News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by mrfusion on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:35PM (#23803969)
Airplanes can crash sometimes. The result is horrible. Usually all lives lost.

But we still fly. Why?

It all comes down to the numbers. The crashes are rare.

What are the numbers here?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by throwaway5752 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:00PM (#23804187)
What an interesting thing! I can comment in a somewhat informed way about both.

In flying, you file flight plans. Air traffic controllers make sure they are followed and orderly. All passengers are highly screened before entering secure areas and employees/food is similarly screened before making it to a terminal. Some flight officers need thousands of hours of experience. When planes are repaired the procedures are exhaustively documented, need to be done by qualified staff, and the replacement parts need to be traceable.

In the case of neurological side effects of COVID , it's largely an unknown and it can be reduced immensely by wearing a $0.10 piece of cloth, modified social interactions, and contact tracing (see most developed nations outside of the US and Sweden). COVID risk mitigation is much easier.

To quantify it a little: the article indicates a roughly 4x increase in a particular severe neurological condition (ADEM) over background incidence rate, and serology indicates < 5% of population exposure in most places. The 4x rate is on adult ADEM cases, and is very likely just [a subset of] cases that pass a threshold on a distribution. It's reasonable to spitball a 50-100x increased risk of neurological side effects. It's probably much higher because of the well documented clotting disregulation and the spectrum of mild to lethal strokes, and the structural damage strokes cause beyond that.

Ultimately, since the scientists in question are experts, I trust them instead of thinking I know better. I was wrong about mask efficacy early in the year, and that was humbling. Most of the scientists have studied this stuff for decades and the best strategy is to just listen.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by andrenotgiant on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:20PM (#23804349)
I don't think the OP is saying we should walk around without a mask.

They're just saying:

- Normally, one in 5.5 million UK residents tests positive for ADEM each year

- Since COVID-19, those odds are looking more like one in 1.4 million

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by throwaway5752 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:34PM (#23804493)
We have a highly infectious virus in populations with no immunity. Across age ranges it has led to an increase in hospitalizations for ischemic stroke. This is completely in line with observed covid associated coagulopathy damage to other organs. It is likely that there is a high incidence of sub-acute cases that might lead to measurable population level cognitive deficit by the time this is done.

Until we have more hard numbers, this is really bad and it would be smart to react conservatively.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by leereeves on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:55PM (#23805331)
>>> It's reasonable to spitball a 50-100x increased risk [of ADEM].

>> Normally, one in 5.5 million UK residents tests positive for ADEM each year

If those statements are accurate, the new spitballed risk of ADEM would only be 1 in 55,000.

That's not going to lead to measurable population level cognitive deficit.

Nor should it change our perception of how dangerous COVID is, compared to a roughly 1 in 200 risk of death.

>>> It's probably much higher because of the well documented clotting disregulation and the spectrum of mild to lethal strokes, and the structural damage strokes cause beyond that.

Perhaps, but that's just speculation. Where is the evidence?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by koheripbal on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:11PM (#23804275)
There's a lot of unknowns in those numbers - and a 50-100x increase in a somewhat rare condition isn't particularly helpful.

We need solid number to make informed decisions about risk.

This isn't about whether to wear a mask or not (anyone with a brain wears a mask) - this is more about whether to shut down schools and the economy.

> the scientists in question are experts, I trust them

Agreed, but they still aren't giving us NUMBERS.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by throwaway5752 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:19PM (#23804335)
I don't know what you expect. This disease is about 8 months old and everyone is still learning a lot. First of all, you're being kind of demanding. Why don't you collect the numbers? The authors, in many cases, are busy on the side treating waves of critically ill covid-19 patients.

Also, this is from the journal "Brain". It's not in a epidemiology journal. They are just neurologists describing a possible tie between a new virus and a constellation of neurological symptoms. https://academic.oup.com/brain/article/doi/10.1093/brain/awa...

