Re:Elo sucks – better multiplayer rating systems for smaller...
by mlyle on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @05:29PM
(#23911212)
It doesn't make sense as part of a rating system, but it may be good for community. Chess is pretty toxic with people refusing to play lower rated people, sometimes, because of danger to rating. Also, people with very low ratings are more likely to have their rating not represent their true ability (my son lost a game against a girl rated 300 that played a very accurate 1400-ish looking game against him... turns out she hadn't been in a rated game for 3 years despite being very active with her local chess club for that time; meanwhile it takes two tournaments or more to get those rating points back).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Elo sucks – better multiplayer rating systems for smaller...
by cortesoft on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @09:25PM
(#23912992)
This is why you have two rating systems; one you show to people and is geared towards making players happy, and one that is used internally to create fair matches.
Re:Elo sucks – better multiplayer rating systems for smaller...
by edaemon on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @05:55PM
(#23911416)
It seems reasonable to cap the number of points you can lose, but it strikes me as odd that you'd lose fewer points in an upset than in an even match-up.
Re:Elo sucks – better multiplayer rating systems for smaller...
by mlyle on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @07:51PM
(#23912217)
Agreed on that point.
A better mechanism, IMO, even though it doesn't catch all the cases: provisional ratings, where you don't affect other peoples' ratings much for the first n games (and where your rating moves faster, too).
Effectively it acknowledges you have less of a prior when you've played few games.