News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by stanfordkid on Thursday July 16, 2020 @01:20PM (#23861248)
I actually think it's a positive thing that the media system is being shaken. Society puts way too much trust in shit that is posted on twitter.

I feel the same way about cancel culture on twitter -- it is bad in the short term, but if it incentivizes people like Yann Lecunn to leave it -- it reduces the importance of the medium itself.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by sillysaurusx on Thursday July 16, 2020 @01:58PM (#23861744)
An article about the Yann story: https://syncedreview.com/2020/06/30/yann-lecun-quits-twitter...

I hadn’t seen that. Thanks for pointing it out.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dkonofalski on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:36PM (#23862251)
Pardon my ignorance but what exactly was the issue with what LeCun said in that response? I feel like it's a pretty agreed upon paradigm that feeding an AI/ML algo with biased data for training will make the AI/ML algo biased. That seems unsurprising and like a perfectly valid statement so there must be something I'm missing and, at least from the article, I couldn't glean what the issue was since the response was just "I'm sick of this framing" without any kind of additional information. If I'm reading it correctly, the issue maybe was that he didn't go far enough and put too much emphasis on data set bias?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by sillysaurusx on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:45PM (#23862360)
I don't know; I had exactly the same questions. FWIW I work in ML, and I've said similar things as LeCun.

The thing is, I would love to help (and listen) to those who have studied this extensively. But there wasn't any information to go on. The article makes it seem like they shouted him down while delivering no actionable advice.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dkonofalski on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:01PM (#23862542)
Yeah... it's nearly impossible to figure out what's going on after the fact since the conversation is split amongst so many different Twitter threads. The best I can discern is that his response is dismissive of systemic issues that affect results and introduce biases but, to me, that feels like he's getting jumped on for not being general enough in his criticism.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by Izkata on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:27PM (#23866324)
More specifically, IIRC the claim was that he's using the data as an excuse, instead of adjusting the data so the ML algorithm gets the desired un-biased result.

My understanding was that it was mostly coming from activists that don't really understand how AI/ML works.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by read_if_gay_ on Thursday July 16, 2020 @04:26PM (#23863454)
> The article makes it seem like they shouted him down while delivering no actionable advice.

Worse. It makes it seem like they shouted him down while not even delivering any concrete criticism. If that's accurate you can't blame LeCun for leaving. And looking at your typical political "discussion" on Twitter, I wouldn't be surprised if it is.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by stanfordkid on Thursday July 16, 2020 @11:21PM (#23866639)
This is the real problem with BLM -- they wanted a sound bite, he didn't give it to them so they attacked him.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by tspike on Thursday July 16, 2020 @01:51PM (#23861652)
It's insane to me just how much of the news content is taken directly from Twitter while newsrooms and investigative journalism is systematically defunded. How can this be reversed?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by jb775 on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:07PM (#23861862)
You have it backwards. News content is now being reported directly via Twitter, because the newsrooms and journalists have proven they can't be trusted. They were never "defunded", their customers left because the product is low quality and biased.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by save_ferris on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:16PM (#23861990)
News content is being reported directly on Twitter because the internet spoiled consumers into not having to pay for reporting. The online advertising model effectively did "defund" publications by forcing them to write low-quality content that people would click on instead of paying for.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by WilTimSon on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:20PM (#23862024)
It's also being reported there because it's an insanely fast way to reach people. Instead of them having to check the news organization's main page to see if anything happened, they can subscribe to their account on Twitter, turn on notifications and get it the moment it breaks.

Granted, Twitter is still a horrible place for long-form news (which is why it links to the full articles) and an even worse one for discussions. Which is why a different platform for instant updates could be beneficial, since news will have to adapt anyway.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by save_ferris on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:14PM (#23862703)
The instantaneous nature of the internet is one of the single biggest contributors to the low-quality nature of news content today, and in my opinion, needs to be rethought.

