News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @01:52AM (#23777308)
> Should that day come to pass, the money-issuer – the central bank – can procure all that idle labor, without creating inflation. If the private sector doesn’t want labor, then there’s no bidding war between companies and a federal jobs program or a universal basic income, so creating money to buy people’s labor won’t drive up the price of that labor.

I had to stop reading after this. This is not how inflation works and it borders on the preposterous to surmise that CBs can monetize deficits without creating inflation because there is excess supply in one market.

All of these people who would otherwise have less/no money are now spending that printed money to purchase goods like food, thus driving inflation higher. You can debate the merits of people being entitled to basic services like food, but the economic pressures are fairly well understood, even by MMTers

Re:Full Employment by skybrian on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:27AM (#23777516)
While I don't agree with Doctorow's argument at all, I would say that inflation is misunderstood more than it's understood.

For example, there is a naive belief that inflation is proportional to the money supply. This seems to be a garbled version of monetarism, which is no longer how central banks think about it, but even monetarism is more complicated than that.

Monetarist theory is based on MV = PQ, where M is the money supply and V is the "velocity of money".

The money supply can go up but velocity can go down (the people getting the money tend not to spend it), in which case there's no inflation. For inflation to happen, people have to want to spend more.

People can spend more or less due to fear, but it depends on the nature of the fear. Currently fear tends to make people spend less (if they can).

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:42AM (#23777608)
Yes this is all very true, but he makes the case explicitly for money velocity to increase. He’s not suggested printing money for savers or rent seekers, he’s suggested printing money for the express purpose of consumption: I have been automated and thus can not afford basic staples without basic income. This is inflationary not matter how you slice it.
Re:Full Employment by smallnamespace on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:57AM (#23777671)
It’s inflationary, but the wealth inequality, unemployment/underemployment, and recession we have are all deflationary forces, e.g. CPI inflation is well below historical trends since 2008.

The argument is we have room to nudge inflation back to normal while also helping people.

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:17AM (#23777755)
You’ve moved the goalposts. OP claims that it’s not inflationary. You’re claiming it’s inflationary but that it’s beneficial. I’m only taking issue with the former.
Re:Full Employment by skybrian on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:28AM (#23777812)
Well that depends. If it's preserving spending power (you were laid off) then it wouldn't be a spending increase. The supply was already there.

Inflation is an average of price increases. You get price increases when supply can't expand as fast as demand while keeping the price of inputs the same. This depends on whether there are supply bottlenecks and what the nature of those bottlenecks are. There have been some supply bottlenecks due to deliberate closures, but mostly temporary.

In a recession, the assumption is that there is extra capacity already, particularly for labor.

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:16AM (#23778052)
I think this thread is full of people confusing absolute inflation with relative inflation (“inflationary”). A policy resulting in zero absolute inflation can be inflationary provided that absent such policy, deflation would have occurred.

I took this with OP stating (incorrectly imho) that a certain policy was not inflationary. I am not advocating that all inflation is bad.

Re:Full Employment by charwalker on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:21PM (#23784004)
I'll take the side that you are right based on the argument in the article but there are better arguments to make. Right now other factors are driving inflation down like lack of consumer spending, consumers outright not paying rent, and that the US dollar is spread across billions of people outside the US where the dollar underpins their economy or USD reserves back their currency. These factors offset the on paper inflation of injecting $5 trillion into the US/world economy but if this was, say, 2017 then they would definitely not.

Our current economic situation is more like 2008/2009 than a boom year where the velocity of money, not technically perhaps but the idea more or less, is very high. Even the decade since the 2008 crash has seen low inflation, at least in the US, and we've seen double digit drops in revenue and sales volumes for several months let alone numbers for the rest of 2020.

For a relevant example here, would WeWork/Uber/Tesla have raised billions in private funding in late 2009 or early 2020? Did the last decade boom in private equity cash on hand drive ability to gain investment ex. increase velocity of money in private investing? None of those companies are critical day to day for US citizens or the economy, at least compared to major banks or grocery stores and maybe they did actually see huge investments during difficult times, but I think the thought experiment stands.

Re:Full Employment by Andys on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:42AM (#23777605)
But isn't the need to buy food to eat a certain guaranteed base level of velocity?
Re:Full Employment by skybrian on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:14AM (#23777739)
You do need a certain amount of spending, but that's M*V, not V. More money means less of it needs to circulate to cover spending on food. (If amount spent on food is fixed.)

