment, which I guess is down to budget.

And Primeval could never approach, say, the brain-rotting stench of The Cape. SGU's poor ratings are not a badge of honour, it is a cancelled show!

As for police shows - that's pretty much a US speciality, but the really good ones are under constant threat of cancellation.

I do concede though, while I've frequently thought of British TV lately "damn, there's a lot that's good right now!", this thought has never consciously crossed my mind while watching anything Canadian. Due South, anyone?

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by GFischer on Friday April 01, 2011 @08:47PM (#2398744)
The BBC has some of the best camerawork I've ever seen. Other European productions aren't bad either (RTL comes to my mind)

Disclaimer: I'm a layman, but that's my opinion as a South American that has watched both North American and European TV (with long stays in Canada and Austria).

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by mikey_p on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:20PM (#2397620)
When I was in college and doing alot of video work (I worked at a TV station, and volunteered in the video editing labs in my free time) one of the most requested features from students doing short films was doing a 3:2 pulldown* to convert their editing video to 24 FPS and then reconvert back to 29.97, thereby giving them the appearance of having originally shot on film (at 24 fps).

Sadly we were using first generation G4s with Final Cut 1.0, so to do this for any any film over about 5 minutes meant that the render time would be measured in days, not hours.

* http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/3:2_pulldown#23pulldown

Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by LogicHoleFlaw on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:11PM (#2397569)
60fps also looks like a high-budget video game. I think that can play a role in overcoming a high-frame-rate aversion.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by lukifer on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:54PM (#2397747)
Perhaps digital animation is the proper place for the transition to take place?
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by _delirium on Friday April 01, 2011 @10:00PM (#2398878)
That's likely a big part of it, but there are also genuine aesthetic effects. In the arthouse-film world, Super 8 filmmakers can normally choose between 18 fps and 24 fps, and don't have the same baggage Hollywood does in which only one of those "looks right": both 18-fps and 24-fps films are accepted by audiences as legitimate. Yet some directors choose one, some choose the other, and some directors switch depending on the film, because 18-fps and 24-fps shooting produce different stylistic effects.
Re:James Cameron champions faster film projection rates (fro... by byw on Friday April 01, 2011 @07:07PM (#2398482)
I think the fact that Cameron, Jackson, and Lucas are using it will make the transition much easier.