The reason is that publications no longer have the benefit of the doubt when they publish something wrong. If a story with a malicious source runs, that publication can't argue that they were duped by a bad source. The community will automatically accuse them of pushing fake news, regardless of whether or not it was intentional. The media no longer has any benefit of the doubt due to the intense political opposition.

Also contributing to this is a publication's desire to be first to run a breaking story. This creates a scenario where a publisher has to decide between waiting for additional sourcing to corroborate a big story or risking losing out to a competitor who may run the story first.

It's one of the main reasons that I try not to actively support Twitter-driven journalism and instead put my journalism dollars towards publications that do long-form writing that takes time and patience to produce. The late-breaking Twitter world is just too often a Kobayashi Maru situation for publications.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by jobigoud on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:35PM (#23862223)
> Instead of them having to check the news organization's main page to see if anything happened, they can subscribe to their account on Twitter, turn on notifications and get it the moment it breaks.

If only there was a really simple way to syndicate all this content that all websites could follow and multiple clients could consume...

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by WilTimSon on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:43PM (#23862335)
There is but, realistically, people have moved away from it. Getting someone to try a new thing is hard. Getting someone to go back to an old thing once they're hooked on a new one is harder.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by iask on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:23PM (#23862055)
Sadly, I believe it’s too late. Attention span is getting shorter for many. Not many would want to scroll a news article. These days almost everyone I speak with is saying they’re busy, not enough time. So, where would they even find time to watch a 30-60 minute newscast.

Which is why Twitter is probably the GoTo for news.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by searchableguy on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:39PM (#23862289)
I don't buy this completely. I see an enormous amount of redundancy to fill space in newspapers and online news media.

An article from vice on any company will mention at least three of their own previous posts and rehash company evil before getting to the point. They will add a paragraph full of questions with no answers and another one for speculations that are only somewhat related.

Why bother with that when you can get to the point using a small tweet?

There is something online news agencies are doing wrong otherwise you wouldn't see so many startups opening news sumarizers, curation etc.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by iask on Friday July 17, 2020 @09:47AM (#23870407)
That is also true. I would come across an article that interest me, however, there’s so much fluff that I would scroll 2-3 times and then just move on.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by criddell on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:33PM (#23862200)
Maybe there should be a per-user tax on large social media platforms that is redistributed to news organizations and journalists?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by adrianN on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:01PM (#23861782)
It probably can't. Why pay a journalist to do deep investigation if you get just as many page views for copypasting Twitter?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by NegatioN on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:10PM (#23861918)
As a counter-argument, maybe the thing people are willing to pay for is the insights of a single individual (like https://www.gwern.net/ which makes a decent chunk of money from patreon), not the entire organization (such as a news paper?)

There's always going to be people who're interested in insightful, well researched articles and opinions. Isn't a part of the problem connecting these people, to the actual individuals doing posting in a more transparent way than a news-paper?

Having this as the default would pose problems of it's own, and make some of the deeper journalism requiring months/years to complete more difficult though.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by searchableguy on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:32PM (#23862168)
Gwern doesn't earn much on patreon for his work.

It's also totally different than most journalists who push out stories left and right on topics they have layman understanding of. The quality and depth of work is significantly higher. I would pay for news reporting from gwern than random journalist.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by debacle on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:01PM (#23861779)
People pay for the real value of valuable news.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by mark_l_watson on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:42PM (#23862318)
+1 I agree

I pay $5/month to get Matt Taibbi’s emails, usually about two a month with in depth research and reporting.

In general I like to spend about five minutes a day quickly reviewing news on Apple News+. Otherwise I read good books, with a little time on HN. I use Twitter and FB for shamelessly plugging my books. Anyway, this works for me.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by Tenoke on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:08PM (#23861887)
>I feel the same way about cancel culture on twitter -- it is bad in the short term, but if it incentivizes people like Yann Lecunn to leave it -- it reduces the importance of the medium itself.