They call for further study in their abstract. This is a new discovery and you want population statistics? They want population statistics, too. The NUMBERS don't exist yet, because they published this on THURSDAY.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by leereeves on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:31PM (#23804462)
Perhaps Reuters should have waited for more information before writing this article.

Warning about a "potential wave of Covid-linked brain damage" when it's likely to be a rare complication is not responsible journalism.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by modmans2nd on Saturday July 11, 2020 @06:57PM (#23806899)
Why? Because people shouldn’t know about something scientists are investigating or because you think Covid19 is over blown and this is just another thing in the bucket of “it’s not over blown” and you don’t like that?
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by gremlinsinc on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:47AM (#23809397)
Some people have a really bad day if you hurt their bucket of cognizant dissonance. They have an image of the world if you chip at it in any way, it just pisses them off. You can't convince these people. I'd like to say I've given up.... but my facebook feed says differently lol.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by leereeves on Sunday July 12, 2020 @06:33AM (#23810359)
Well, isn't this interesting. On this same thread I'm being downvoted for correcting another comment's outdated quote of the CDC's estimated IFR. I posted the latest (higher) figure from the CDC, which increased the estimated number of people who will die, and some folks didn't like that.

And over here modmans is accusing me of thinking Covid19 is over blown, while you accuse me of cognitive dissonance. It seems to me that you simply dislike any suggestion that Covid19 is less serious than you think, while other people dislike any suggestion that Covid19 is more serious than they think.

Here's what I think: I think honest, factual discussion of this topic is important, and that includes considering all facets of the evidence. I think describing a rare complication as a "potential wave" is overblown. And I think the level of discussion of this topic, even here on HN, is among the worst I've ever seen.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by fzeroracer on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:48PM (#23804644)
> this is more about whether to shut down schools and the economy.

Can you give me any reason why schools should not be shutdown?

What happens when teachers catch the virus? Is the expectation that they should come to work? If they're supposed to quarantine for 3ish weeks, who fills in for them? And what do you think happens when large portions of the school catch the virus, or kids catch it and bring it home to their parents and family?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by koheripbal on Saturday July 11, 2020 @05:46PM (#23806351)
Because kids not going to school means parents can't go to work - which means they cannot pay their mortgage/rent.

There are a lot of horrible things that happen when the economy shuts down.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by fzeroracer on Saturday July 11, 2020 @06:59PM (#23806915)
Okay, but you didn't answer my question.

Kids go to school, the coronavirus rapidly spreads and then the school has to shut down again. What exactly did opening up the schools in the first place even do?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by koheripbal on Sunday July 12, 2020 @12:46PM (#23812663)
IF opening schools meaningfully contributes to hospitals filling up with deaths and (potentially brain damaged patients), then of course.

...but the degree to which that is true is the exact data we're asking for here.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by fzeroracer on Sunday July 12, 2020 @04:12PM (#23814372)
Okay, but again you keep dancing around my actual question. You're not talking to me at all, you're talking so far past me that either you're ignoring my arguments or not seeing them.

If a teacher or a student catches the coronavirus, is the school supposed to stay open? If a teacher gets sick and has to stay home, who replaces the teacher? Who will risk themselves also getting sick to come in and substitute when there are confirmed coronavirus cases?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by thu2111 on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:33AM (#23809577)
You know kids don't get infected at all, right? Or at least that's the latest "scientific consensus". There's no risk from schools re-opening, but children trapped at home unable to see their friends or learn things definitely has risks for them.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by jshaqaw on Sunday July 12, 2020 @08:21AM (#23810797)
Plenty of adults work at schools. I understand the frustration. I cry for the lost year here in my kids’ lives. But I’m also not thrilled to sacrifice teachers and other educational workers on a bonfire. Will you personally volunteer to spend days in cramped classrooms with 25 kids?
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by thu2111 on Monday July 13, 2020 @08:36AM (#23820063)
Where would this "bonfire" come from? Have other professions experienced with a "bonfire" when they went back to work?

Will you personally volunteer to spend days in cramped classrooms with 25 kids?

