News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by x87678r on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:18PM (#23862010)
Looks mostly fine to me, maybe some are over the top but these are cherry picked examples. Most of these situations there is riot police trying to clear an area. Do what you're told. Most people are hanging around waiting for a fight to start then complain when one happens. And dont say we need more protesting, there are plenty peaceful protests around. I'm glad I'm not a cop you couldn't pay me enough to put up with that.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by wbronitsky on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:08PM (#23862626)
> Do what you're told.

Why do we all need to conform to every order from every police officer, even, and sometimes especially, when that order is unlawful?

When the police are using unlawful orders to escalate violence, and then justify that violence by asserting that one was not complying with their order, which was unlawful, or otherwise stated illegal, is that not wrong?

I do not believe that any law, or logic, supports a situation in which anyone must "do what [they are] told" in this context. This argument can be restated as "do what I say, no matter what, or die". This is pure terror enacted by the state against its population.

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by meheleventyone on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:17PM (#23862726)
It’s a jaundiced view but a lot of American society seems predicated around the idea that the person with power is correct. Whether that’s a policeman or corporate shareholders or your obviously incompetent president.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by thephyber on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:29PM (#23862864)
As someone who recently sat through jury selection, it's a remarkably common view. So many American citizens revere the badge, are willing to trust the person in uniform despite evidence to the contrary, and automatically assume the person sitting in the defendant's chair is guilty.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by stallmanite on Thursday July 16, 2020 @04:15PM (#23863347)
Based on your lucid comments in this thread I’m guessing you were not selected for the jury.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by thephyber on Thursday July 16, 2020 @06:42PM (#23864690)
Between the 2 attorneys and the judge, one of them might have been disbarred if I was allowed on a jury. I was in the jury box as a potential juror for a few days, but was challenged out.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by x87678r on Thursday July 16, 2020 @04:28PM (#23863477)
I didn't say always, but when there is riot police and they're telling you to move you should definitely do what they tell you.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by tehwebguy on Thursday July 16, 2020 @05:08PM (#23863824)
Interesting, but I think when riot police in particular are giving you an order it is probably the most important time to disobey.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by bigwavedave on Thursday July 16, 2020 @07:59PM (#23865326)
Yes, because staying put on the train tracks when you hear the train whistle is a good idea. This reminds of those "self-defense" classes my elementary school used to do- they're not martial arts, they're practical ways to keep yourself safe. Should you cross the street the second the traffic signal gives you the go-ahead without even looking up the road? Of course not. No amount of right-of-way or moral authority will restore your shattered body. So no, staying in place when you're clearly in danger and are actively being warned about this danger is a pretty stupid idea. Enjoy being a martyr though.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by tehwebguy on Friday July 17, 2020 @12:27AM (#23867032)
I expect police officers to have more options than a train that can’t stop in time or even turn left or right
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by CompanionCuuube on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:22AM (#23871501)
“This is a lighthouse. Your call.”
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by tehwebguy on Friday July 17, 2020 @11:43AM (#23871732)
This is exactly the same wrong point again. A human with a badge is not similar to a lighthouse. It’s a person with agency, when they beat, shoot, strangle or arrest another person they make a choice.

Lighthouses don’t.

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by yeetawayhn on Friday July 17, 2020 @01:14PM (#23872883)
So you've made your call, so confident in feeling you're in the right. Nice knowing you, "admiral".
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by wbronitsky on Saturday July 25, 2020 @01:10PM (#23950769)
I thought a bit about this argument here, and I just want to sum it up, so we can understand where this landed.

The sum of the final argument is “I believe that you should do whatever the gunman says, so much so that I don’t care if they kill you”, directed at a commenter here.

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by CompanionCuuube on Tuesday July 28, 2020 @11:40AM (#23976900)
You need to think about it a little more.

In the story, the admiral is conceited about his position so much so that he believes that he has the right not to understand the situation. Which is exactly why the commenter is in the stated position about the "righteousness" of their argument.

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by andybak on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:43PM (#23862339)
I'm not sure you've been watching the same videos as me. Or maybe the fact that I'm not a US citizen has some bearing on the matter. Our police are far from perfect but the stuff I've seen from the US has been on a different level.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by badrabbit on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:54PM (#23862460)
Ahh, is that why white people shielding black people stopped police attacks or why multiple journalists were shot in the eye with rubber bullets? Seems you've picked which side of justice will support.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by vangelis on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:51PM (#23862428)
Free expression in the free expression zone only!
[dead]
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by AlexandrB on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:00PM (#23862526)
> If you act like an asshole ... you will be treated like one.