Given that Twitter is the only platform where interesting ML discussions happen daily with a large amount of actual researchers and practitioners talking about their work directly I'm not sure in what way it's better to have people leave without an alternative. The value just decreases for everyone.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by mft_ on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:11PM (#23861924)
If only that group of people was tech-savvy, and could find some other medium or platform to facilitate their discussions.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by Tenoke on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:36PM (#23862236)
Yes, if only it was so easy to solve coordination problems to be able to freely abandon mostly working solutions before we've even done so. Sadly, that's not the world we live in.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dogfoods on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:29PM (#23862126)
> is the only platform where interesting ML discussions happen daily with a large amount of actual researchers and practitioners talking about their work directly

arxiv.org

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by Tenoke on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:34PM (#23862211)
There aren't quite that many discussions especially from practitioners rather than almost only researchers.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by derefr on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:23PM (#23862056)
I feel like we need domain-specific Twitter-alike services, that anyone can read (and send DMs on), but only people "in" that domain can make public tweets on.

Not a community-specific service, precisely; I'm not talking about the sort of partitioning StackExchange does. I wouldn't want a CS-people-only Twitter. (Cross-pollination of ideas between fields is important!)

Nor am I talking about individual independent forums that have their own specific (rivalrous) memberships, where you can't expect network effects to guarantee that J Random Peer-in-your-domain will definitely already be a member. Everyone you wish would be there, should already be there. Like Twitter.

But different domains of discourse have different standards/norms, and it'd be helpful to keep each such domain separate, such that people don't try to interact using conflicting standards/norms; but rather will know what the primary set of norms are for their current domain, and will "mode-switch" to using those when they're in that domain.

For example, all of "academia" is one domain of discourse, with its own social norms.

So we could have one domain-specific Twitter-alike where, to join (and not get banned), you'd have to obey the rules of academic conduct; and to get verified (and so to make public tweets), you'd have to be actively in academia in some way (e.g. maybe you'd need to submit proof-of-identity in the form of the DOI of an academic paper you've written.)

Then you could have a separate domain for politicians and talking-heads, where the rules of discourse to follow are those of a political debate, and where user verification happens through a petition of non-verified users, proving that the user has "constituents."

I would imagine a blended app where one user account could be active on multiple domains at once, perhaps even with new posts from them collected onto a merged timeline for easy reading; but it'd be important to make clear, for each post, which domain it's in (e.g. by embedding the post within a background theme that represents that domain.)

I'd also imagine that getting verified in a second domain after already being verified as something else, would be harder, requiring a manual audit of your specific case. (Sort of like how multi-classing in Dungeons & Dragons is something you're supposed to have a long talk with the DM about.) Not every economist is both a professional academic and a professional political commentator; most are a professional at one and an amateur at the other.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dkonofalski on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:51PM (#23862432)
This seems great in theory but how do you "verify" these types of domains without also instituting some kind of gatekeeping? What's stopping someone from setting up or putting together a "medical" domain where that domain promotes anti-vax ideals. All it takes is for the first person to get verified to hold that ideal and then gatekeep all the other approvals through that lens. Additionally, to use your example, someone could be verified in "academia" by submitting proof of identity or an academic paper but does that then mean that "academia" also needs sub-domains to prevent people like Ben Carson from being leaders in certain fields while also being, arguably, off the deep end in other areas? He's a well-respected doctor in a specific field but also completely ignorant in other medical fields.

I don't have a solution but am mostly just curious if this kind of platform is even possible with the number of people online now. It's not like the early days of the internet where there were technical challenges that you had to overcome to make your voice heard. Now, it's so easy to say whatever anyone wants but also so easy to take ownership of the platforms for people to say what's accurate. Case in point: There are 12 users that make up the moderators for something like the top 200 sub-reddits on Reddit where 80%+ of the userbase is.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by derefr on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:06PM (#23862600)
I mean, like I said, domains are about having shared social norms, not about being part of the same community. One can be ostracized from a given community while still sharing that community's norms. There can be divisions and fractiousness within a domain. (There certainly is within the domain of "all of academia"!)

