News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by stretchwithme on Monday March 28, 2011 @09:51PM (#2380994)
The previous artificial leaf and the current one are different things.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by mhb on Monday March 28, 2011 @09:59PM (#2381013)
But 45 hours and one day aren't that different.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by MaysonL on Monday March 28, 2011 @10:08PM (#2381033)
Being at ~100% after 45 hours and at 0% after 24 hours are quite different.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by mhb on Monday March 28, 2011 @10:15PM (#2381052)
Since you're intent on belaboring the point, it doesn't claim that one is at ~100% and the other was at 0%. More significantly, if the assertion is that one is more stable, don't you think it would be more compelling to demonstrate its operation for, say, a month? Or did they build this one leaf 45 hours before issuing a press release?
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by jedsmith on Monday March 28, 2011 @10:56PM (#2381165)
"Lifespan" implies that at the end of the period, the old leaf died. There would be no other reason to use the word. The submitted article also mentions 45 hours without a drop in activity, implying 100% at the end of 45 hours for the new leaf without any kind of assertion about a lifespan for the new leaf. The linked ACS release doesn't discuss this, either.

Grant him the point. Truthfully, you're splitting hairs, and it really isn't worth arguing about, especially since this entire thing seems dubious without proof.

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by prawn on Monday March 28, 2011 @10:07PM (#2381030)
Well, different but I agree, not different enough to call one highly unstable and the other stable.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by deadbadger on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @06:30AM (#2382081)
Certainly not when you're trying to judge energy payback horizons for a device incorporating silicon, nickel and cobalt, all of which come with significant costs of production. What if the degradation isn't linear, as seems very likely? Obviously it's a significant improvement, but 45 hours' operation tells us virtually nothing about the device's likely practicality.

The real problem here is that, as usual, we're forced to speculate about what should be straightforward facts, because the story in the OP is based on a dumbed-down press release relating to a talk we can't see, describing research we can't freely access (http://web.mit.edu/chemistry/dgn/www/pubs/publications_2011....), and as a result contains almost no actual information. So it's grandiose claims "we could power the third world!" without any means of assessing whether they're even plausible.

None of this is to say the new cell isn't really interesting, of course. But it's just so typical of science churnalism.