I guess the cops haven't learned that lesson yet.

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by vangelis on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:57PM (#23862497)
I agree with you on the second point. There are however many instances of a "police riot", unprovoked escalations on peaceful protestors recently.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by greatwhitenorth on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:05PM (#23862591)
Do you've unedited videos of these escalations that show the complete context? You may be able to find 0.1% of the videos that show the complete context. Everything is conveniently edited to make people angry. No question that there are a few shitty cops but the media wants to show that every cop is one.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by grecy on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:09PM (#23862635)
Isn't Americans right to peaceful assembly one of the things that makes the country great?

Without it, how are people supposed to demonstrate about things they want the government to change? How can democracy function?

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by Ar-Curunir on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:26PM (#23862830)
“I love authority”
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by greatwhitenorth on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:53PM (#23862448)
Exactly. It's mostly people who are looking for trouble that cry police brutality. There were so many instances of people shoving their camera in a cop's face and get beaten. Why would you do that? There are a lot of dumb people who believe everything the media tells them to believe.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by rsynnott on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:04PM (#23862579)
Look, if the police officer in question was a bear or something, I could kind of see your point. But police officers are typically humans, and have free will. If they're not able to deal with that sort of thing without assaulting people, then perhaps they should consider less demanding work.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by greatwhitenorth on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:12PM (#23862676)
20 people are encircling your car, banging your windows, shouting and ready to break your car. Can you tell me how you would respond? Sit there and wait for them to assault you?
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by thephyber on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:54PM (#23863157)
So many problems with this argument.

> 20 people are encircling your car, banging your windows, shouting and ready to break your car.

Of the 400 videos, how many of them were this type of situation? I would guess 3 or fewer. This isn't a representative scenario.

> Can you tell me how you would respond?

People (police or otherwise) who aren't trained will respond in any number of inappropriate ways. Your argument is basically just justification for police to act inappropriately anytime they encounter a situation for which they haven't been explicitly trained. We don't pay police departments 40% of all municipal revenues to put untrained people on the street to act in completely unprofessional ways towards the same people who pay their paychecks, retirement, union dues, medical bills, and department lawsuits.

Actually check that. Apparently we do and those departments settle for billions of USD per year in legal settlements. The problem is that the officers largely aren't held accountable -- but the taxpayers frequently are. Moral hazard.

> Sit there and wait for them to assault you?

Professional police have a whole belt full of tools, a radio (to 40,000 other officers in NYC), a megaphone, a long gun, a short gun, and frequently a tazer.

Also, why is an officer in a car surrounded by angry citizens? Because someone in the same uniform mistreated their brother/father/son/husband/etc. Police have a lot of ability to de-escalate the problems before they happen, but they aren't doing it. Instead, police {departments, chiefs, unions, officers, wives} are pointing at violent protesters as if violent protesters have no incentive or excuse to be angry at police.

And while we're at it, shouldn't your logic be equally used against officers who assault civilians? Why shouldn't the entire country support civilians defending themselves against officers who use "extralegal" force? (rhetorical question)

Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by meheleventyone on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:29PM (#23862865)
Right but your original example was someone filming a policeman at close range. Should you be beaten for filming the police?
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by greatwhitenorth on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:31PM (#23862887)
Is shoving a camera in a cop's face same as recording from a distance?
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by meheleventyone on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:36PM (#23862964)
No the person is closer but so what? What crime has been committed that justifies extra-judicial beating? Are the police so poorly trained they cannot be filmed at close range without becoming violent?
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by scollet on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:36PM (#23862969)
The first line of defense against authoritarianism is eyes on the regime. You're defending disproportionate response to a non-violent checking of power. It leaves a bad taste in my mouth.
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by vangelis on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:56PM (#23862485)
If recording is violence, do I have the same rights as a civilian to respond?
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by greatwhitenorth on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:10PM (#23862655)
Is shoving a camera in a cop's face same as recording from a distance?
Re:We Reviewed Police Tactics Seen in Nearly 400 Protest Videos by vangelis on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:52PM (#23863137)
I'd hope an officer of the law would be able to keep their composure even with a camera in their face.