News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by scarier on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:58PM (#23828387)
Fires on a ship can spread scarily fast, which is one reason sailors devote so much time underway to cleaning--I've heard anecdotal stories of at least one lethal fire spreading through a ship's ventilation system due to the amount of combustible stuff it sucked up.

In port, a ship may be particularly vulnerable to this sort of thing, partially because fire boundaries that are normally closed while underway may be open to facilitate maintenance.

Here's a diagram showing a rough LHD cross-section near the bottom of the page: https://fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ship/lhd-1.htm

The fire here broke out in the lower V, close to one of the ship's magazines but pretty far from a lot of the bulk fuel (although there are a number of fuel pipes in and around the area in order to facilitate fueling assault craft and ground vehicles, which may be contributing to the fire with residual fuel).

Fortunately, even if there is a magazine in close proximity to the fire, it's likely well-protected, and unlikely to be full of ordnance. Furthermore, ordnance approved for shipboard operation has special thermal coating to reduce the likelihood of cook-off, which may be enough to protect it against the indirect heat of a fire on the other side of a bulkhead.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:45AM (#23828603)
I've read some comments by someone that's been on scene since the start as one of the DC teams.

No ordinance is in the magazines. It's standard procedure to unloaded it at a pier specially designed for that task before extended port stays.

The fire has definitely reach the fuel lines you mention, and they're sustaining the fire. The team my commenter was a part of was one of the first to try to push inside. They made it about 25 feet in. The floor was so hot their team leaders boots melted. The writer said he had to stand on a pile of hose to avoid the same problem. The heat pushed them back out after less than half an hour. His opinion was that there was little choice but to just let the fuel burn off.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by yingw787 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:21AM (#23828498)
I think this would be the first U.S. capital ship lost since WWII.

It's also interesting that China, Russia, and now the U.S. have all lost carriers while undergoing construction / maintenaince in just the past few years:

https://www.cnn.com/2019/12/12/europe/russian-carrier-fire-i... https://www.forbes.com/sites/hisutton/2020/04/11/brand-new-c...

Something to bond over, I guess. Dangerous work, and I hope everybody stays safe, better a carrier burns in peacetime than a life lost.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by vonmoltke on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @08:45AM (#23831193)
Neither of those was stricken.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:40PM (#23828271)
> McGrath described military shipyards in general as places “where an almost insane devotion to safety, good housekeeping and procedural compliance is required. It’s hard to imagine one or more of those things not being involved in the cause or spread of the fire.”

It seems like the culture of safety and competence of the US Pacific Fleet is not what it was. Another example is the USS John McCain colliding with a freighter[0]. Then there was the whole Fat Leonard corruption scandal[1]. Maybe these are just anecdata and a side effect of greater attention.

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_John_S._McCain_and_Alnic_M... 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fat_Leonard_scandal

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by walrus01 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @03:21AM (#23829390)
I'm surprised this article doesn't mention at all the Los Angeles class nuclear attack sub that was deliberately set on fire by a dockyard worker.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Miami_(SSN-755)

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by ornxka on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @06:08AM (#23830178)
>Fury admitted to setting the 23 May fire by igniting some rags on the top bunk of a bunk room. He claimed to have started the fire to get out of work early.[10][11][12][13] On 15 March 2013 Fury was sentenced to over 17 years in federal prison and ordered to pay $400 million in restitution.[14]

Wow, uh, that's a lot of money. Is this the poorest individual (by assets sans debts) in America? I can't imagine anyone being able to acquire personal debt on that scale by any other means.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by curionav on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:30AM (#23828831)
One month ago, the French Navy lost the nuclear submarine "La Perle" meanwhile the ship was being maintained. The similarities with the "Bonhomme Richard" accident are striking.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by boomboomsubban on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:34AM (#23829170)
This is just a guess, but I assume both are suffering crew shortages as a result of the pandemic, resulting in the excess trash that fueled the fire.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by gorgoiler on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:58PM (#23828381)
It is a cruel irony of Earth that our atmosphere is made up of such an odd mixture. It’s odd to think that air itself is outright dangerous.

Four fifths of the fluid in which we live and breath ranges from inert to noble. The remaining fifth is one of the most dangerous, angry, reactive, poisonous gasses we know: Oxygen.

It is crucial to life and yet at the same time is quite capable of partially or completely destroying everything we hold dear. Our tools, belongings, us, our homes, warships, forests, crops and savannahs. It needn’t even burn with a flame: most things will decay in its presence with or without spectacle.

