If China's BSL-4 virus laboratory was set off in the countryside in a "little" town of 50,000 and the outbreak started there, the paper's argument would be way more compelling. If we could even reliably trace a "patient zero" to a neighborhood near the WIV, then, again, maybe. But we can't. All we can say for sure is that a dangerous global pandemic caused by a novel coronavirus started in a huge metro area (or its surrounding province) that's also the site of a BSL-4 lab specifically set up to study dangerous global pandemics caused by novel coronaviruses. The paper's conclusion is, well, pretty much the paper equivalent of archly intoning "that would sure be a weird, ironic coincidence" and staring meaningfully into the camera. I mean, yes, it would be, but that's a little short of a slam dunk.
If you read the actual paper, what they say is:
"These meet the criteria of means, timing, agent and place in this reconstructed historical aetiology to produce sufficient confidence in the account to reverse the burden of proof. Henceforth, those who would maintain that the Covid-19 pandemic arose from zoonotic transfer need to explain precisely why this more parsimonious account is wrong before asserting that their evidence is persuasive"
ie. Basically, there are enough red-flags here that the burden-of-proof is to show that it isn't artificial rather than that it is.
...and you could hear that argument.
On the other hand, it's not really rigorous.
You can't go and say, hey, look, I invented an EM drive; rather than proving that it generates thrust without any emissions by isolating it and measuring it, the burden of proof is on everyone else to "prove why this more parsimonious account is wrong before asserting that their evidence is persuasive".
Ie. Before you go and measure anything, first you have to come tell us why we're wrong.
Now, rather than putting the EM drive in an isolated box and measuring the thrust it produces, you have 50 different people who have to go out and prove that EM drives are impossible before anyone actually goes and measures anything.
See any problems here?
I mean, you could argue it either way, but it doesn't convince me.
While I agree that the paper lays out some interesting points, they're wide open to attack on the conclusion they draw from them.
This, in particular:
"We refute pre-emptively objection that this methodology does not result in absolute proof by observing that to make such a statement is to misunderstand scientific logic. The longer the chain of causation of individual findings that is shown, especially converging from different disciplines, the greater the confidence in the whole."
Sure.
"We posit that the evidence below attains a high level of confidence."
Yup, that's what they've done here. They posit which means, in this case, arbitrarily assert without proof that it is the case that there is a high level of confidence here.
They just haven't shown that in a compelling way imo.
Personally I think the circumstantial evidence in this case is fairly strong. But I’m hardly impartial.
No, they haven't.
The evidence is circumstantial.
You can choose to believe what you want to believe; but the fact is that they have not proved anything.
That's the problem with the paper. Actually read the darn thing.
I'm 100% sympathetic to what they're saying here and I do hear their arguments, but this paper doesn't prove it.
> Personally I think...
You know the quote. "The good thing about science is that it's true whether or not you believe in it."
If it comes down to "well, I think that's high confidence" and someone else is just like "well i don't" as a personal opinion ("...But I’m hardly impartial..."), then, don't you think, maybe they haven't really done a great job here?
The things written down in this paper are true whether or not you agree that they lead to the conclusion that the virus was engineered (obviously, exclude their conclusions).
Maybe using proof was the wrong word.
You're also just making a straight up false claim anyway, since most of the virus samples discussed in their research come from distant regions (500+ miles away).