News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by zelly on Friday July 10, 2020 @07:59PM (#23798055)
Imagine a Raspberry Pi secured onto a tree somewhere being powered by a solar panel and serving a website over 5G.

Imagine that Pi is running a SaaS product that generates revenue and pays for its own 5G subscription.

Now imagine that Pi is earning Bitcoin, pays for its 5G in Bitcoin, and puts up job postings online to get people (paid in Bitcoin) to provision and set up more replica Pis on other random trees in town.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by louwrentius on Saturday July 11, 2020 @06:48AM (#23801101)
I'm sad to see that this crypto-comment is now the top comment on my build. The one topic I really don't care about.

I just hope people will may be incentivised to build fun projects like these, copy my example and improve on it or create a variant.

Stats for mobile users: https://louwrentius.com/solar/index.html

Regarding the crypto stuff, please read this: https://louwrentius.com/cryptocurrencies-are-detrimental-to-...

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by rjakobsson on Saturday July 11, 2020 @08:35AM (#23801729)
I’m sorry, but you don’t seem to understand bitcoins intrinsic value proposition.

Loved the solar powered blog though ! Im looking at setting up my own now, thanks to your post.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by zippoxer on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:20PM (#23805556)
Ethereum's upcoming 2.0 release kinda solves the issues you raised there.

1. Energy waste: solved by staking instead of mining. See proof of stake [1].

2. Centralized mining: staking in Ethereum 2.0 should be possible with a Raspberry Pi 4, therefore the viability of joining the network isn't closely tied to your geographic location as it is with mining (mining is only profitable with cheap electricity & hardware, which is why China is dominating Bitcoin mining right now).

3. Facilitates crime: well, that's still a problem, but it's also a problem with other things that give anonymity. Is Tor detrimental to society? Is cash detrimental to society? Should we force everyone to stop transacting with cash since most crimes are done with it, and like China to force them to transact digitally where it can all be tracked by the government, banks and corporations?

4. No intrinsic value: you should check out what's going on with DeFi (decentralized finance) right now in the Ethereum world. Over $2B is locked into smart contracts, people aren't just HODLing anymore, they're playing. Sure, it's not used to save the planet just yet, but I definitely believe it will develop to be enormously beneficial to society. Would love to elaborate if you want.

5. Stability: solved with stablecoins. Basically, you transact with a token that keeps it's value stable against a real world currency. DAI is a good example of a USD stablecoin. This defeats the "ponzi scheme" argument as well, since you can interact with many smart contracts with a stablecoin instead of a cryptocurrency. Your choice. If you acquired a cryptocurrency (which is somewhat like a stock) instead of a stablecoin and lost money, it's your fault.

I really like your article, well said. The issues you've raised are still real and need to be discussed. Nevertheless, I argue that those issues can, and are, being solved...

At least 4 of these issues had no solution 10 years ago, but just like innovations (proof of stake, stablecoins) fix them, further innovations will slowly fix other unsolved issues as well.

[1] https://eth.wiki/en/concepts/proof-of-stake-faqs

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by bouncycastle on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:02PM (#23798815)
Reality check time!

- Raspberry Pi is way underpowered to run any SaaS on.

- There are no 5g providers that would accept bitcoin as payment. Highly unlikely there ever will be any.

- Bitcoin's network is too congested for it to be used for trivial payments such as subscriptions for SaaS.

- A bitcoin node takes hundreds of GB of storage itself. Bandwidth costs will probably be significant too. This means the SaaS would probably have a hard time getting to break-even.

- It may be more profitable to climb up the tree and steal the pi and then take its bitcoin private key (assuming there is a hot wallet). Competing SaaS may also look for rivals and take them down.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by beering on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:01PM (#23799102)
> - Raspberry Pi is way underpowered to run any SaaS on.

Probably sufficient if it's written in Go or another compiled language. Obviously depends on how much revenue you're making per hit, but certainly within the realm of possibility.

> - Bitcoin's network is too congested for it to be used for trivial payments such as subscriptions for SaaS.

There are alternative coins that would work quite well, if fees/txn is the concern. Current fees seem to be about $1.15/txn, which is quite high if you're only charging $5-10.

> - A bitcoin node takes hundreds of GB of storage itself. Bandwidth costs will probably be significant too. This means the SaaS would probably have a hard time getting to break-even.

