Ah, this makes sense because the first seen and last seen columns are the same for all the stuff I didn't download, but for the one thing I noticed that I do actually recognize there's a gap between first and last seen.
Of course I imagine if two peers were looking for the same thing a few hours a part this wouldn't work to identify stuff either.
EDIT: Is there any way to stop it from doing this? I don't want law enforcement to mistakenly use this as evidence that I actually downloaded anything.
And this site (which i guess is just a couple lines of python collecting the data) is not bothering to distinguish any of the finer details.