If one encountered a planet where almost everything was made of gelatinous gasoline, whose principle inhabitants were a form of highly evolved sentient matchstick that kept striking boards as pets, one might think them a little risk averse. Then of course you’d realize that life and society on this planet have evolved in such a way because they are neither unfortunate or insane enough to live on a world that’s blanketed in O₂.

On a visit to this planet you explain to their ambassador about the atmosphere on your home world. She doesn’t know whether to laugh hysterically or faint in horror. The knowledge terrifies her and she takes deep methane breaths while stroking her phosphorous hands on tibbles-the-striking-board, trying to calm down. You decide it’s best not to further disturb her with stories of plate tectonics and the major cities, nuclear reactors, etc your people have built on fault lines, at sea level.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by rckoepke on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:12AM (#23828450)
> One fifth is the most dangerous, angry, reactive, poisonous gas we know.

Obviously you're utilizing hyperbole here, but I'm assuming you're referring to oxygen's oxidative potential (really "standard reduction potential"), but other gases have significantly higher reduction potentials than oxygen. Fluorine and Chlorine cause bigger, hotter fires at conditions that would generally be considered "non-flammable" if oxygen were involved instead. They also corrode/rust things faster than oxygen does.

Charts like [0] are misleading because they list the standard reduction potential of the monoatomic forms, which isn't realistic when most of these form diatomic gases (e.g. Cl2, O2, etc).

Both fluorine and chlorine gases are more oxidative than oxygen. Chlorine has electron affinity of -2.4 eV and while O2 is -0.4 eV.

0: https://www.angelo.edu/faculty/kboudrea/periodic/trends_elec...

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by Reelin on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:21AM (#23828783)
> at conditions that would generally be considered "non-flammable" if oxygen were involved instead

"Generally considered non-flammable" doesn't even begin to describe it. From (http://www.lateralscience.co.uk/Fluorine/Fluorine.html):

> the problem was its collection and containment. Fluorine chemically reacts with just about everything, usually very vigorously. He fashioned collection vials from platinum, palladium and gold. All were destroyed.

As to the GP:

> > the most dangerous, angry, reactive, poisonous gas we know

To continue the nitpicking, bear in mind that a gas is just one phase of matter for a particular chemical. What we're really after then is something from among the most reactive chemicals we know. I nominate dioxygen difluoride which will (for example) react with liquid methane at -180C. It's antics are summarized by Derek Lowe. (https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2010/02/23/th...)

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by gorgoiler on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:35AM (#23828559)
It would indeed be an even crazier planet where those gasses were part of the atmosphere and our lives!

(Also, hyperbole clarified.)

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by stormdennis on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @02:18AM (#23829083)
According to Wikipedia, the Richard refers to"Poor Richard's almanac" a publication of Benjamin Franklin, who was US ambassador to France when John Paul Jones named the original Bonhomme Richard in his honour.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by everybodyknows on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:23PM (#23828160)
1,000,000 gallons of fuel oil reportedly on the ship. And munitions.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by NikolaeVarius on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:33PM (#23828229)
Last time I checked, the fire was controlled to be away from munitions and fuel. The stuff burning is pretty much anything that isn't metal scattered around the ship.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by cyberlurker on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:39PM (#23828261)
I'm obviously ignorant on this, but I would have expected anything short of munitions or fuel would not have caused this much damage on something as advanced as an aircraft carrier. The article mentioned that having fewer crew members made it harder to handle, but having 160 crew on board with fire and smoke detectors doesn't seem like it should have resulted in this. I hope to one day read the report on how this happened, I clearly have a lot to learn.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by Element_ on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:54PM (#23828363)
Apparently the fire suppression systems were locked out to facilitate the work and the doors/hatches had temporary cabling/hoses/vents running through them which prevented the crew from quickly locking down areas and control the spread.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by peapicker on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:51PM (#23828349)
According to what I’ve read, the halon fire suppression was down for maintenance when the fire started.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by wil421 on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:55PM (#23828367)
Have you ever been on a massive ship? 844 feet long and only 160 crew. How many rooms do you think the boat has? The ship is almost of the size of a Manhattan city block. Imagine a small skyscraper incased in a steel hull.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by modwest on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:00AM (#23828396)
If the fire was in control it wouldn’t still be burning. This isn’t a forest fire where controlled burns can keep smoldering for days. If the fire was in control it wouldn’t still be burning.

edit: Downvote all you want but if the fire was in control it wouldn’t still be burning.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by tandr on Wednesday July 15, 2020 @02:59AM (#23842139)
Curious - why they did not pump out all the fuel from the ship? 3500t of fuel can a lot of ecological damage, be that spilled or burned.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by galacticaactual on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:42PM (#23828286)
The BHR is old as it is. I don't see it ever leaving port again after this.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by avs733 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:20AM (#23828488)
age isn't the issue...metal structure and repair cost is

pretty much the entire structure seems to be destroyed. Undoing that damage and then rebuilding what was destroyed will be effectively (if not greater than) the cost of just buying a new one.