Few people run a full bitcoin node, so I think it would be sufficient for this use-case to send txns to the network via a third-party service.

> - It may be more profitable to climb up the tree and steal the pi and then take its bitcoin private key

Honestly the human factor involved in the whole scheme is probably the hardest thing to make happen. There's maintenance, h/w failure, the difficulty of finding trustworthy contractors who don't need human guidance, etc.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by bouncycastle on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:42PM (#23799277)
Good points. The only thing I'll disagree here is that using Go doesn't make it magically faster. The SD card is also a performance bottleneck for any database intensive work. Although, some services may still be viable such as a VPN service maybe?
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by acwan93 on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:50PM (#23799306)
> - Raspberry Pi is way underpowered to run any SaaS on

Our MVP SaaS product was done on a Pi (Node.js backend), and several of our launch customers were using it before we deployed them to production. Helped us simulate micro instances and write more efficient code as we started to scale.

Definitely doable, but not for something as crazy as running Asana or Zendesk over.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by zelly on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:34AM (#23799806)
> Raspberry Pi is way underpowered to run any SaaS on.

Depends. Here's a random SaaS which I assume is making money:

https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/11984

A URL shortening service. Yeah, I'm thinking this could fit on a Pi. Database and everything on the SD card. Latency won't be great, but it should be possible, especially if you rewrote it in Rust.

It doesn't have to run a Bitcoin fullnode. It can run a SPV wallet which would take a few megabytes if that.

> take its bitcoin private key

Generate and store the key in a Hardware Security Module

The biggest killers are related to BTC. It would be difficult to pay for 5G with BTC (although there probably could be workarounds like how Purse.io has humans with credit cards buy your Amazon shopping carts in exchange for your BTC) and also difficult to get subscription revenue in BTC. Something like Libra could solve all these problems.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by kebman on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:25AM (#23800511)
> Raspberry Pi is way underpowered to run any SaaS on.

Now there's a sentence that triggered a lot of anecdotes to prove the contrary lol!

I gather that while it is indeed possible, I have my doubts as to how practical or economic it might be. Anyone willing to accept the challenge? ;)

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by bad_user on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:28AM (#23800057)
Who would pay for a URL shortening service, especially one that can lose your URLs?
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by raghavtoshniwal on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:48AM (#23800136)
Maybe? But only if it ran on a tree and was powered by the sun
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by czbond on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:40PM (#23799006)
Dream killer. Username doesn't check out. =]
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by louwrentius on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:02PM (#23798069)
I'm sorry, I was nodding along when I stumbled over the 'bitcoin' word. That's a big no from me and the reason is probably not hard to guess in light of this project.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by gwicks56 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @02:09AM (#23799972)
"Can you please show me the benefit to society of cryptocurrencies?" Sci-Hub? Wikileaks? Medical Marijuana?
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by zelly on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:06PM (#23798096)
If you're concerned about energy usage, there are much bigger fish to fry than Bitcoin mining. But if you want, s/Bitcoin/Libra. A computer can't get a bank account, but it can get a crypto wallet.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by louwrentius on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:10PM (#23798121)
I'm opposed to the whole concept of cryptocurrencies.

Google 'cryptocurrencies louwrentius' to understand my position.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by shpongled on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:49PM (#23799040)
From your article:

> Cryptocurrencies have no intrinsic value. They are only worth what people are willing to pay for them.

How is this any different from US dollars, gold, or anything besides food, medicine, and shelter?

> Cryptocurrencies facilitate crime

Once again, the same argument could be applied to US dollars

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by sbmthakur on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:04AM (#23799659)
Precious metals have been sought by humanity for ages because of their strong resistance to oxidization and fiat money is backed by governments. There is also a strong oversight on both of them by various organizations. These are the reasons why people are usually willing to pay for them.

At the moment, I do not think major cryptocurrencies have any of those qualities. Though it could change if all major governments have a favorable view towards it.

https://www.loc.gov/law/help/cryptocurrency/world-survey.php

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by dhosek on Saturday July 11, 2020 @12:41AM (#23799556)
US dollars are the only accepted means to pay taxes. This is the big thing that makes national currencies work. Having a government behind a currency may not be a sufficient guarantee of value but it is, at least so far, a necessary one.

