News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by mysterydip on Saturday July 11, 2020 @09:30AM (#23802072)
Agreed, got some good insights in the article and I will be reading more as well.

Also explains the sequelitis of the video game industry: while new ideas/IP can succeed, it's a risk. People really want more of what they know. Consider a random platformer, or the exact same game reskinned as Super Mario.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by aikinai on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:16AM (#23802368)
A tangent, but this is one reason Nintendo is so successful; they know the characters sell, while at the same time understanding it’s not the characters but the quality of the game and that really matters and brings customers back for more.

That’s why they first experiment and develop a lot of game ideas looking for the most fun mechanics. Then after something is shaping up into a great game, they look at the IP catalogue and see what skin to put on top.

Edit: In general, but not 100% of the time. The Zelda team is mostly consistently the Zelda team and does set out with intent to make the next Zelda game, for example.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by gumby on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:09PM (#23804254)
> A tangent, but this is one reason Nintendo is so successful; they know the characters sell, while at the same time understanding it’s not the characters but the quality of the game and that really matters and brings customers back for more.

I think you undersell this comment: it’s far more than a tangent.

Nintendo and Bandai the only companies I’ve worked with who I’ve Consistently heard the term “fun” discussed at the executive suite level, or a level below. Back in the Ken Kutaragi days at Playstation (SCEI in those days) this was true as well.

Hasbro seems to value playfulness, but in my more limited experience The higher up the chain the less relevant it was. Could be that the execs took it as a given?

Never came up in any AAA titles I talked with folks about at the companies (but big disclaimer: I never worked on one!)

You don’t have to be Marvin Acme, but “fun” seems like a pretty basic value, while objectives like “engagement” I’d see as a consequence,not a primary goal. I think understanding this is what has made Nintendo so successful for decades, and has allowed them to survive flops.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by aikinai on Saturday July 11, 2020 @08:30PM (#23807505)
Oh, I just meant a tangent in the discussion. It’s definitely critical to Nintendo’s success!

Also, very interesting to hear your experience with the other companies.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by blackrock on Sunday July 12, 2020 @02:53AM (#23809425)
I used to love reading those Nintendo Power magazines when I was a kid. I can't believe they actually got people to subscribe to it. Most likely, it was parents who bought a subscription for their kids.

As a kid, I always marveled about video games. The wizardry behind it was always fascinating to me. And Nintendo elevated video games to an art form.

Decades later, I finally built my own basic video game, and I finally unraveled the mysteries behind it all. It's like you finally saw the true structure of the The Matrix in its coded form. And you said to yourself, there is no spoon.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by wincy on Saturday July 11, 2020 @09:56AM (#23802236)
Like Doki Doki Panic was reskinned to become Super Mario Bros. 2.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by chillee on Saturday July 11, 2020 @09:12PM (#23807753)
I think this is doing a massive disservice to Nintendo. Certainly, they have their "cash grab" franchises, like Pokemon, "New Super Mario Bros <x>", and arguably, Mario Kart/Mario Party.

However, Nintendo has always done a phenomenal job in reinventing their franchises - sometimes to the dismay of fans of that franchise. For example, take the 3D Mario games. They have continually reinvented the series, from Mario 64, to Mario Sunshine, to Mario Galaxy, to Mario Odyssey.

Or take Zelda. Breath of the Wild is a massive departure from the traditional Zelda formula.

An example where they've reinvented to fans' dismay has been Paper Mario. After Paper Mario: Thousand Year Door, fans just wanted more of the same formula. Unfortunately, they've often take the series in a direction that long time fans don't appreciate.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by dhosek on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:36PM (#23808262)
I recently read Mac B Cracks the Code (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1338594230/donhosek ) to my kids and there's a history of Nintendo as part of the story. They began as a playing card company in 1889, entered into businesses like making instant rice and offering taxi service before getting into toys in 1969 and releasing their first video game in 1973. They've got a long history of reinvention.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by heavenlyblue on Saturday July 11, 2020 @09:59AM (#23802259)
Isn’t there also a limited set of genres of games anyway?

Why would you rebrand Starcraft if the players only want a reskinned version of Starcraft 1? There’s probably not much new you can invent by trying a totally new RTS anyway.

We don’t reinvent football for example. Reinventing it would get rid of the whole industry around the watching of football.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by brutus1213 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:22AM (#23802401)
I think that is where creativity and imagination come in. I'll give an example I encountered recently. Northgard by Shivo Games. It is absolutely brilliant, thematically and mechanism wise, a re-take on the traditional RTS.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by lacker on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:55AM (#23802620)
New genres appear reasonably often. For example the “battle royale” genre, e.g. Fortnite, was only developed in the past few years.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by heavenlyblue on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:08PM (#23804250)
You could call that a full genre, but it’s nowhere near the creation of RTS or FPS genres themselves.

“Battle royale” is simply a recent development because up until recently we barely had any 3D shooters which had maps huge enough to allow for this style of play.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by magila on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:00PM (#23805377)
What really gave birth to BR games was the invention of the "eye of the storm" mechanic. From a technical perspective BR could have been implemented as a mod for Operation Flashpoint as early as 2001 (not coincidentally the genre has its roots in OFP's spiritual successor, ARMA). What was missing was a way to keep the pace of game from fizzling out as the player count dwindled. The blue circle in PUBG was a brilliantly simple and effective solution. It's one of those things that looks blindly obvious in hindsight and makes you wonder how it took so long for someone to think of it.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by catalogia on Saturday July 11, 2020 @09:54PM (#23808009)
> It's one of those things that looks blindly obvious in hindsight and makes you wonder how it took so long for someone to think of it.

Particularly since the movie Battle Royale had a mechanic that filled the same role (sectors of the island were declared off limits to force students to encounter each other.) Not quite the same implementation, but I think basically the same idea.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by toomanybeersies on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:57PM (#23808395)
I think it's due to the success of the Hunger Games franchise, which introduced the concept to (Western) pop culture.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by catalogia on Saturday July 11, 2020 @11:42PM (#23808614)
You're probably right that Hunger Games was the immediate inspiration for PUBG. I understand Hunger Games to basically be an American adaptation of Battle Royale though (and also derivative of The Running Man.) Battle Royale already had "cult classic" status in America by that time. The naming of the genre seems to support the notion that the public was generally aware of Battle Royale. Before Battle Royale the term was in use, but generally referred to free-for-all boxing matches. The modern use of the term to describe Hunger Games or PUBG seems to closely resemble the premise of the Japanese movie/book.
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by lacker on Sunday July 12, 2020 @03:03PM (#23813825)
It's one of those things that looks blindly obvious in hindsight and makes you wonder how it took so long for someone to think of it.

Multiplayer Bomberman had this back in the 90's! I loved that game in high school.

But yeah, combining it with putting 50 people in a FPS deathmatch came much later. In video games a whole lot of innovation is combining a few ideas that already existed somewhere else. Well, not just in video games, really....

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by erik on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:57PM (#23804728)
> “Battle royale” is simply a recent development because up until recently we barely had any 3D shooters which had maps huge enough to allow for this style of play.

It's often surprising how long it can take for things to become mainstream. The first Battle Royale mod dates from 2013. And Planetside supported hundreds of players in a single match back in 2003.

Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by KONAir on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:51PM (#23805307)
UT2k4's Onslauth and every Delta Force games disagree. Especially the ARMAs, which this "new genre" had been there for about a decade (even more with Last man standing mod/es).
Re:Why are toys such a bad business? by toomanybeersies on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:59PM (#23808407)
Battlefield, Operation Flashpoint, and ARMA (among others) had maps large enough for BR type gameplay almost 20 years ago.