"I already read The Underground History of American Education. Is it worth reading Weapons of Mass Instruction too?"
No. Weapons of Mass Instruction is basically just excerpts from Underground History. I think there are a few new things, but mostly what happened is that the publisher for Underground History backed out once they read the book, which left Gatto allowed to self publish it himself but unable to find another publishing deal. So Weapons of Mass instruction was basically just him going out and repackaging Underground History and publishing the best of it.
Re:Against School - John Taylor Gatto
by euroclydon on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @08:57AM
(#2382396)
I imagine any publisher would have strong disincentive to publish UHAE. He has few good things to say about the scholastic publishing houses.
I had the distinct privilege of being home-educated, and never darkening the door of a government run primary school. My parent's resolve in doing this was largely influenced by Mr. Gatto. There is hope.
Why? There are plenty of home/un-schooling groups that you could assist even though you don't have kids.
Re:Against School - John Taylor Gatto
by JabavuAdams on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @09:30AM
(#2382489)
You can mentor someone else's kids. It needn't be formal.
Not sure haven't read that work of his. Right now I'm finishing off Disabling Professions by Ivan Illich which looks at how professions are a continuation of the learned helplessness that schooling helps to instill.
Not that it greatly matters, of course, since there is absolutely nothing I can do about it as I have already decided not to have kids.