News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by corin_ on Monday March 28, 2011 @09:39PM (#2380969)
Solar panels are already good enough that they are used in developed countries such as USA and UK. Are they perfect? No, they cost too much, and they don't generate enough electricity, but they are used none-the-less.

By the sound of it, this new creation would be more efficient, either in price, electricity generation, or both, than traditional solar panels - if that wasn't the case, why on earth would any project use them in third world countries, when they could instead use solar panels.

So, based on those two facts, surely anyone who would be using solar panels ought to look to be using this product in the next few years? (And, depending on how much better than traditional solar panels it is, possibly more people/companies would want to use it than are willing to use solar power right now.)

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by tesseract on Monday March 28, 2011 @10:37PM (#2381107)
I don't see, in the linked article, a comparison of the efficiency of this device to that of existing solar panels (which are quite a bit more efficient than natural leaves).
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by mryall on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @08:52AM (#2382383)
> [solar panels] are quite a bit more efficient than natural leaves ...

Got a citation for that? I'd be interested to learn more.

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by tesseract on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @11:33AM (#2382990)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency vs 10% to 30%+ for solar cells (depending on technology/price).
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by anamax on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @11:48AM (#2383067)
> Solar panels are already good enough that they are used in developed countries such as USA and UK. Are they perfect? No, they cost too much, and they don't generate enough electricity, but they are used none-the-less.

Subsidy and vanity explain a lot of economic activity.

Plus, energy costs are not very uniform. It's much easier/cheaper to get power to the next house in a suburb than it is to get power to a freeway sign 10 miles from the nearest town. That's why solar is cost effective in some situations even when it doesn't make sense in general.

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by berntb on Monday March 28, 2011 @10:17PM (#2381056)
>>Solar panels are already good enough that they are used in developed countries such as USA and UK. Are they perfect? No, they cost too much, and they don't generate enough electricity, but they are used none-the-less.

Does no one follow energy news, except for oil prices and the Polywell project?! :-)

Many estimates talk about soon reaching "grid parity" in large parts of the world. If this leaf isn't good enough, there will be some other solar variant soon.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grid_parity

It seems to go faster than this prediction from 2009: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/8386460.stm

(Kurzweil argued in 2008 that solar energy will take over http://www.livescience.com/4824-solar-power-rule-20-years-fu... )

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by ars on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @04:36AM (#2381888)
BTW one reason that Grid Parity is a moving target is that one of the input costs to making solar power is energy. When energy (hydrocarbon fuel) becomes more expensive, instead of making solar power cheaper in comparison, it has no real effect.

Instead, regular power becomes more expensive, which makes building solar power also more expensive, and the net result is a wash.

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by DannoHung on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @07:07AM (#2382145)
That seems weird. That would imply that the lifetime energy capture of a solar panel is roughly equivalent to the creation and installation energy cost.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by randallsquared on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @09:43AM (#2382539)
Doesn't seem weird at all, I think. Solar just barely passed breakeven in the last decade, unless you factor in subsidies. I notice that for a random zip code in Maine, http://bpsolar.cleanpowerestimator.com/bpsolar.htm shows that absent federal and state subsidies, you'll save only about $4600 over 25 years with their default settings. It's phrased as saving $36K, though, due to subsidies and interesting presentation. :) But BP Solar really wants you to buy solar panels, of course.
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by GFischer on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @09:38AM (#2382523)
Indeed. That used to be said of eolic energy (wind power). For example you can see a cost breakdown in 2005 here:

http://www.mnforsustain.org/windpower_schleede_costs_of_elec...

I believe the energy costs are now competitive (but wind still cannot serve as "base" power), but my yet-unresearched hunch is that solar is still at the same stage that wind was: only viable due to the massive tax breaks.

Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by puredemo on Monday March 28, 2011 @11:54PM (#2381291)
Where do you get your energy news from?
Re:MIT's artificial leaf is ten times more efficient than th... by berntb on Tuesday March 29, 2011 @12:32AM (#2381344)
I don't really follow it either, just some tech/science news outlets that waste my time by covering [edit: Energy], too... :-)