For bitcoin at least, it's an intrinsically deflationary currency. There's no incentive to spend a bitcoin today if it will be worth more tomorrow, so it ends up being primarily a currency of choice for transactions which are unfeasible in any other way, which ends up being primarily illegal transactions.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by _eht on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:26AM (#23799760)
>US dollars are the only accepted means to pay taxes.

I agree with this, of course. But there is also a method that allows me to convert my AUS dollar in to US dollar. I just paid my taxes with $AUS?

Does the logic follow: $BTC->$USD->USTAXES ?

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by notahacker on Saturday July 11, 2020 @05:45AM (#23800807)
Your ability to convert your Aussie dollar holdings into US dollars with ease is contingent on there being a relatively stable demand for Aussie dollars, which are the only legal means of paying taxes in Australia, and settling debts denominated in Aussie dollars. Cryptocurrencies are not a legal means of payment of taxes and are not created as debt so lack that guarantee that people will want to exchange significant quantities of USD for that coin [I guess in theory some cryptocurrency could have the property of being emitted as debt, but I'm not sure decentralisation and credit creation go well together].
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by _eht on Saturday July 11, 2020 @11:20AM (#23802797)
I think you missed the point I was trying to make. I haven’t had my coffee so that’s my bad.

As long as there is a means of conversion you can start with anything and end up being able to pay your taxes. You can’t directly pay taxes with your time and skills, but you can trade your time and skills for USD, and then pay your taxes. You can’t directly pay your US taxes with the AUS dollar, but there is a market where you can exchange that for USD, then pay your taxes. The logic is inclusive of BTC, which makes the ideology that BTC is bad because you can’t pay your taxes with it, at very least, murky.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by notahacker on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:01PM (#23803599)
Sure, you can convert anything to anything if you can find someone else that wants to complete the trade at a suitable rate.

Taxes provide [part of] the reason to believe a market to exchange Aussie dollars will exist in two years time: tax and Aussie-dollar denominated debt mean a lot of people need Aussie dollars. That's the only reason the Aussie dollar is worth more than the plastic its printed on. BTC doesn't have that reason [to any meaningful extent; credit is a tiny part of the economy and nobody needs BTC to pay taxes] and unlike the fruits of your labour [which I'd hope are more useful or entertaining than an alphanumeric string even if they can't be exchanged in future], it doesn't have any non-exchange-related reason to be worth anything either. The some-people-need-it-to-pay taxes argument is why Aussie or US dollars aren't bad despite being as intrinsically useless as BTC.

So the argument is that BTC is bad because both intrinsically useless and almost entirely lacking a mechanism [similar to taxes] to create a stable flow of future demand to acquire it

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by HeadsUpHigh on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:44PM (#23804060)
>US dollars

You can pay taxes with dollars and buy oil anywhere in the world. And the US government will send the strongest army in history against anyone who will try to decline US dollars for their oil.

>gold

Gold is naturally rare and has a much wider network of places that will accept it as payment.

>food, medicine, and shelter

Because you can use those for actual real-world things? How is that even comparable?

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by shpongled on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:58PM (#23805906)
Food, medicine, etc have intrinsic value. That's what the OP is talking about. The US gov't says that the US dollar has value and is willing to back it up. That is extrinsic value.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by strombofulous on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:22PM (#23798189)
I agree with that but these are specifically RPIs running on solar power (which, btw, will be useless for mining btc), so they will be completly wasteless (the energy goes to waste otherwise). The only exception would be if you somehow rose the cost of mining for others, which would not happen since you're using pis to mine btc. Except I guess the environmental cost of producing these pis, but unless you buy tens of thousands your purchase would be a rounding error
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by loktarogar on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:51PM (#23798735)
locally no impact, globally supporting a system that burns enormous amounts of power (of which much is co2 producing).

would be a cool little project, and it falls to you to decide which side of the ethics of it you subscribe to.

I would love to have a little cryptocurrency miner, completely self sufficient, just doing its own thing until it dies. but I would also love a cryptocurrency that didn't have the same kind of environmental impact that bitcoin has. maybe another application? selling computing power?

