The money is diverted from the public schools to the charter schools... because the student has moved from a public school to a charter school.
Or is that wrong?
I'm fine with properly managed charter schools. However, opting out of public education does not entitle you to defund public education.
What's the problem? If people don't want to send their children to your public schools then take a look at why.
Imagine two groceries. One that has to, by law, serve every kind of customer, and one that is allowed to throw out shoplifters, drunks, people high-out-of-their-minds-on-meth, etc.
Which one of these will provide better groceries for lower prices?
The question is if there is a net benefit in educational outcomes for the combined charter and public system.
Maybe I could see charter schools as a reasonable option in some cases. With Betsy Devos at the helm, they should be fought at every turn.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2016/12/...
[2] https://www.michiganadvance.com/2019/02/12/how-25-years-of-c...
[3] https://web.archive.org/web/20170217112809/https://www.fox2d...
The wapo article was garbage (really, 3 sentences?) , but I found the michigan advance ariccle informative. I still don't agree with your conclusions, but now know there is a questionable track record in Detroit. I think the connection between Devos and charters and her influences is overstated, as they existed in numerous states long before she held any federal positions.
But second, even if the funding is exactly the same, the result is that all the "cheap" i.e. wealthy students (books and technology readily available at home, familial support for their studies, financially able to engage in more expensive educational opportunities outside the classroom) end up in one school while those without these privileges, or with disabilities, end up in the other. Even if you give both the same resources the second school is going to perform worse. And under current US policy, the school that performs worse then gets even less money while the school of rich kids gets more! It's wealth consolidation, pure and simple.
I don't understand - are charter schools allowed to refuse to admit disabled students?