News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by Kednicma on Friday July 24, 2020 @01:43PM (#23942350)
Let me sharpen the dilemma: Are some people better than others, or not?
Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by recursivedoubts on Friday July 24, 2020 @01:51PM (#23942455)
Unfortunately that makes the dilemma less clear, although more emotionally powerful. Good rhetoric, bad dialectic.
[dead]
Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by recursivedoubts on Friday July 24, 2020 @02:43PM (#23943092)
Ad hominems are not useful dialectically either.

Your emotionalism is leading you away from the truth, which will lead to bad reasoning and, therefore, bad outcomes.

Edit:

"Look, the fact is that meritocratic beliefs eventually boil down to eugenics and race realism at some point."

This is one place, among many, where your reasoning is faulty. This may be a limiting case of meritocracy (I am not committing to that, but I can see the argument). But I am not arguing for pure meritocracy. Rather I am arguing for giving both luck and merit proportional consideration, and varying that proportion over success curves. This is more complex than the manichean viewpoint you are arguing, but I believe it conforms with reality more closely.

I oppose both eugenics as well as racial reasoning (race is such a broad genetic category as to be meaningless in most discussions) on both logical and religious grounds.

Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by mistermann on Friday July 24, 2020 @05:02PM (#23944404)
> In particular, could you show how my reasoning is faulty?

I'll give two:

- you believe things to be true that you have no way of knowing are true.

- you seem to believe you can predict the future.

Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by dsnr on Friday July 24, 2020 @02:01PM (#23942584)
If by „better“ you mean better cognitive abilities, then yes, some people ar better in this regard.
Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by Kednicma on Friday July 24, 2020 @02:31PM (#23942951)
Okay, could you show it? In particular, while you can point to something like the g-factor, can you show that the g-factor exists? It is currently completely hypothetical that such differences exist.

For a good example of evidence, look at the Flynn effect. One way to read the effect is that people dramatically got smarter over the past century, but...how? What exactly actually changed? The biggest correlate is education, suggesting that the quality of schooling is far more important than any innate ability.

Edit: Ah, you believe in IQ. I presume that you won't simply let me win the argument just because of my high IQ, though? So IQ isn't everything. More importantly, though, note that IQ also correlates with sex and skin color, but a cursory look at the genes says that that correlation must be spurious. So indeed what we see is that IQ actually correlates with quality of education, which then goes on to correlate with both sex and skin color thanks to the sexism and racism inherent in our educational system.

Re:A belief in meritocracy is not only false: it’s bad for you by dsnr on Friday July 24, 2020 @02:39PM (#23943042)
The fact that there has been measured an increase in average IQ of the world population, doesn‘t mean that the differences between individuals don‘t exist. Look up some studies and you will see that there are huge differences in IQ, and intelligence is the number one predictor of an individual‘s success.