Even if you could repair it, you don't want to. A large amount of the metal has been heated to very high and unknown temperatures. Typically, the concern is three things [0]: dimensional changes (i.e., you warped your entire ship), increased corrosion (hot metal rust faster), and permanent reduction in strength (like, >50% permanent reduction in strength). Now add in that the fire has almost certainly burned or boiled the paint off the external surfaces that are contacting sea water. That paint is the the skin of the ship, any of that underlying steel would need to be expected, cleaned, and likely repaired.

Age isn't the issue, the damage is. It would be like trying to renovate a burned out house. At some point it's not a renovation its a teardown.

EDIT: adding the obvious 'this is my opinion based on observations and I have no first hand data on this ship' qualifciation

[0] https://www.edtengineers.com/blog-post/fire-effects-steel

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by dingaling on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:03AM (#23828702)
> The BHR

I assume that's some sort of contrived neutral nickname for the ship. It's the Bonny Dick to sailors and always will be.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by newacct583 on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:52PM (#23828353)
It was laid down in 1995, that's not particularly old for a naval vessel in general. The Wasp class are still active, their replacements are just now entering service, and there was no plan to decommission it that I'm aware of.

Whether it gets repaired or not is more of a financial decision than anything else. Surely the hull has many decades left.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by linuxftw on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:02AM (#23828405)
The fire has been raging for 2 days now and the forward mast has collapsed. I'd be absolutely shocked if that ship sailed again.

Steel really warps when you heat it up. Each compartment needs to be water tight. Just fixing the doorways alone would be a monumental task. Not to mention all the cabling and equipment that needs to be replaced. The amount of labor it will take to fix the steel will probably more than just laying down an entire new ship.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by rwmurrayVT on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @08:21AM (#23830990)
You have to evaluate the cost of the work, the cost of a new build, dry dock availability, and the ability to parallel path a repair + a new LHA.

It'll be an interesting decision.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by linuxftw on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @11:52AM (#23833367)
Yeah, not just costs, but also scheduling concerns. The amount of spaces in shipyards is not elastic. The amount of labor needed for the repairs is not elastic. How will deferring the maintenance of other ships that are operation impact ship availability and how much will deferring maintenance end up costing those other ships in additional repairs?

Unfortunately, the military is run by MBAs now. There's no excess funding available for emergencies. Every penny is allocated, and it's still not enough. I was on a smaller amphib class ship, we routinely ran out of budget for replacement parts. Every quarter was an exercise in prioritizing what was going to be fixed and what was going to not get fixed because we simply didn't have the budget for maintenance.

Another concern is the crew. You've now got 200 or so sailors with nothing to do. Are they supposed to just mill about and wait for the ship to be repaired for a couple years? The crew will need to be rotated to other assignments. Now, you have a ship with no crew, it's going to have to go basically through the entire commissioning process again, sea trials, etc.

It's all a logistical nightmare.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by sterwill on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:51PM (#23828347)
Multiple news sources have called the ship "old" at 23 years, and more succeptable to fires because of its age. I mean, we knew about fire back in 1995 when the thing was designed (I was alive back then, and I knew about fire).

I don't know anything about shipbuilding, but isn't the US Navy full of much older ships that aren't considered fire hazards? Is there something special about this one? It had a halon system (that didn't work).

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by modwest on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:59PM (#23828389)
The halon system was switched off because it was in maintenance.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by jeffcore on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:46AM (#23828610)
Halon being tagged out wouldn't have influenced the outcome here. Lower V is not Halon protected. MMR1 below it is, but not V. The next closest Halon compartment would have been FWD EDG, which would have been beyond too late once the fire reached it. The AFFF system would have made short work of the fire, had it not been tagged out / in IEM -- definitely affected the fire attack.

