News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by MisterTea on Thursday July 09, 2020 @10:45AM (#23780833)
Do you need these services that badly that you're willing to get the government involved? If you don't like the product or the company ethics then don't give them money. The only lesson greed will ever learn from is No Sale.
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by pwinnski on Thursday July 09, 2020 @10:50AM (#23780897)
I don't follow your logic.

I don't need these services badly at all. But since they exist, and are predatory, they "naturally" interpose themselves between the restaurants and their customers unless great effort is made by both the restaurants and all of their customers to avoid it.

It's not a question of wanting or not wanting the services. Some of these companies are so nasty and predatory that they are very, very hard to avoid.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by uedue828e on Thursday July 09, 2020 @11:16AM (#23781163)
There isn't a single food delivery or ride hailing service in the world that is very very hard to avoid.
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by pwinnski on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:16PM (#23781796)
In the middle of a pandemic, that's simply not true.

Otherwise, sure, you just go get the food yourself in your ca--oh wait, ride hailing. In a taxi? On a bike? Within walking distance? But yes, just go to the restaurant, unless there's a global pandemic that requires many people to not leave their homes.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by uedue828e on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:44PM (#23782856)
Did take out or kitchens stop existing in your world? Do you really think grubhub or uber is even a rounding error in terms of how the majority of people get their food? There's being out of touch but your comment is a whole new level of reality disconnect. And your comment doesn't even make sense internally. You can't avoid ridesharing but you can't leave your house? LOL okay.
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by pwinnski on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:04PM (#23792918)
Please, calm down, and keep the personal insults in check.

I have eaten food that was not cooked in my home no more than six times since February. All but one of those times were takeout. I'm well aware of how both kitchens and takeout work. I'm very privileged in that sense.

However, I was practicing empathy. Many people do not have the options I do, and I'm not sure mockery is the best way to think about them.

You mentioned both delivery and ride hailing in your initial comment, so I made the starting assumption that you were talking about someone who doesn't have a car. If you don't live within walking distance of a restaurant offering takeout, and you don't have a car, how do you get takeout?

In the suburbs where more than half of Americans live, access to restaurants within walking distance isn't ubiquitous. Many restaurants in my state remain closed, including in my case, both of the restaurants within walking distance.

So, much of America cannot eat out, and some percentage don't have cars or can't drive due to injury or fear of the pandemic. That leaves cooking at home, yes, from groceries they've had delivered or taken public transit (quite the disease vector) or via ride hailing. And it leaves food delivery.

GrubHub reported 22.6 million "active diners" in Q4 2019. That's a small number compared to everybody in America who eats, but it's not a tiny number. And GrubHub isn't the only food delivery company.

My bottom line is that it may be easy for you or I to avoid food delivery or ride hailing services, but that is simply not true for everyone, and it's not even a value shared by everyone.

If you want food delivery, and many people clearly do, it can be very hard to avoid GrubHub and Doordash due to their slimy and unethical practices. If you don't want food delivery, then clearly this issue has nothing whatsoever to do with you.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by smolder on Thursday July 09, 2020 @11:59AM (#23781627)
Getting the government involved is exactly the right solution here, and they could implement a rule to keep things fair at near 0 cost. Our particular government being incompetent is mostly due sabotage by people who stand to gain from its continued incompetence.
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by caoilte on Thursday July 09, 2020 @11:24AM (#23781245)
Pretty sure a lot more greedy people have taken lessons from the carceral state than a no sale.
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by andrewla on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:17PM (#23781799)
No! Absolutely do not do this! Do not listen to this idea! Regulation is the wrong solution here! Warning! Jaguars will eat you if you do this!

Prosecute the dumb startups for breaking the law. Don't force everyone to comply with some stupid pricing regulations and fill out a trillion forms when they're not doing anything wrong. Legislators should legislate, law enforcement should enforce laws. Regulators will just be captured by private equity and forced to set rules to that make the regulatory burden higher and higher for new companies, unless they have "friends" who can "cut" the "red tape", which means being financed by these predators.

Regulation is the lazy answer for politicians who want to have no understanding of the issues of business responsibility, and just pay some unaccountable "experts" to decide what is acceptable.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by dml2135 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:50PM (#23782156)
I don't really see your distinctions here. Regulations have the force of law, and regulators are law enforcement.