The point of "discourse domains" as a concept isn't to create echo-chambers of (correct or not) majority views. It doesn't aim to solve every problem that moderation, ignore-lists, etc. solve. The point really isn't to limit what people say at all; it's to limit how they say it, per domain (or rather, to make it clear what the proper "how" is, when you're in this space vs. that space.) It's to reconstruct a sense of there being a conversation happening within a context of particular sub-cultural discourse norms at all, vs. the current situation we're in with the Internet where every open-membership website has the de-facto discourse norms of "a protest in the public square."

As for why you'd want that—if it isn't immediately apparent: people who are enculturated to a given domain's norms, see certain things as being offensive (norm-violating), and these things differ per domain (but not really per community, given two communities both "of" the same domain.) So isolating domains from one-another, means that you eliminate "impedance mismatch" conflicts where everyone is trying their best but the difference in discourse norms makes everyone think that everyone else is acting in bad faith. It especially helps out the people for whom the norms of "a protest in the public square" are quite far from the norms of the domain they're enculturated to.

(Have you ever seen a scientist argue with a politician on Twitter? That's an impedance mismatch. Each one is trying to get different things out of the conversation, and so neither side can actually say anything without it seeming to be an act of rhetorical sabotage when seen through the lens of the other side. And further, the politician is closer to the norms of "a protest in the public square", while the scientist is further, so usually the scientist is seen by Twitter users as committing the greater faux-pas in the process.)

> This seems great in theory but how do you "verify" these types of domains without also instituting some kind of gatekeeping?

I hope it's clear, here, that the point isn't credentialism / closed-membership communities. You aren't trying to detect whether someone e.g. "is a scientist"; you're only trying to detect whether someone is best modelled as being offended by the set of things scientists are offended by.

"Verification" (in the sense of Twitter's blue checkmark) is a KYC mechanism, not a credential per se. It helps people to find a specific person on Twitter by their name. It doesn't assert that they're a member in good standing of their field; someone could be "verified" for being infamous just as much as for being famous. It just ensures that the people who "squat" on names are the people you'd expect.

The suggestions in my previous comment for verification strategies (and for linking verification to "voiced-ness" within the domain), just take this a step further: they're suggestions of processes that would be applicable to anyone who really is enculturated to a given domain's norms. They make it hard for people "uninitiated" in the domain to come in, but not by requiring a credential or a skill test; rather, they just test for something trivial that people only learn to do after first enculturating to the domain's norms.

There's no academic who hasn't written a paper—you have to write one to complete a master's and start doing original research (or, if you're an auto-didact who's not part of an academic institution, papers are even more important, as they're the way you collaborate to advance the field at all. Like PRs are in software.)

And there's no professional politician or talking head who doesn't have at least a few people willing to vouch for them. (It'd be like saying you're a professional e-sport athlete with no ladder rankings anywhere.)

None of these things require effort; they're just things you do as a matter of course as part of the process of becoming enculturated to these domains of discourse. They're like those locks in fantasy books that are opened by pushing mana into them: they don't stop bad or evil wizards, or even incompetent wizards; they just stop people who don't understand wizardry and so will probably just muck everything up if allowed inside. (Imagine a lock on a chemistry lab where you had to draw a benzene ring to get in. Same idea. They don't want you blowing yourself up in there.)

-----

Note, though, that once you've got a working domain with a cohesive set of norms, it becomes much, much easier to moderate it, because everyone in a domain will agree what the social norms they're abiding by are!

That's the real point of all this: if you untangle from your social platform all the different sub-cultural domains with their different discourse norms, then each domain can be moderated independently, by people who are also enculturated to that domain's norms and so understand them implicitly. They won't be blindly applying a checklist of rules; they'll be applying the spirit of a law that both they and the people they're applying it to understand.

