Re:D3js Tree of Wittgenstein's Tractatus
by motohagiography on Sunday July 26, 2020 @09:52AM
(#23957045)
Reading all these other examples, feels like Tractatus would be a useful example tool for teaching graphs and RDF. This person's example on github was my favorite of the ones I found, as I was going to implement it like this myself, then had the sense to look it up and see if anyone else had.
Some time ago I posted about using these trees for expressing complex ontologies in a way that you can absorb them quickly, Tractatus is a great example of something impenetrable but consistent that could be used as a test for the quality and usability of a teaching ontology scheme.
His hierarchical format preceded modern software, but I wonder what his opinion might have been on tabs v. spaces. :)
Given it's a treegraph of axioms and rules, I'd wonder if there is an isomorphic or homomorphic graph that could form a syntax tree for a domain specific language or the basis of a reasoner or even a classifier. It's as if the Ted Chiang story writes itself.
Re:D3js Tree of Wittgenstein's Tractatus
by raminf on Saturday July 25, 2020 @11:31PM
(#23954208)
Great idea, but it would work much better as an educational tool if the text was also presented, with text highlighted to show the conceptual connections.
Re:D3js Tree of Wittgenstein's Tractatus
by jonjacky on Sunday July 26, 2020 @10:32AM
(#23957308)
Michele Pasin's PhiloSurfical web app did a visualization of the Tractatus in the early 2000s, using Common Lisp and Javascript. The app is revived here [1]. There is also code [2] and a writeup [3].
I recall the original version could show the text in the original German or a choice of English translations, but I can't find that in this revived version.
Some time ago I posted about using these trees for expressing complex ontologies in a way that you can absorb them quickly, Tractatus is a great example of something impenetrable but consistent that could be used as a test for the quality and usability of a teaching ontology scheme.
His hierarchical format preceded modern software, but I wonder what his opinion might have been on tabs v. spaces. :)
Given it's a treegraph of axioms and rules, I'd wonder if there is an isomorphic or homomorphic graph that could form a syntax tree for a domain specific language or the basis of a reasoner or even a classifier. It's as if the Ted Chiang story writes itself.
http://tractatus.lib.uiowa.edu/map/
https://www.masswerk.at/WebTLP/pages/map1.html
Normal text view: https://www.masswerk.at/WebTLP/
http://tractatus-online.appspot.com/Tractatus/jonathan/index...
http://tractatus.gitlab.io/
https://gitlab.com/tractatus/tractatus.gitlab.io
https://www.clarin-d.de/images/lt4dh/pdf/LT4DH10.pdf
1. http://philosurfical.open.ac.uk/tractatus/tabs.html
2. https://github.com/lambdamusic/PhiloSurfical
3. http://wittgensteinrepository.org/agora-ontos/article/view/2...
I recall the original version could show the text in the original German or a choice of English translations, but I can't find that in this revived version.
1. https://leahneukirchen.org/trivium/2008-12-06