Did the majority of people paying for AOL really pay for it for access to AOL services, rather than thinking of it mostly as an Internet (and email) service provider, that just happened to offer some value-added gated-community-portal services? Were those portal services an actual selling point?
Maybe a better example is paying in phone minutes to dial into a BBS. Sure, that money isn't going to the BBS (unless it's on a 900 number)—but users are still being charged by the minute to be there, so they're constantly doing an ROI calculation and only staying if they're getting real value out of the place.
Yes, they really did. Before the web grew, AOL had far more content in its services. There were discussions, communities, even early MMORPGs. They devolved into an ISP and email later.
I'm not denying that the economics of the internet are evolving, it just irks me our industry comes full circle to the same stuff we hashed through decades ago and people act like it is a new phenomenon.