Volunteer, no, obviously not. Pay me more than what I get now, sure. I'm not afraid of children. Nor am I retired or in any risk group. I know the data about the risks perfectly well - I'm in far more danger from simply getting to and from the school in the first place. It's other adults that can infect me, not children:

https://www.rivm.nl/en/novel-coronavirus-covid-19/children-a...

Worldwide, relatively few children have been reported with COVID-19, the disease caused by the novel coronavirus. Data from the Netherlands also confirms the current understanding: that children play a minor role in the spread of the novel coronavirus. The virus is mainly spread between adults and from adult family members to children. The spread of COVID-19 among children or from children to adults is less common.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by fzeroracer on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:30AM (#23812068)
Where did this 'kids don't get infected' lie come from? Kids absolutely can catch the coronavirus, it's just far less likely to cause adverse effects.

They're still a vector of infection which means they're going to spread it to their family or teachers who can and will get sick and suffer adverse effects. Saying that there's no risk is wrong and harmful to spread.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by thu2111 on Monday July 13, 2020 @08:39AM (#23820095)
Lie? Given how much chaos and contradiction comes out of the public health establishment every day, do you really think people who disagree are just lying, or have they seen other reports than you?

https://www.rivm.nl/en/novel-coronavirus-covid-19/children-a...

Here's the public health arm of the Dutch government summarising the evidence:

Worldwide, relatively few children have been reported with COVID-19, the disease caused by the novel coronavirus. Data from the Netherlands also confirms the current understanding: that children play a minor role in the spread of the novel coronavirus. The virus is mainly spread between adults and from adult family members to children. The spread of COVID-19 among children or from children to adults is less common.

No lie - current best understanding.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by xaedes on Tuesday July 14, 2020 @10:45AM (#23832566)
two statements:

"You know kids don't get infected at all"

"relatively few children have been reported with COVID-19,"

So, do get kids infected (at all) or not?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by rurban on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:15PM (#23805507)
The reasons to keep schools open are simple: Kids from 1-10 are immune against COVID-19 and they don't spread the virus.

The risk for kids 11-18 is lower than the risk to survive the traffic to school. The risk to transmit from those older kids to their parents or grandparents are higher, esp. with comorbidity factors. So parents need to decide by their own. Note that parents need to decide that for every years flu season. This year's flu season is pretty soft on kids, and higher risks on normal age groups - in the US only, everywhere else the risk is lower. Most countries are below the normal morbidity rates this flu season. next year's flu season will be H1N1, which has a much higher morbity, but vaccines.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by koheripbal on Saturday July 11, 2020 @05:47PM (#23806363)
Kids from 1-10 are not immune. They still carry and spread the virus. They just don't get very sick.

There was a recent case locally where an infected child spread it to her entire daycare, infecting all the kids, and in turn infecting all the parents - one of whom died.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by mrfusion on Sunday July 12, 2020 @08:40AM (#23810899)
Do you have a link to that study?
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by jjcon on Sunday July 12, 2020 @09:17AM (#23811100)
> it can be reduced immensely by wearing a $0.10 piece of cloth, modified social interactions, and contact tracing (see most developed nations outside of the US and Sweden).

And what about Spain, Italy, Belgium and France? All have worse rates than those two.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by throwaway5752 on Sunday July 12, 2020 @01:38PM (#23813115)
What about them? Tell me about when the virus started spreading and before they started policy to prevent the spread? What has the spread been like since those policies were put in place? How does that compare to the US?

Here are the US and Sweden https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/us/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/sweden/

Here are Belgium, France, Spain, and Italy https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/belgium/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/france/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/spain/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/country/italy/

You can actually look at that within the US, which has NY/New England type curves (including Seattle, Michigan, Chicago, and San Francisco) and the Texas, Florida, Arizona, Louisiana, et al. type spread.

All of the examples you noted had large, uncontrolled spread in mid-March that was gradually brought under control in lockdowns, and kept low via social policy (mask wearing, distancing, testing/contact tracing).

