News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by ck2 on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:08AM (#2395281)
Based on previous "investigations", basically nothing will happen to the company and things will continue as usual.

The $5-per-pill price URL Pharma set for Colcrys surprised the FDA

Find the people that were surprised and terminate them immediately. The "FDA" wasn't surprised, it was a few idiots left in charge.

What if they just do a compromise of $2.50 a pill, is that really going to help anyone when it was 10 cents previously? How about $2, or even $1 ? 1000% markup is okay when it comes to people's health? It's okay for the CEO to buy their 2nd or 3rd house with the profits while patients suffer? When as a society are we going to tell corporations they need to be responsible for all their actions and not just help a few charities to do penance afterwards.

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by qwer99 on Friday April 01, 2011 @07:25AM (#2395788)
This is just unbelievably incorrect, absurd, and just shows complete ignorance of the healthcare industry. Profits for healthcare companies are the same as those in any other industry. A quick check on Yahoo Finance will let you compare their respective financial statements. The culprit is in the endless rules and regulations that drive up costs to make the pills, preventing competitors from coming in to drive down the costs.
Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by Retric on Friday April 01, 2011 @08:17AM (#2395880)
I don't think you understood what he was saying.

In effect the FDA set a ~1 billion dollar bounty from doing 2 study's on this drug. What was not said is there are limited resources in the industry so while this company went after this fairly safe and profitable drug plenty of other companies went after other drugs and there is no incentive to research the same drug as another company. This is a land grab plain and simple and only an idiot would think a company would act any differently.

PS: And when you realize the only thing patents gained from this was higher prices you need to conciser it poor regulation. (1 study of 200 people says next to nothing about a drug regularly taken but 10's of thousands of people for hundreds of years.)

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by shpxnvz on Friday April 01, 2011 @10:56AM (#2396455)
It seemed pretty clear that in addition to the FDA he was attacking the company for behaving like a profit seeking entity (which it, of course, is). He questioned whether it is "ok" for them to charge the particular price they wanted and questioned how many homes the CEO should be able to own while there are still suffering people in the world.

We can argue that this particular bit of regulation is wonderful or evil all we want, but to think that any for-profit organization is going to act in your best interest rather than it's own, or that it's even possible to regulate a company or person into doing so, is just plain naive.

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by alexqgb on Friday April 01, 2011 @02:34PM (#2397423)
Relentless profit-seeking tendencies combined with monopolies are fundamentally toxic. Which is why we (generally) outlaw monopolies. The ones we do grant have (in theory) provisions that favor the public interest.

In other words, if your business operates a monopoly granted by the state, you DO have a special set of legal, moral, and ethical obligations that don't apply to less privileged organizations. If a protected company DOES start to behave in an anti-social fashion, opting for pure profit-maximization and short-term shareholder gains, then it's the JOB of the government to attack them, rescind their monopoly, and generally punish the hell out of them for violating the basic contract that accompanied the initial grant.

If they don't like that possibility - or realize that they're just not up to the (admittedly challenging) task of administering an public trust along side a commercial business - then they can retreat to the less complicated, less ethically demanding, and more mercenary ranks of those operating in the free market - which has it's own set of mechanisms from weeding out the truly dishonest and abusive.

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by shpxnvz on Friday April 01, 2011 @04:58PM (#2398045)
In other words, if your business operates a monopoly granted by the state, you DO have a special set of legal, moral, and ethical obligations that don't apply to less privileged organizations.

If there were such obligations, they would be made specific in the regulation. It's pointless to set the rules for the game and then get upset when they are followed. I personally find the price gouging distasteful as well, but those are my ethical beliefs and they in no way compel the behavior of others.

Hence my claim that the regulations should be the subject of the discussion, not whether some particular company is acting in accordance with our personal views.

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by Alex3917 on Friday April 01, 2011 @10:27AM (#2396345)
"It's okay for the CEO to buy their 2nd or 3rd house with the profits while patients suffer?"

