Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @02:56PM
(#2388653)
I agree 1000% that people compartmentalize based on functionality, which is why Google shouldn't be afraid of Facebook on search (that and Facebook not having search and search being difficult).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by malloreon on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:07PM
(#2388694)
What if I'm facebook and I'm processing >500M "likes" a day?
Could I create a reasonable search engine only using URLs people have "liked" and weight search results based on number of likes and whether people in my friends list have liked it?
Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by timr on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:21PM
(#2388763)
That'll work great if you're searching for the latest hamster-on-a-piano video. It might not work quite so well if you're searching for something with substance. Despite the hype, most people aren't especially good at uncovering original content.
Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by gumbo on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:43PM
(#2388841)
A totaly agree, people don't usualy share much stufs on facebook?
Have you seens around a link to a Hadoop tutorial in your news feed yet?
Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by StavrosK on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:56PM
(#2388902)
I think that sharing that sort of thing will be in a more targeted way, via e.g. yourpane.com. I never share links that don't appeal to everyone on Twitter or Facebook, but I send things to specific friends all the time.
Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by MatthewPhillips on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @03:20PM
(#2388761)
You could, but I doubt many would use it. I agree with the above, that people compartmentalize, and they see Facebook as a place to see pictures of their friends and play games. They see Google as place to look up information.
There already is a very good search on Facebook and the fact that it is powered by Bing is unknown and irrelevant to 95% of the people. However it hasn't made a dent in search, so you have to seriously ask why that is. If you believe in Facebook as a search engine (I don't), the only real answer is because it's not powered by Likes. But to believe that, you have to believe that people have a major affinity for Likes, enough to throw away their old search habits in favor of it.
Re:With +1, Google Search Goes Truly Social — As Do Google Ads
by cft on Wednesday March 30, 2011 @06:49PM
(#2389576)
I would see the fact that the walled Facebook encompasses more and more of previously searchable content as a bigger threat to Google search. Facebook that cannot be scraped for content competes for the pageviews share with the independent searchable sites, so there's less left for Google to search.