Unless you are referring to some of the anti-trust laws which are actually criminal statutes? In that case I'm on the same page that we should actually start enforcing those.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by andrewla on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:20PM (#23783330)
I am referring to existing anti-trust laws, and I do favor criminal action in almost every case here.

Regulations do have the force of law, theoretically, but rarely have the ability to enforce at scale, and would much rather deal with a couple of giant companies rather than try to deal with a variety of different companies, so there's a natural push back in that direction.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by heisenbit on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:05PM (#23785223)
/s is missing.

There is this misconception that the absence of regulation is bad. But that is not true for sane appropriate rules. Absence of public rules is not a vacuum of rules but a universe where rules are made by the strongest.

Also laws do often not prescribe details but empower regulators to manage the details. There may be laws against predatory pricing. There is also case laws against predatory pricing. But markets also evolved and it us extremely costly and time consuming to prosecute monopoly cases based on principles (read up on e.g. the case against IBM way back). It is more efficient to put in place industry specific rules which then can be enforced with much simpler reasoning.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by andrewla on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:16PM (#23785320)
> It is more efficient to put in place industry specific rules which then can be enforced with much simpler reasoning.

I could not disagree more strongly. If you could point me to a rule that meets these criteria I'd love to see them -- all the rules that I've had to deal with in my professional life have been contrived to benefit the small number of companies actually capable of complying with them, rather than supporting the end goal of the regulation directly, and most of the time, allowed sufficiently large players to circumvent them entirely.

Antitrust legislation is hard to enforce, costly and time consuming, as you say, but it should be hard, and it should be time consuming, because the alternative is that you outsource the hard and time consuming parts to the industry, which is just "weaponizing the complexity" -- the cost to comply does not scale linearly with the benefits, so small players are just wiped off of the board.

(Note: I think you got confused with the double negatives in your first sentence -- you say "There is this misconception that the absence of regulation is bad" but I think you mean "There is this misconception that regulation is bad" or "There is this misconception that the absence of regulation is good". Not that I agree with you, but the rest of your post argues for sane regulation rather than deregulation)

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by heisenbit on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:28PM (#23785432)
Rules e.g. establish markets and enable competition: Standard screws or standard contracts. The absence of basic rules like disclosure of service prices is doubling the cost of US health care. Other rules force the airlines to compete on services and price but not on safety.
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by andrewla on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:12PM (#23786357)
This is a grab bag of regulatory and non-regulatory stuff.

How long do you spend in jail for making a nonstandard screw?

Standard contracts are industry standards (mostly) not government or regulated. Where contracts abut government function is enforcement and to some degree limitations and exclusions on what contracts are allowed to cover.

US health care is not easy to one-line, but I think you’d be hard pressed to argue that the space is not heavily regulated already, and yet mysteriously still has tons of problems.

Safety regulations I’ll grant you are probably a net benefit to society. Largely because limitations of liability make the situation too asymmetric.

Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by sidr on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:49PM (#23782145)
Do you have any evidence that this particular rule actually involves any additional cumbersome paperwork? Is this just a knee-jerk reaction to the word "regulation"? Would it be better if the word "law" was used instead?
Re:Portland approves 10% cap on fees that food delivery apps... by andrewla on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:18PM (#23783299)
The post I was replying to said "Or just regulate the dumb behavior of these dumb start ups to not distort the market in dumb damaging ways,"

I assume that the proposed regulation here was larger in scope than the Portland City Council rule, especially since that rule does not do anything to correct the market distortion -- arguably, it makes it worse, by mandating that they undercut economically viable approaches, rather than just letting them do so. That was what I was addressing.

This particular rule is innocent enough on the face of it -- it has only two requirements [1]; that they cannot charge more than 10% of the purchase price, and that they cannot reduce payments based on compliance with the first part. To enforce this (especially given how broad the definition of a delivery service is) will be a supreme act of discretion, and clarifying this rule and eventually handing it off to the local commissioners of the counties' health departments for enforcement will complete the slide into the endless land of bureaucracy.

[1] https://www.portlandoregon.gov/auditor/article/763323