(There's a good comparison to the "cultural laws" of Judaism and Islam, here. Take "cultural laws" and the priests who study+interpret+enforce them; subtract the religious aspect; and you have a domain and its moderators.)

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dogfoods on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:30PM (#23862139)
You've just invented forums, but worse in some ways.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by derefr on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:33PM (#23862195)
There is no single forum that contains as participants all of academia (and nobody else), with public viewership and the ability to DM the participants.

(One might say that Usenet did, at one point, contain all of academia within a few of its hierarchy-roots; but there's nothing stopping random quacks from posting to those. Imagine a version of the 80s where Usenet's sci. hierarchy would only accept posts from actual science departments in universities and research institutions—but where it was still mirrored for reading everywhere else—and you'd be closer.)

Really, what I badly re-invented here, was scientific journals, but with a 140-character publication limit ;)

Or IRC channels in +v mode, but where there's only 10 of them, and each one has millions of unvoiced members and thousands of voiced members.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by klyrs on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:34PM (#23862201)
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by SmokeyHamster on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:45PM (#23862368)
>Society puts way too much trust in shit that is posted on twitter.

So you're saying Biden's isn't going to send me back my Bitcoin doubled?

Dang it.

[dead]
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by flatline on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:39PM (#23862282)
We have a prominent AI researcher being ostracized for a tweet (and presumably a more general attitude we don't see out of context) that marginalizes people of color, reflecting a larger problem of systemic racism, particularly in academia. Neither his attitude nor the reaction to it seem productive in my mind. Online forums have always been prone to everyone shouting over everyone else until the loudest voice wins.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dlivingston on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:24PM (#23862813)
Can you explain how his tweet “marginalizes people of color”?

His position, from what I understand, is that the ML algorithm which reconstructed a photo of Obama as white was biased solely because the training data set consisted of mostly white people. If it had been a more diverse data set then the algorithm would have behaved more appropriately.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by flatline on Thursday July 16, 2020 @04:25PM (#23863439)
The complaint is that he was being dismissive of racism in the field by saying it's just the training data. Technically correct, but missing the larger picture - who is generating this training data? Doesn't his comment subtly attempt dismiss the issue entirely? Deployed ML systems are notorious for these kinds of biases. He was offloading the criticism to engineers building these data sets, as though he could not have any possible role to play as a researcher. He was thus shot down for a seemingly innocuous comment that is set against a very large backdrop of racism that tends to get ignored. Haven't you read White Fragility three times over by now?? /s

On the one hand this guy was pushed off twitter for a seemingly innocuous comment - one that some people just happened to take as insensitive. The type of comment that, in fact, increasingly large numbers of people seek out to take offense at - so it seems like an overreaction. On the other hand this is twitter, exactly where these types of narratives play out, he was unable to defend his position competently or even acknowledge the criticisms against him, gave up, and walked off.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by sillysaurusx on Thursday July 16, 2020 @05:21PM (#23863962)
I think I see the disconnect then: ML researchers are often the people who build the datasets. Datasets aren't something that grow in the wild, nor is it usually a task for ML engineers. So the original tweet wasn't really offloading the problem; it was self-criticism (though it's understandable it didn't sound like it).
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by isoskeles on Thursday July 16, 2020 @01:53PM (#23861673)
Can you explain why it is relevant that he's white?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by ciarannolan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @01:56PM (#23861716)
No explanation necessary. It's the same old racism, but with a new 2020 twist: it's ok as long as it's racism against people we don't like.

Check out the recent spate of black athletes and celebrities posting openly anti-Semitic comments on social media (one directly (mis)quoting Hitler re: Jews) with zero repercussions.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nba/2020/07/08/stephen...

https://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/wireStory/jewish-leader...

https://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/hip-hop/9400472/i...