To answer your question indirectly: Spain, France, Italy, and Belgium all together are currently having fewer new daily cases than just Arizona on its own. And Arizona has less cases daily than Georgia, California, Texas, and Florida.

The US would be the laughingstock of the world if it weren't so sad. The US response is too tragic to laugh at.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by lghh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:38PM (#23803995)
Airplane crashes are not contagious.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by mrfusion on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:41PM (#23804023)
Just to clarify, you’re saying because airplane crashes aren’t contagious, numbers don’t help us reason about COVID risks?

I for one would like to know if brain damage is a 5% risk or a .0005% risk. You wouldn’t?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by makomk on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:34PM (#23805137)
This has become a standard, widespread talking point for why it's obviously immoral to accept any Covid-19 risk whatsoever as a trade-off for anything else, even though we don't treat other death or injury risks this way.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by ForHackernews on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:53PM (#23804134)
Sure, but it's not just your own personal risk tolerance.

Getting on a plane involves accepting risk for yourself; taking covid risks involves risk to yourself and also imposing risks on others.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by Marsymars on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:38PM (#23804552)
I expect a hefty number of people would be willing to undergo controlled variolation for covid, where they'd be of no risk to others.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by mrfusion on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:04PM (#23804221)
I sort of disagree. Unfortunately many things we do put other people at risk. Driving for one.

I think people with especially high risk need to be looking out for themselves at this point. It’s not reasonable to ask the entire world to put their lives on hold.

(I know this is an unpopular opinion but it’s something we all have to address at some point)

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by api on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:57PM (#23804156)
Silicon valley and its larger orbit are all about exponential growth curves. It's weird to me that so many people dont get the concern about COVID. "But the numbers are so small!"

Elon is the most puzzling to me. He was one of the PayPal crew. I'm sure their initial numbers were small. I recall Thiel talking about how in the beginning they didn't understand what a rocket ship PayPal was.

Well... this thing spreads quite exponentially too if distancing measures and masks are not used, and lethality is at least 1% (higher among older people) not to mention potential lung and brain damage. You exponential curve junkies need to do some math.

Personally I think it will take a million deaths for Americans to notice what an exponential curve is. We are at about 140k right now. Given that its exponential that could be by October.

"But we can't afford to close any more!"

Other countries with competent leaders and a population that doesn't live entirely in a social media bubble fantasy world have slowed the virus to the point that they can now reopen cautiously. Canada recently had a huge hiring boom. China is back in business. We can't reopen because we failed the first time. We are incompetent from the top all the way down to the street level.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by acdha on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:02PM (#23804202)
It’s not that they don’t get it as much as they have a financial incentive to pretend otherwise. Elon Musk is not an engineer dispassionately analyzing a problem but a factory owner whose business is facing both a downturn in demand and substantial costs to redesign business operations to be safe under current conditions. The more he can promote re-opening as workers having to take on additional uncompensated risk, the more he stands to personally profit.

You see this all the way up to the top: nobody pushing for schools to have normal in-person classes has children or grandchildren who need to go to public school rather than being tutored but their business interests need you to have a place to send your kids so you can go to work.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by api on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:07PM (#23804239)
That isn't rational. What does he think will happen to demand when millions are dying and the government instituted mandatory curfew under a national state of emergency? I could see short sighted pointy haired bosses doing that but he seems like a systems level thinker. It would have made sense for him to advocate a strong response early some we can really get back to business.

Maybe he realizes that America is too dysfunctional to stop the virus so the whole thing is futile. But he's not saying that, and his Twitter history doesn't suggest someone who is afraid to say whatever he thinks. He's publicly blunt to a fault.

To me it appears he's drunk some bad kool aid. The fact that he's a brilliant engineer and a great businessman doesn't make him immune to being irrational in other contexts.

Another possibility is that he's trying to win a big SpaceX contract and must publicly echo the Trump line to do so. Trump is quite well known to personally go after anyone who does not echo his party line and feed his ego. Also possible that he does not want to risk Trump interference via the FCC with the Starlink launch.

