Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by ScottFree on Saturday July 11, 2020 @11:07PM
(#23808456)
> Ten years from now no one will even remember or care that master/slave was a term in computing.
I don't think it will take them that long to regret this change. Now that everyone knows linux will just roll over, they'll push for greater changes to the "Code of Conduct." Then developers will get deplatformed at an alarming rate. And I'll have my popcorn ready. It'll be quite the show.
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by nathanaldensr on Saturday July 11, 2020 @11:40PM
(#23808608)
It seems like nowadays that's where concessions on visible efforts the likes of the Linux kernel go, inevitably.
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by ScottFree on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:11AM
(#23808739)
It's not inevitable. It can be resisted. It takes a leader who can stand up to the pressure and say no. That's not a trivial thing. The pressure is considerable, especially these days.
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by sneak on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:44AM
(#23808885)
What evidence do you have that suggests that these reasonable changes will lead to further unreasonable changes?
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by ScottFree on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:23AM
(#23809061)
munches on popcorn
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by H8crilA on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:54PM
(#23808368)
> they're worth making to demonstrate exactly how arbitrary language is to change
Why is that so important? Also, who doesn't know that? Plenty of changes over the past few decades, for example "restroom". Language changes all the time.
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by Yetanfou on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:57AM
(#23812271)
Not good, it only serves to increase the precedent for hijacking unrelated concepts for political purposes. Language has meaning, twisting that meaning to ascribe negative connotations to terms is divisive and counterproductive. Calling everything and everyone racist devalues the term 'racist' after which a new term for (the actual concept of) racism needs to be found.
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by jimbob45 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:56PM
(#23808387)
Well I now go out of my way to use those terms wherever I can. Iām not personally a fan of doublespeak or censorship though.
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by tuesdayrain on Sunday July 12, 2020 @08:08PM
(#23815837)
I'm not certain that the cost actually is low. My company also announced that they'll be making similar changes. They mentioned there are over 4000 mentions of "master" in our Confluence docs. And they're all not in the same context, so someone will have to read over each instance and change it on a case by case basis. Between these changes and all the PRs that will have to be created to remove master branches / alter CI pipelines, etc., this will easily require thousands of dollars worth of wages. Globally, this is a multi-million dollar effort. And for what gain? Are slaves around the world going to appreciate that techies will no longer be burned with being reminded of their existence?
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by iso8859-1 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:53PM
(#23808357)
Are there any 20 year old examples of terms with the popularity of master/slave that everybody has forgotten?
Re:Merge tag 'inclusive-terminology' into Linux kernel
by ksaj on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:58PM
(#23808404)
I'm surprised at how many people don't initially remember what Y2K means, since it was a huge thing that everybody was talking about about for about 6 months before and 2 weeks after. Mention it now, and virtually everyone says "Hah, I forgot about that!"
Ten years from now no one will even remember or care that master/slave was a term in computing.