News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by ig1 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @04:52AM (#23925457)
In terms of medical data the amount of leakage is somewhat limited by the nature of DNA, e.g because you get a random mix you can't conclude anything about parents, etc medical status.

By far the biggest practical knock-on effect is if you match someone who's doesn't know their parentage (adoption/illegitimate children/etc) who can figure out their parentage as a result of that match.

Familial DNA crime searches are probably the next biggest, but they're still very rare at the moment and many of the DNA platforms don't allow them (GEDMatch was one of the few that do).

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by dwighttk on Thursday July 23, 2020 @07:16AM (#23926114)
> and many of the DNA platforms don't allow them

I’m assuming that the stolen information doesn’t have this limitation.

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by dragonwriter on Thursday July 23, 2020 @09:28AM (#23927142)
> I’m assuming that the stolen information doesn’t have this limitation

Stolen information has provenance problems that make it difficult to use as evidence of any crime other than theft itself in any system with even rudimentary due process protections and presumption of innocence.

I mean, it's hardly as if you are going to be able to get the people who handled the data between the people who had it lawfully and the time it got to the police on the stand to attest to it's integrity.

(That doesn't prevent its use in investigations, but it means that it would only lead to convictions in a contested case where the police used it to locate proof that was legally sufficient without the use of the DNA as evidence.)

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by jjoonathan on Thursday July 23, 2020 @09:31AM (#23927164)
Law enforcement is trained in information laundering and courts consider it a legitimate tactic.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by throwaway2048 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @02:30PM (#23930568)
Its easy to use this information to search for suspects, but not bring it up in court once you find other evidence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by ig1 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @07:52AM (#23926325)
Most law enforcement typically use a handful of commercial agencies (like Parabon NanoLabs, etc) for these kind of searches, it seems highly unlikely that any of them would risk using illegally obtained data because it would put their entire business at risk.

(obviously if your threat model includes intelligence agencies, etc. then your calculus might be different)

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by monadic2 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @01:19PM (#23929696)
Honestly all I see is upside for the business.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by jacquesm on Thursday July 23, 2020 @09:21AM (#23927062)
And of course law enforcement has never before used illegally obtained evidence to construct a new trail that was plausible:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parallel_construction

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by ig1 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @12:23PM (#23929006)
It's not about law enforcement using the data, it's about the viability of running a business that provides illegal hacking services for law enforcement.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by JetSpiegel on Wednesday August 05, 2020 @07:27PM (#24066733)
Works for Hacking Team and NSO.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by madaxe_again on Thursday July 23, 2020 @07:30AM (#23926190)
I’m cackling at the idea of GDPR compliant data thieves. “This data is only to be used for the purposes of: anything. The data controller is: whoever.”
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by haihaibye on Thursday July 23, 2020 @05:42AM (#23925660)
If a child has 2 copies of a variant you know both parents have at least 1 copy.

You know what parent a male's X and Y came from.

You can use phasing and linkage to reconstruct parental haplotypes.

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by thaumasiotes on Thursday July 23, 2020 @06:43AM (#23925949)
> You know what parent a male's X and Y came from.

You can identify which parent any chromosome came from. They're all marked, and the same genetics may do sharply different things depending on whether it was inherited from the father or the mother.

Inability to recover this data has nothing to do with "the nature of DNA" -- the data is very much present in the DNA. It's unrecoverable because when we summarize DNA, we leave it out.

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by drdeca on Thursday July 23, 2020 @12:56PM (#23929386)
> You can identify which parent any chromosome came from. They're all marked, and the same genetics may do sharply different things depending on whether it was inherited from the father or the mother.

I did not know this. This sounds interesting! Can you provide any google search terms (or a link) where I can read more about this? (e.g. a name of what they are marked with) This surprises me. I thought that there was a process by which portions of the two copies of a chromosome get switched between the two. Is that right? How does that fit together with these markings?

(If these questions would be answered by searching for whatever search term or reading whatever link you provide, I would consider providing said search term or link to be answering these questions)

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by thaumasiotes on Thursday July 23, 2020 @01:19PM (#23929694)
> Can you provide any google search terms (or a link) where I can read more about this? (e.g. a name of what they are marked with)

The term I know related to this is "methylation". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DNA_methylation . I don't know all that much about it; I would not want to claim that methylation is the only such mechanism, or that this is the only information expressed by DNA methylation.

> I thought that there was a process by which portions of the two copies of a chromosome get switched between the two. Is that right? How does that fit together with these markings?

Yes, that's correct. "Crossing over" does not occur during ordinary cell division ("mitosis"), in which one of your cells divides into two of your cells -- your chromosomes should stay the same (except for new mutations) through your life.

But it does occur during meiosis, the process by which one of your cells divides into four sperm or four eggs (these are "gametes", and in terms of chromosome content they are only half-cells, not full cells). Your children's chromosomes may therefore differ from yours.

So the interaction between parental marking and crossing over would broadly look like:

1. You are going to produce four gametes.

2. Remove the parental marking (indicating the sex of the gamete's grandparent) from the cell undergoing meiosis.

3. Do the crossing over.

4. Apply parental marking indicating your own sex (the gamete's parent, rather than grandparent).

5. Divide into four cells.

I don't actually know where the unmarking and remarking occur in the process; maybe reality is more like 2435, or 3254. But both crossing over and applying correct parental marking are part of meiosis -- since meiosis produces a cell that belongs to your child rather than a cell that belongs to you, it's easy to know what kind of marking should be applied.

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by drdeca on Friday July 24, 2020 @11:56PM (#23946738)
Ahhh, cool, thank you! That makes sense now, thanks!
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by ig1 on Thursday July 23, 2020 @07:57AM (#23926354)
Yes, but there's generally not much medical data you can infer from those.

You're right that you could reconstruct parental haplotypes, but that reveals a fairly limited amount of data, typically you'll share haplotypes with many millions of people.

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by mberger on Thursday July 23, 2020 @08:08AM (#23926438)
Yes, but there's generally not much medical data you can infer from those.

Not yet.

Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by Dumblydorr on Thursday July 23, 2020 @08:56AM (#23926821)
What would insurance companies do with the data though? If they knew you were predisposed to obesity and cancer due to this data, would they be kind enough to ignore that info?
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 23, 2020 @08:57AM (#23926834)
Federal law prohibits health insurers from using DNA data for underwriting and pricing.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by astura on Thursday July 23, 2020 @09:15AM (#23927003)
And if it didn't the insurance companies could just demand a dna test before underwriting any policies.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by kube-system on Thursday July 23, 2020 @12:21PM (#23928991)
If we’re hypothetically considering what they could do if they weren’t one of the most regulated industries, they have exponentially better options for limiting their risk than requesting DNA.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 23, 2020 @09:31AM (#23927163)
It would be a sound business decision (who takes on unnecessary risk or costs willingly?), and yet another reason to support universal healthcare.
Re:Breach exposed more than one million DNA profiles on a ma... by stepstop on Thursday July 23, 2020 @08:12AM (#23926456)
It’s not only medical data that’s of concern, but also nation states Could try to use the data to identify embedded foreign agents/spies implanted in their country. Those are the ones without diplomatic cover