It has to be one of the two things I listed. It's just too irrational and he's too smart.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by acdha on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:19PM (#23804345)
People are rational a lot less frequently than we like to think. Having a large amount of money on the line is an especially effective way to be tempted to avoid it and, as you mentioned, there are political considerations – he mostly donates to Republicans (presumably with business goals in mind), he has contracts which Trump appointees oversee, and nobody wants to risk being part of the next presidential tantrum. All of that makes it so easy to say “maybe the contrarians are right…” – and working conditions in the Tesla plant suggest that he wasn’t overly concerned with health even beforehand.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by sokoloff on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:15PM (#23804309)
> and lethality is at least 1% (higher among older people)

The first half of that claim is contradicted by most of the recent data I’ve seen, particularly among the young and otherwise reasonably healthy.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by api on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:17PM (#23804322)
Links? I see numbers like 4% on average globally, but those are likely skewed high due to tests being administered mostly to the symptomatic. I estimated 1% for that reason. I also ignored potential non-lethal but bad complications.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by sokoloff on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:26PM (#23804417)
https://ourworldindata.org/mortality-risk-covid#case-fatalit...

States that the case fatality rate for those under 50 is substantially under 1% (under 0.5% in fact). The infection fatality rate would of course be even lower.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by mrfusion on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:23PM (#23804388)
The CDC says 0.26% IFR over all age groups.

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by leereeves on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:40PM (#23804568)
That did say 0.26%, until July 10.

Now, that page says the best estimate is 0.65% IFR.

(Infection Fatality Ratio, Overall in table 1)

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by api on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:59PM (#23804750)
That's well over a million fatalities if it spreads across the US unchecked, and does not count complications.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by nkurz on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:28PM (#23805633)
Yes, if we assume a that 50% of the US population becomes infected, a .65% IFR means that over a million Americans will die. Yes, this does not count complications.

That said, do you now agree that your earlier statement that "the lethality is at least 1%" is contradicted by the CDC's current best estimate? If so, it would be considered good etiquette to say so, and to thank the other posters for providing you with better information.

Or if you still believe your statement is correct, you should explain why the CDC is wrong (or being misinterpreted) and point to an authority you feel is more trustworthy. As it stands, it feels like you are galloping: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by api on Saturday July 11, 2020 @05:44PM (#23806330)
1% may be a bit high, but over a million casualties is really quite awful. Are people okay with that?

I would be less cynical on the US response were it not for the fact that so many other countries have handled this so much better.

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by Hydraulix989 on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:11AM (#23809265)
Assuming the COVID-19 IFR is 0.2 (as discussed earlier), then it's on-par with seasonal flu. In which case, we should continue taking normal precautions like widespread wearing masks and social distancing, while especially vulnerable persons should continue sheltering in place. Closing "non-essential" businesses or shuttering medically-necessary surgical procedures again (such as tumor removal operations) are still extreme measures.

Stanford University Epidemiology Study: The infection fatality rate of COVID-19 inferred from seroprevalence data (the SF Gate article originally covering this study was taken down):

https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.05.13.20101253v...

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by api on Sunday July 12, 2020 @11:59AM (#23812283)
It's already well past a bad flu season with only a fraction of the number of typical flu infections. I have never heard of a flu that fills up ERs to past capacity as is now happening in many cities.

People are still repeating that it's just a flu?

Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by Hydraulix989 on Monday July 13, 2020 @04:39PM (#23825325)
Who is saying that? I'm only comparing the IFR.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by SpicyLemonZest on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:20PM (#23804363)
But it seems to me that your attitude here is a large contributor to why the US was unable to do well. I've consistently seen discussions framed this way from the start, just dripping with contempt for everyone who doesn't know the facts about the virus or doesn't understand what the right response is. It's impossible to build a cohesive social movement that way.
Re:Scientists warn of potential wave of Covid-linked brain d... by javiermares on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:41PM (#23804029)
i'd love to know, too. do we even know, yet?