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by Retric on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:29PM (#23798596)
Every project is a global rounding error environmentally, that doesn’t mean they’re harmless. The real yardstick is simply a cost vs benefit equation as we can’t mitigate everything. On that scale a project trike this is extremely harmful as the benefit is nonexistent and the harm is real.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by forgotmypw17 on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:24PM (#23798561)
Are you also opposed to automobiles?
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by asveikau on Saturday July 11, 2020 @12:27AM (#23799499)
I am, or at least I think they should be used sparingly.

They destroy the planet. And on a personal scale, over-reliance upon them encourages lack of exercise and a needlessly stressful life spent in traffic.

I reckon we could make a big dent in pollution and obesity rates by having most people reduce their car usage.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by dvtrn on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:54PM (#23798747)
You inclined at all to explain where you see these two being comparable? I’m lost as to what it is you’re trying to say with this statement.
[dead]
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by dvtrn on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:11PM (#23799139)
Sorry of my brevity caused you any frustration but I find it’s usually easier to ask questions and seek mutual understanding and clarity rather than make assumptions and accusations about intentions and torpedo the conversation before it’s even got going.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by giantrobot on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:49PM (#23799042)
Check out LibraryBox/PirateBox. While not typically featuring a cellular connection they're at least an independent host for files/wiki/whatever and meant to be self-sufficient.

http://jasongriffey.net/librarybox/

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by rvz on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:09PM (#23798476)
> pays for its 5G in Bitcoin, and puts up job postings online to get people (paid in Bitcoin)

'Cryptocurrencies' would have been a better mention that I would agree with rather than just only to use Bitcoin.

In this day and age, It's a good time to be in the business of building and selling these shovels i.e Solar Panels to people who aren't able to do this themselves.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by pankajdoharey on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:18AM (#23799723)
Yup that is what 'Joe Armstrong' @joeerl once suggested' https://twitter.com/joeerl/status/1055808039369039872%3Fs=20...
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by vkou on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:34PM (#23798264)
It the Pi is providing a useful service that people are paying dollars for, that it then uses to pay for its 5G subscription, why introduce intermediate steps of converting its money to bitcoin, gold boullion, or pirate treasure, in order to pay someone?
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by zelly on Friday July 10, 2020 @08:58PM (#23798421)
I'm imagining that the Pi is an independent agent, not owned by a human, and therefore can't get a bank account. The Pi is paid in Bitcoin to begin with, so no conversion is necessary. The assumptions are that there is a 5G service that can be bought with Bitcoin and that the Pi can supply a lucrative enough service to get paid enough to reproduce itself.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by agumonkey on Friday July 10, 2020 @09:29PM (#23798593)
Wanted to put solar powered sparse mesh networks in forest as emergency trackers..
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by pmlnr on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:32AM (#23800533)
Lorawan. You want lorawan.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by RcrdBrt on Saturday July 11, 2020 @10:03AM (#23802287)
LoRa as a Data Link and thr RadioHead library on top of it is probably more flexible
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by samcodes on Saturday July 11, 2020 @12:51AM (#23799606)
Not to nitpick, but wouldn’t Etherium Be the right cryptocurrency? I try to ignore it, but I remember that that’s the “smart contracts” one, so it could make the job contracts in such a way that if they are completed, payment is automatic or something?
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by zelly on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:49AM (#23799879)
How would the contract know that the job is completed? Ethereum contracts can only access events on the chain itself. There is no way to go out to the network and, say, ping the new Pi, because there is no way to cryptographically verify that this happened. So some off-chain server somewhere has to issue a command (with some private key) to the contract to say, "Yes, I checked that the work was done, you can disburse the funds". In which case you never needed the contract anyway and just could have sent the money directly.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by ClumsyPilot on Saturday July 11, 2020 @08:24AM (#23801651)
You know there is this device thats much faster, powerefficient and has 5G - a phone or a tablet! You could write write an app for Surface X or similar.

Anyway, i am just fighting the Pi-obsession, there are much more capable devices out there.

Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by pmlnr on Saturday July 11, 2020 @04:31AM (#23800530)
Imagine a similar device, embedded into tombstones and monuments, forever serving hotspots with content to remember to the dead, maybe even running their archived blog and content.
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by flobosg on Friday July 10, 2020 @10:06PM (#23798837)
Sounds like Universal Paperclips!
Re:This Blog Is Now Running on Solar Power by vbezhenar on Saturday July 11, 2020 @05:15AM (#23800695)
Also fix bugs, review commits, etc :)