As someone else said, the original paintings are worth more because they are one touched by the master. That history is valuable to certain people. I am not one of those people, and many others share the same opinion, they appreciate the art only for its aesthetics.
Interestingly, replicas of famous works are often much more expensive than original works by the same no-name artist. I have lots of originals from art students that I picked up for <$20 or so.
You see the same behavior in other fields. An original Mustang GT350 is worth a hell of a lot more than a replica, even if the replica is better in many metrics, because a small group of wealthy people value the heritage and history much more than the tangible good.
> FBI agents have identified eight probable forged paintings, five of which were billed as previously unknown works of Ault, an American artist active through the 1940s. Two other paintings were purportedly created by Crawford, an artist active through the 1970s whose precisionist style was similar to that of Ault, according to the search warrant affidavit. The last painting was purportedly created by Abercrombie, a surrealist American artist active through the 1970s.
To use your analogy, it would be as if someone created a car using Ford Mustang styling cues, but that wasn't a replica of any Mustang that Ford ever made, and claimed that it was a Ford Mustang prototype found hidden in a garage.
>You'd think paintings have an intrinsic value by themselves,
If paintings didn't have intrinsic value, then there wouldn't be a market for replicas and prints of famous of pieces. Yet, there is a market for such.
(There are a few paintings I would love to have nice replicas of on canvas, but I haven't yet tried any of the online replica factories for fear of poor quality)
We have a lot of street fairs with artists showing off their work, most are receptive to commissions and you can get an idea of capabilities by looking their work. Anymore, my favorite place is this antique store next to an art studio, the artist that owns the studio makes a lot of replicas (and original) to sell in the antique store.
Photography and other forms of reproduction changed people’s view of art.
There are a LOT of talented painters in the world, with incredible skills. But there’s only one Picasso. Buying an original is owning a tangible piece of history — an object that he touched with his own hands, which maybe then went on to tour museums around the world (and maybe bears the freight stamps from those travels on the paintings backside).
Otherwise you can just frame a perfect reproduction or poster.
But broadly speaking, photography emerged at a time where the aim of most painters was still to create a window into a world. It's no accident that Impressionism emerged at the same time as the avant guard reaction to that. Which then led to abstract expressionism, etc – the idea that a painting is an object in and of itself. That the surface of the painting (the texture, the geometry of the composition) is what's interesting; rather than it being a vehicle for depicting some image.
Someone could make a frame by frame reproduction of a Kubrick film, or cover a Bowie song as faithfully to the original as possible. There is some value in the execution, the talent needed to pull it off. There's so much more value in the idea, the situation that led to its development, the blood, sweat and tears.
It just so happens that in fine art there is scarcity and that drives the price up.
Sentimental value isn't rational, but it's innately human, and practically all people practice it. The art market in particular is famous for expanding it to some ludicrous levels, where sentiment is given a dollar value in the seven and eight figures, but it's mostly just rich people playing on exactly the same emotions you have, with more money.
It's complicated by additional factors of competitive culture and possibly some money laundering, but at the base of it is a feeling that a piece of art that "witnessed" history takes on a value beyond the visual conveyed on the canvas. Often, the artist was innovative in some way that's appreciated by fans, and that innovation is no less rational than a baseball that was hit out of the park at an important time -- even though it's just a baseball.
Anyway I imagine the intrinsic value of a piece of art is, the joy it gives in interacting with it. Kind of the entire point of art after all. And notice, nothing in that about "who made it".
There is this attitude that it is somehow wrong to value authenticity when it comes to art, but I don't really get it. Surely an authentic historical artifact is more interesting than a fake.
I simply observe that the value was destroyed not by the artist that created them, but by the investigator. That much seems obvious.
But whom to blame? That's a human moral issue. I suggest we could reasonably blame the investigator.
If I faked a letter from Albert Einstein where he confessed to secretly being a Christian I'm sure people consider it of great value. Would it "destroy value" if someone figured out it was actually a hoax?
https://archive.org/details/related_communists/page/36/mode/...
I always find it interesting that some of these works are high value when everyone thinks that they are by a certain person, and worthless when they find out it is by someone else. This guy would probably never be known for anything, except that he sold some expensive paintings he made fraudulently. But he has talent in that particular area; but that sort of talent doesn't get you far.
You'd think paintings have an intrinsic value by themselves, but in art dealing, context & association is everything.