Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by lm28469 on Monday July 20, 2020 @07:35AM
(#23896785)
> Being in a global pandemic is arguably much more stressful than work.
Depends where you live and on your lifestyle. I know that for me and close friends it actually has the opposite effect, I'm much more chill than before covid and I doubt we're the only ones.
Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by christophilus on Monday July 20, 2020 @07:56AM
(#23896879)
Most likely, pregnant women who aren’t working can rest more. They can sit when the want, go to the restroom when the want, etc. These are things that take a cumulative toll when working / add a cumulative benefit when not.
Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by bananaface on Monday July 20, 2020 @09:25AM
(#23897548)
It sounds appealing as an explanation, but so does the general stress argument. I'm skeptical of concrete explanations in general.
Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by emn13 on Monday July 20, 2020 @05:24PM
(#23902070)
The stress of fearing a pandemic is perhaps quite different from the everyday stresses of work. We may find them both severe - even the fear much worse; but it's still conceivable the everyday stresses are worse specifically to the extent they influence birth weight. Perhaps everyday stress is more immediate; perhaps it's more physical; or perhaps it's more social - or perhaps we're grasping at straws and it's something else entirely.
In any case; just because a pandemic is stressful doesn't necessarily mean that stress that matters here isn't lower. All those various strains don't affect us in the same way.
Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by bananaface on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @04:38AM
(#23905270)
It could also be that they are sleeping more, which people will try and shoehorn into: "that's a form of stress!" Stress is a buzzword, I'm wary of manhandling the theory too much as counterpoints come up, especially if it involves playing with semantics.
Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by emn13 on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @06:50AM
(#23905828)
Exactly; stress isn't one clearly defined thing, and the forms do matter: therefore the focus on overall stress isn't that useful.
Re:Hospitals see significant drop in premature births during...
by bananaface on Tuesday July 21, 2020 @07:18AM
(#23905967)
It's worse than that: "it's stress" is a lexical tautology. By definition anything that causes a miscarriage was a stressor.
A good piece of general evidence I once heard against this is: premature births & miscarriages did not increase in London during The Blitz (I think they may have even reduced). There's a big narrative around stress and all of its wild short-term health implications, but I'm not convinced it translates into reality. It's not easy to measure.