I did two years on Iwo, and BZ to the Bonny crew. They did all they could have with those fire trees with plastic nozzles until help arrived.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by mattdeboard on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:32PM (#23834986)
BTW were you aboard the Iwo in 2005? I was a Marine deployed w/ SPMAGTF Katrina down there and we got “evacuated” on the Iwo Jima when another hurricane was bearing down on the area. It was a Marine battalion along with a lot of civilians. Don’t remember how long I was aboard but a few days certainly, before disembarking in norfolk or somewhere thereabouts.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by mattdeboard on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:05AM (#23828708)
Yeah it’s a harrowing situation. I look forward to seeing an accounting of what happened. This is a catastrophe for the Navy.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by sterwill on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:06AM (#23828421)
I understand that, but why is a 23-year old ship considered old? USS Nimitz is nearing 50 years old. Wikipedia [1] lists a bunch of ships built in the 70s and 80s. USS Bonhomme Richard appears to be newer than half the ships there.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_current_ships_of_the_U...

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by modwest on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:07AM (#23828430)
It’s not. Commenters on HN know jack shit about this topic but love commenting like they have any idea. It’s the thing HN is most known-for: non-experts speaking out of their ass with top-tier confidence.

Edit: it’s not even halfway through its projected lifecycle.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by avs733 on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:21AM (#23828493)
hey now...most of us speak out our ass with top-tier confidence about things we ARE experts in. Don't limit us.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by galacticaactual on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:32AM (#23828545)
Well. Given that I've planned and rehearsed operations with this exact ship, I'll stand by my comment - this ship and its guts are hardly new. In colloquial terms - "old."
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by mattdeboard on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @01:04AM (#23828703)
It’s not old. It’s not new. Wasp classes have a half-century lifespan. It’s one of the newest Wasp classes to be commissioned. You still have plankholders on active duty. By ship standards this is not an old ship.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by modwest on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:58PM (#23828383)
Extremely ironic given your username.
[dead]
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by perl4ever on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:55PM (#23828366)
I don't understand. You have an issue with "spending so much", but you have a hard time caring about an event that's going to have a large cost?
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by simlevesque on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:58PM (#23828384)
He thinks we overvalue these things in our society and he does not view this as a huge loss. I'm sure he grasps that they will just buy a new one.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by pm90 on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:57PM (#23828375)
Military funding is just something we will have to live with, regardless of any kind of social movement. The military is one the few institutions that enjoys Bipartisan support, there is also ample evidence that military funding keeps the American economy humming. Accidents such as this will always happen, regardless of the best safeguards in place; it is the cost of maintaining a large naval force.

At the cost of defunding schools? Most certainly not. The US has enough to fund schools and the military; the lack of federal funding is purely political on the part of the current administration.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by 737min on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:44PM (#23828305)
Do we know if this was possibly not an accident, but a hostile act by one of our adversaries? Taking one of the 8 USNavy’d mini-carriers without a fight is certainly something China dreams about...
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by jasonwatkinspdx on Monday July 13, 2020 @11:51PM (#23828345)
No, that's a rather preposterous idea. What exactly would China gain from this that would be worth the possible blowback?

The CCP's #1 priority is stability to enable continued economic development. That's why they advance their more adversarial goals via sustained incremental efforts. They view democracies as vulnerable as they so often change leadership, whereas they can sustain very long term goals.

Life tends to be more banal than James Bond. The simple explanation here is that something went wrong and sparked a fire during maintenance work, likely welding, and because the ship was in dock with a bazillion service lines running through the hatches, the fire was able to spread to find fuel trivially. Based on a comment I read from one of the DC folks fighting the fire, they don't know the origin, but they do know it got into the fuel lines, which caused a minor explosion. The odds are pretty high they're just gonna have to let the fuel burn off.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by modwest on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:03AM (#23828407)
When I was deployed aboard Naval vessels in 2000 a hole was blown in the side of a ship in our group, the USS Cole.

My real life includes attacks on US naval vessels that kill people and destroy equipment.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:34AM (#23828556)
Of course I know about the Cole. But this was not a bomb. There's a pretty clear difference in frequency of ships bombed in port vs ones that simply catch fire. The whole point of terrorism is to create a public spectacle and take credit for it.

And of course, now we've shifted the goal posts yet again from "It was China!" to "It was terrorist!" with none of this changes in belief motivated by new information or evidence.

Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by khuey on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @12:09AM (#23828442)
The USS Miami was destroyed in port by a fire set by a disgruntled maintenance worker. There are options other than accidents and acts of war.
Re:Bonhomme Richard, fate uncertain, would be one of largest... by 737min on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @08:36AM (#23831106)
Wow; quite the downvotes for even thinking it could be sabotage? the USN investigators will consider it as a possibility, even if unlikely.