News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Trail Router – generate running routes that pref... by karussell on Saturday July 11, 2020 @07:13PM (#23807026)
I just wanted to reply this cannot be as Komoot is also using CH (fast routing algorithm using GraphHopper) but yes, they are relative slow for fast routes. The reason seems that they create a very big response (5MB) in these cases and then it takes more seconds to visualize this. For current & original GraphHopper the response is highly optimized and so it is much smaller (20x) even with comparable road data (like elevation, surface, bridges/tunnels and road class)

btw: in general Komoot is a nicely polished app. I can only recommend it :)

Re:Show HN: Trail Router – generate running routes that pref... by donjoe on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:19AM (#23809300)
I absolutely agree. Routing using a phone is loads of fun. I do have the paid version and I highly appreciate their open source-ish character.

Besides large response data and a slaggish planning interface @ komoot: try routing from northern Italy to Sicily: Komoot doesn't seem to know the ferry departing in Villa s. Giovanni to Messina. Komoot will always - no matter how may vias you place - route you back north and send you on a ferry in Salerno. Yes, I know, I could split my route and such. Yet, I love the idea of my planning tool to show me the complete route - including official transportation ;-)