If you added up all the costs of the people at the lowest extremes (by various metrics), I'd venture to guess that we could increase our prosperity (by various metric) by an order of magnitude.
Example: When I started my startup, we made the decision not to hire any salesperson who wasn't proficient in using a computer (we have no IT support line). We also made the decision to not sell to any customer that couldn't figure out how to use the website (we have no telephone support).
I cannot even tell you how multiplicative the benefits are. The 2% employees who couldn't use a computer or clients who couldn't use the website were responsible for 90% of the issues we had at my prior company. Everything from regulatory complaints, to lawsuits, to ad-hoc report requests, to virus infected PCs, to... the list goes on and on.
Having smart people is great. Not dealing with idiots is equally important.
As your parent said, it's not 2%, it's more like everyone. No one is perfect all the time.
More importantly, it's one thing when hiring, but are you seriously suggesting 2% of the population shouldn't be able to use Twitter or online banking or other online services? 140,000,000 people should effectively face social death because you can't be fucked to help them?
This is backwards, we should be sacrificing profits and convenience to be more inclusive.
...and it's not correct to say that "everyone is imperfect sometimes" because the correlation between people who are problems across various metrics, is high.
It appeared that normally they not really check if it matches, but this time given the transfer amount they did. And it just so happened that the signature they had scanned in their system was the first one I ever made as a kid (30yrs ago) when I opened the account.
Finally after many retries they turned the monitor to show me the expected signature and let me practice it on a piece of paper, so it would pass some other approval stage.
With a 200 yard line waiting behind me, sweating profusely, I finally managed to reproduce something. The sale went through, luckily, and immediately after I ditched that bank account.
I believe most banks allow their customers to change their signature to something they can replicate more consistently — but it probably relies on showing up to a branch and producing sufficient ID.
Helpfully, they provided me with a screenshot of the one they had on file... one copy and paste later and the problem was resolved.
One copy and paste
Because they showed you the signature and let you practice, right?
I guess one, admittedly brutal, solution is for customers to act like the immune system. Call up, fudge your way through to something that should be protected, and then escalate to a manager and report that you got access to your own account with vague details; they can listen to the call log to verify.
Worst case is that the rep gets fired (which sucks..) but if enough reps get fired then future reps will be hired and trained more diligently.
The technological measures have to account for human behaviour. Otherwise you just end up with almost everyone not being able to access almost everything almost all of the time. People are forgetful, irrational, stubborn and stupid. So are institutions. Put them together and you have a social engineering dream world (literally our current world).