A really thoughtful piece about this by Kareem Abdul Jabbar here too:

https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/kareem-abdul-jabbar-i...

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by whymauri on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:01PM (#23861775)
Zero repercussions? Nick Cannon lost his job and board position, and rightfully so [0]. Do not misconstrue the consequences - people will be fired or blacklisted for these anti-Semitic comments, and that's frankly a good thing.

[0] https://www.cnn.com/2020/07/15/entertainment/nick-cannon-via...

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by ciarannolan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:05PM (#23861839)
You're right that Nick Cannon is the exception. (edit: actually, you're wrong: https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/jul/16/nick-cannon...)

How about Ice Cube, Stephen Jackson, DeSean Jackson, Dwyane Wade, etc. and all those who supported the comments or brushed them off as "speaking their truth" or some other nonsense? They will face no consequences, because, again, racism is deemed okay in the current climate as long as it's aimed correctly.

Can you even _imagine_ the absolute chaos that would rein if a white NBA player started quoting David Duke to millions of followers, and a bunch of white NBA players and commentators supported them?

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by baddox on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:19PM (#23862018)
> They will face no consequences...

> Can you even _imagine_ the absolute chaos that would rein if...

I think everyone has their own media diet, influenced partly by their own choices and partly by algorithms. Your media diet likely has a huge effect on whose reactions you see and thus which reactions you perceive to be "brushing something off" or "absolute chaos."

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by ciarannolan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:22PM (#23862036)
True - I need to keep in mind that Twitter isn't "everyone".

But at the same time, these are well known public figures broadcasting openly racist and anti-Semitic thoughts to millions of people.

I'm not completely sure what to make of it.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by baddox on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:53PM (#23862458)
Even within Twitter there will be a vast difference. If a liberal quotes a conservative tweet in disapproval you will see replies from liberals also expressing disapproval. But if another conservative quotes the same tweet in approval, you’ll see a bunch of conservatives replying in approval. It would be incorrect to conclude either “everyone realized that tweet was terrible” and “everyone agreed with that tweet.”
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by lawnchair_larry on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:10PM (#23861908)
It’s amusing that Cannon got fired for anti-semitism, which he wasn’t actually guilty of, and not racism for saying white people are less, and are closer to animals.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by ciarannolan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:15PM (#23861976)
His full quote for people to judge for themselves:

>“When you have a person that has the lack of pigment, the lack of melanin, they know that they will be annihilated,” Mr. Cannon said during the June podcast. “So therefore, however they got the power, they have the lack of compassion — melanin comes with compassion, melanin comes with soul. We call it soul — we’re soul brothers and sisters — that’s the melanin that connects us, so the people that don’t have [melanin] are a little, and I’m going to say this carefully, are a little less.”

>“They’re acting out of fear, they’re acting out of low self-esteem, they’re acting out of a deficiency,” he continued. “So therefore, the only way that they can act is evil. They have to rob, steal, rape, kill in order to survive. So then, these people who didn’t have what we have — and when I say we, I speak of the melanated people — they had to be savages. They had to be barbaric because they’re in these Nordic mountains. They’re in these rough environments. They’re acting as animals, so they’re the ones that are actually closer to animals. They’re the ones that are actually the true savages.”

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by lawnchair_larry on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:26PM (#23862097)
Thanks. Yes, again, he did NOT get fired for this.

But he started talking about conspiracy theories relating to the illuminati and the Rothschilds (who, yes, happen to be jewish) and how they have all the power. Nothing derogatory or about jewish people in general that I saw.

Every single headline on my news page says he was anti-semetic and completely ignored the blatant racism. What fun times we are in.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by octernion on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:02PM (#23861794)
yeah definitely there were zero repercussions and nick cannon definitely didn't lose his job.

??? what are you talking about.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by ciarannolan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:06PM (#23861847)
Ice Cube, Stephen Jackson, DeSean Jackson, Dwyane Wade, etc.

