News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by chrisseaton on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:47PM (#23874682)
Isn't it the same funding per student?

The money is diverted from the public schools to the charter schools... because the student has moved from a public school to a charter school.

Or is that wrong?

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by MereInterest on Friday July 17, 2020 @03:58PM (#23874800)
Irrelevant. Plan a building for 2000 students. Figure out the best location, heating/cooling, building maintenance schedules, etc. Merge districts so that you can offer niche courses for advanced students. Then have the funding cut by 50%, because 1000 of the students go to charter schools. The fixed costs were planned out for the next 20 years, until the rug was pulled out from under schools. Instead, you get fewer teachers, larger class sizes, lower supply budgets, since those are the costs that can be reduced over a short time scale.

I'm fine with properly managed charter schools. However, opting out of public education does not entitle you to defund public education.

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by chrisseaton on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:12PM (#23874954)
Aren't these charter schools free and open to everyone?

What's the problem? If people don't want to send their children to your public schools then take a look at why.

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by vkou on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:37PM (#23875225)
No, they aren't, because they expel problem students, into the public system. Even if admissions are lottery-based, expulsions are not.

Imagine two groceries. One that has to, by law, serve every kind of customer, and one that is allowed to throw out shoplifters, drunks, people high-out-of-their-minds-on-meth, etc.

Which one of these will provide better groceries for lower prices?

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by s1artibartfast on Friday July 17, 2020 @07:45PM (#23877393)
Don't we want better groceries for lower prices?

The question is if there is a net benefit in educational outcomes for the combined charter and public system.

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by MereInterest on Friday July 17, 2020 @08:09PM (#23877588)
Experimentally: No. Betsy Devos's implementation was tested in Detroit, and failed miserably at teaching children. Expanding it without major, major changes is irresponsible and immoral. Step 1 is a system that doesn't defund public schools in the process.
Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by s1artibartfast on Friday July 17, 2020 @09:54PM (#23878267)
can you share a link? What I have read about charter schools in NY was very positive
Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by MereInterest on Friday July 17, 2020 @10:29PM (#23878410)
Certainly. [1] gives a good overview, on how Devos pushed for more and more charter schools, without any requirement for credentials. [2] is some focus on the history of charter schools in Michigan, Devos's home state. [3] is a local news story (tracked down from some articles that reference it), going into a lawsuit about the poor performance of schools in the Detroit area, following the siphoning of funds to charter schools. The state didn't even attempt to argue that the schools were well-run, and instead argued that "there is no fundamental right to literacy".

Maybe I could see charter schools as a reasonable option in some cases. With Betsy Devos at the helm, they should be fought at every turn.

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2016/12/...

[2] https://www.michiganadvance.com/2019/02/12/how-25-years-of-c...

[3] https://web.archive.org/web/20170217112809/https://www.fox2d...

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by s1artibartfast on Monday July 20, 2020 @03:34PM (#23901098)
I wanted to circle back and say thanks for providing the links.

The wapo article was garbage (really, 3 sentences?) , but I found the michigan advance ariccle informative. I still don't agree with your conclusions, but now know there is a questionable track record in Detroit. I think the connection between Devos and charters and her influences is overstated, as they existed in numerous states long before she held any federal positions.

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by MereInterest on Wednesday July 22, 2020 @02:12PM (#23919882)
Thank you for the feedback. For the Washington Post article, it looks like they are silently paywalling the majority of the article. Opening it in incognito mode gave me the full article (several pages, not just a few sentences).
Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by amanaplanacanal on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:42PM (#23875286)
If they are free and open to everyone, that’s a good thing! If they just skim the good students off the top, that’s a bad thing.
Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by morelisp on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:13PM (#23874972)
First, it is wrong. There's no requirement that charter schools get paid the same per student as public schools. Even when they do, charter schools also often lean heavily on public school resources (e.g. charter schools where I grew up used our public gymnasium, theater, and library regularly).

But second, even if the funding is exactly the same, the result is that all the "cheap" i.e. wealthy students (books and technology readily available at home, familial support for their studies, financially able to engage in more expensive educational opportunities outside the classroom) end up in one school while those without these privileges, or with disabilities, end up in the other. Even if you give both the same resources the second school is going to perform worse. And under current US policy, the school that performs worse then gets even less money while the school of rich kids gets more! It's wealth consolidation, pure and simple.

Re:Teachers are ready to quit rather than put their lives at... by chrisseaton on Friday July 17, 2020 @04:21PM (#23875058)
> the result is that all the "cheap" i.e. wealthy students (books and technology readily available at home, familial support for their studies, financially able to engage in more expensive educational opportunities outside the classroom) end up in one school while those without these privileges, or with disabilities, end up in the other

I don't understand - are charter schools allowed to refuse to admit disabled students?