News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by jfengel on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:20AM (#23792387)
I suspect that you have objects of sentimental value as well. Most people do. Perhaps it is a book given by a friend that you don't throw away, even though you never read it and, if you had to, could replace it for a few dollars. Perhaps it's an autograph from a celebrity, or a prop from a movie.

Sentimental value isn't rational, but it's innately human, and practically all people practice it. The art market in particular is famous for expanding it to some ludicrous levels, where sentiment is given a dollar value in the seven and eight figures, but it's mostly just rich people playing on exactly the same emotions you have, with more money.

It's complicated by additional factors of competitive culture and possibly some money laundering, but at the base of it is a feeling that a piece of art that "witnessed" history takes on a value beyond the visual conveyed on the canvas. Often, the artist was innovative in some way that's appreciated by fans, and that innovation is no less rational than a baseball that was hit out of the park at an important time -- even though it's just a baseball.

Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:26AM (#23792458)
I'm under the impression that sentiment plays very little role in bidding up art. Its a 'tulip bulb' sort of thing, where folks are trading the art essentially as they trade baseball cards, not because of intrinsic value (just a bit of paper or cloth etc) but because others may be expected to bid more later.
Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by goto11 on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:36AM (#23792600)
What is intrinsic value?
Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:18PM (#23793076)
You can look that up. It means something like, the materials or useful value (as a tool etc) gives it a price in the market.
Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by Falling3 on Friday July 10, 2020 @01:12PM (#23793744)
I'm sure the parent knows the meaning of the word, but was asking as more of a philosophical exercise. But funny enough, your example is still describing extrinsic value. Tools don't have intrinsic value. They're valuable because of a problem they solve. If they stop solving that problem or the problem no longer exists, the same thing happens to their value.
Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by JoeAltmaier on Friday July 10, 2020 @04:01PM (#23795736)
You've lost me. I was aware of both those definitions, and used them as I intended, I believe? Oh, its the tool issue. Its reasonable to value a tool for its inherent usefulness - that's intrinsic to the tool. Extrinsic value is just the market value. That one seems clearer.

Anyway I imagine the intrinsic value of a piece of art is, the joy it gives in interacting with it. Kind of the entire point of art after all. And notice, nothing in that about "who made it".

Re:In north Michigan woods, feds raid an alleged upscale art... by goto11 on Saturday July 11, 2020 @03:39AM (#23800336)
But it can give you joy to know who made a painting and the historical context of it.