If you want to do this accounting, I'm really here for you.

Also, he didn't lose his job here: https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/jul/16/nick-cannon...

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by octernion on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:10PM (#23861912)
i have no idea what you are talking about. folks are being held accountable, you said they weren't. are you saying that it's not happening fast enough for your liking? you were straight up wrong.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by ciarannolan on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:12PM (#23861936)
No, I was straight up right. Look at my edit:

https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2020/jul/16/nick-cannon...

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by davinic on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:05PM (#23861835)
Because power dynamics play a huge role when we're talking about systemic issues, and the current system gives most favorable outcomes to white males. It's not that the other cases are not important, but dealing with them deserves less priority unless and until they structurally hold that power and receive the benefits.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by noworriesnate on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:36PM (#23862247)
What you're describing seems to me like a rationalization for injustice and hypocrisy. If you want to know what the power dynamics are, look at who is held accountable for their actions and who isn't.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by lawnchair_larry on Thursday July 16, 2020 @03:27PM (#23862847)
This, but also, the premise isn’t even valid. Race is an extremely poor predictor of power or success relative to other variables. People are just lazy with stats, driven by an ideological agenda, and selective about the studies they decide to focus on. Also, critical examinations where they are most necessary are not morally fashionable, and can even cost one their job.

Even if this were true, which it isn’t, pushing this message leads to worse outcomes for the populations in question. If you are taught that the system is against you and you have no agency, the only rational response is not to try, and instead just harbor resentment. This perpetuates a vicious cycle and leaves everyone worse off. Learned helplessness is real.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by lawnchair_larry on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:08PM (#23861881)
Why do people buy into this nonsense?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by shadowgovt on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:11PM (#23861926)
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by davinic on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:14PM (#23861969)
With which part do you disagree and what is your basis for that?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by eternalban on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:30PM (#23862145)
There are 2 parts here: (1) problem, and (2) remedy.

The issue for myself and likeminded individuals who actually do not have a stake in the current "power dynamics" -- I could post during the Twitter hack -- is "part" (2).

Where are the "scientific" and "rational" studies on the du jour mob tactics cum "remedy" to social injustice? As a spectator it is reminiscent of previous attempts at "remedy", notably the Cultural Revolution by Chairman Mao. That didn't really solve anything, did it?

Distorted power dynamics certainly should be addressed. There are actually quite a few elephants in the room that aren't even discussed. But please do not make a claim that mobilized mob squads are a "proven remedy to fix power dynamic's distortions in society". The historical verdict on this is: one group of power holders replaces another.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by shadowgovt on Thursday July 16, 2020 @10:47PM (#23866459)
> As a spectator it is reminiscent of previous attempts at "remedy", notably the Cultural Revolution by Chairman Mao.

You left out Stonewall, the Haymarket Riot, and the LA riots.

And maybe the Civil War or American Revolution.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by eternalban on Friday July 17, 2020 @06:41AM (#23869158)
No I didn't. I can make the necessary fine distinctions.
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by davinic on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:36PM (#23862241)
Where did I even come close to making the claim that mobilized mob squads are a "proven remedy to fix power dynamic's distortions in society"?
Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by dx87 on Thursday July 16, 2020 @02:40PM (#23862300)
> dealing with them deserves less priority unless and until they structurally hold that power and receive the benefits.

I don't know if it's your intention, but the way you phrased it makes it sound like you don't think we should do anything about racism unless it's being done by whatever group is currently the most powerful. Considering that white people are a global minority, it doesn't seem to make much sense to say that posting anti-white/anti-semitic statements to a global audience isn't a big deal just because the person who said it happens to live in a country where they are a minority.

Re:Twitter hack has profound national security implications by davinic on Thursday July 16, 2020 @09:18PM (#23865935)
I am saying that we should react proportionally and that the societal context is critical.