To be fair, patients can continue to take the drug in it's herbal supplement form the same way people have been taking it forever. Or they can take tart cherry juice, which also works; a one month subscription for home delivery of tart cherry juice is only $60 on cheribundi.com

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by _emice on Friday April 01, 2011 @02:57PM (#2397528)
They all look alike to me, tart cherry juice and colchicine must work just the same! This struck a chord with me, it is like saying MySQL and Ruby are both used to make websites, why not replace one with the other?

The few times I have had to take colchicine, I had to titrate my dose up, taking two 0.6mg pills to start and then 1 every hour, at least until the diarrhea and abdominal pain sets in. My gut has continued to hurt for months after the fact. The risk of organ damage, especially the kidneys, is serious. So it is important to watch exactly how much your taking so that you take the absolute minimum needed, usually around 3mg total for me. I don't think controlled upping of dosages is even possible with the herbal supplement version.

The relief it brings within 24 hours, after being 2 weeks into a devastating gout attack, is unbelievable. It is the difference between laying frozen in severe pain, unable to so much as twitch for fear of pain that is not unlike being stabbed. Try not moving the "stabbed" appendage under penalty of being stabbed harder additional times the moment you do. Severe, quivering pain is the result of this feedback loop, as you struggle to stay calm and limit movement. It is torture and rates very high on the official pain scale.

I have also drank lots of tart cherry juice, which may work as prophylactic but doesn't seem to bring attacks under control. It has anti-inflammatory properties similar ibuprofen (it is a COX inhibitor), and may help alkalize the body a bit, but this is not the mechanism colchicine works by, and the effect is not the same. This is common knowledge for anyone having to deal with gout. I don't drink cherry juice anymore, but I do make fresh lemonade to help alkalize my blood and take regular inexpensive COX inhibitors to control inflammation when needed.

I'm not saying cherry juice is bad, just expensive and not comparable to colchicine. I would not buy from cheribundi and just get 100% tart cherry concentrate in syrup form. The concentrate does not have added sugar, which has a significant acid forming effect that can scuttle the benefit.

The bottom line is Colchicine, which is now sold exclusively under the name Colcrys, has been written about since 1500BC. Ben Franklin brought it over here from France to deal with his own ailments. There is a long history behind the stuff and the studies required to monopolize the drug haven't changed the way it is used or made it any safer. Suggesting alternative treatments is a red herring, nothing else works quite like it.

This reminds me of Wikipedia of all things. I recently read somewhere about how Wikipedia had put all the door to door encyclopedia salesmen out of business. Families would often buy just a couple volumes because they were hard to afford, but now we have Wikipedia which is more expansive and comprehensive than what was offered then. Sure fewer $ are being made and that is a hit to the economy, but this shows that using $ earned as the the only measure of value is sketchy, particularly when competition is diminished through regulatory or other means.

The inverse has happened here with colchicine, introducing scarcity so $ can be generated. All the while providing diminished value due to the drug being financially out of reach for many, without any additional benefit to those able to afford it.

Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by meric on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:15AM (#2395301)
All too true. By the time they do something about it the exclusivity would've ended and the price of the drug dropping back to normal.
Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by zaidf on Friday April 01, 2011 @03:19AM (#2395311)
I'm still optimistic. For some reason, while the general exclusive is for 3 years, for my condition(Familial Mediterranean Fever) it is 7 years. Yikes.
Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by asmithmd1 on Friday April 01, 2011 @07:49AM (#2395832)
What does that even mean? The pharmacist is going to ask you why you are taking the drug to decide if they can give you the generic version or not?
Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by sp332 on Friday April 01, 2011 @09:30AM (#2396085)
Yes. The FDA regulates (among other things) "indications" for drugs. For example, you can't represent that a drug is effective at treating something without FDA approval. So, currently, only one company can make this pill, and even then they can only sell it for a specific list of diseases. After some time, other companies will be able to make the pill and sell it for the same list of diseases, except this one. The FDA has the power to regulate the claims made by various companies, so this was probably a compromise that was part of a larger deal.
Re:This pill used to cost me 10c/pill, now it's $5/pill. I t... by randallsquared on Friday April 01, 2011 @08:53AM (#2395981)
Surely there will be two different retail names for it. OldDrug X and OldDrug XLI, or whatever.