It was on every single Hidden Wiki at the time.. it _was_ everywhere, and commonly linked to from sites like 4chan.
other drug marketplaces pop up
Sure, but nothing like the Silk Road. In a winner-take-all market like the online marketplace market, you would expect a top dog to emerge.
When did you do your research? The difference I noticed began late 2012.
I'm sure any operators that didn't get busted realized the heat had showed up and chose to shut down. When you are facing 20 years in jail you don't need hard evidence that Tor is broken to decide to walk away.
There were huge markets after Silk Road, though admittedly I don't know how size compared to Silk Road (e.g. AlphaBay, Agora, Nucleus, Hansa).
DNM's haven't been the same since the busts of AlphaBay and Hansa in close succession.
Scrubbed my drives, poured bleach in my eyes and swore off TOR forever. I'd agree that at the time, it was rampant.
However, it was during the same time that the FBI had set up their Operation Torpedo so it's quite possible those were heavily advertised on purpose as a trap.
Either way, it's sickening and another proof that we can't have nice things. Give a dark-web to mankind and the first thing they do is upload disgusting illegal porn to it (I am not talking about kinks but actual criminal activity).
I'm sure CP existed and exists on the dark web, but I think it's an exaggeration to say "you couldn't throw a stone without coming upon CP". A few years back I spent quite a bit of time on tor (research purposes), and thankfully never once just stumbled upon CP - I'm sure it's there, but you're going to have to go looking for it.
While Silk Road isn't around any more, other drug marketplaces pop up as soon as one dissappears - it's still very, very easy to buy any drug you want. Next day delivery of heroism? Easy. You've 3 big threats with buying drugs on the darkweb though:
1) The site pulling an exit scam, dissappearing with all the escrowed funds 2) Your seller pulling an exit scam, taking money for as long as possible without sending any drugs, then leaving the market 3) The site being compromised by the feds - it's actually quite difficult to run a watertight site on the darkweb, so this does happen