But this is based on a very simple model that doesn't take inequality into account at all.

Re:Full Employment by js8 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:09AM (#23777719)
> I had to stop reading after this. This is not how inflation works and it borders on the preposterous to surmise that CBs can monetize deficits without creating inflation because there is excess supply in one market.

I think the government doesn't have to run deficits, it can always tax the money back out of the economy. (The only problem is nobody likes that, for some reason. People seem to prefer inflation to taxation.)

It's actually more honest, because it better shows what actually happens. Government prints money, (hopefully) invests into places that benefit the society as a whole, and then taxes the excess money back from wherever they ended up, destroying them (by not spending them again).

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:25AM (#23777795)
We’re not talking about the Treasury. We’re talking about Central Banks who lack the power to tax (directly at least).

> People seem to prefer inflation to taxation.

That’s because they’re not the same thing, not at all.

Re:Full Employment by js8 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:49AM (#23777914)
I think when Doctorow talks about the CB, he pretty much puts it under government at large. Which I think is fair, various attempts at making CB independent on the actual government are rather puny in my opinion.

Regarding inflation, you're right, there are other sources of inflation than just government printing money. Money are also created privately, and certain inflation is IMHO inevitable, because most goods and assets depreciate.

But I do think that the inflation, induced by government printing additional money, can be negated by taxation.

Re:Full Employment by evbpcapfxy on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:24AM (#23778384)
It's not too dissimilar if you think of from the perspective of the government taking away purchasing power from the individual
Re:Full Employment by michaelt on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:24AM (#23778388)
How is a 1% inflation rate meaningfully different to a 1% tax on savings and investments, and a 1% subsidy on debt?
Re:Full Employment by Negitivefrags on Thursday July 09, 2020 @05:42AM (#23778486)
It’s a tax on savings, but not on most investments which would typically be assets that rise with inflation.
Re:Full Employment by empath75 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @07:33AM (#23779034)
It’s a tax on debt issuers. Anybody loaning money will have to charge a much higher interest rate or they’ll get back less than they lent out.
Re:Full Employment by leetcrew on Thursday July 09, 2020 @10:57AM (#23780974)
> (The only problem is nobody likes that, for some reason. People seem to prefer inflation to taxation.)

the reason for this is fairly obvious. if you have a positive net worth, cash is probably a small fraction of your total assets, which limits the direct harm you face from inflation. if you have a negative net worth (ie, you have debt), inflation erodes the real value of your obligations over time. in general, this is already priced into the interest, but you certainly wouldn't want to see inflation decrease while you're repaying a loan, and you might be happy to see it increase.

Re:Full Employment by jusssi on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:02AM (#23777371)
> All of these people who would otherwise have less/no money are now spending that printed money to purchase goods like food, thus driving inflation higher.

This assumes those goods are a scarce resource, so that increased consumption eventually leads to shortage. I can't quote sources, but my understanding is that we have enough food to feed everyone ATM, and any remaining hunger is just a failure of the economy to solve the distribution of currency.

Re:Full Employment by climwe on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:13AM (#23777433)
Millions of potatoes were recently discarded by Idaho farms due to surplus and lack of demand. I would point to Yemen's hunger crisis, but there are people literally inside of Idaho who don't have food. If you can't even distribute excess food within your own borders it's no longer a logistics problem, people just don't care.
Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:19AM (#23777468)
These goods are scarce in the economic sense, even if you think they are “cheap”. They are not free to produce.

We do have enough food to feed the world, but that would mean your food gets more expensive as other people consume what would otherwise contribute to downward supply pressure.

Re:Full Employment by climwe on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:33AM (#23777550)
If there is excess food and it is given to people who would not otherwise buy food, there would be no negative effect on prices or the economy in general. Maybe examples of these types of people don't exist in America all that much but they certainly do in the rest of the world.

Your argument only makes sense if the excess food is given to people who can afford it and just want to eat for free.

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:40AM (#23777594)
I’m sorry, that’s just not how economics works. A market with excess supply necessarily has lower prices than one that is balanced, ceteris paribus.

Idaho potatoes were mentioned above. They are only being thrown away because the market does not want them. The mechanism by which this happens is price: prices drop low enough that it’s cheaper to throw away (we saw negative oil prices recently). One explanation is that other farmers saw this supply glut and raced to slash their prices. If we took all those excess potatoes and gave them away, then absent this excess supply, those other farmers would not have done this and prices would have remained steady or not gone down as much. Thus the artificial increase in quantity demanded is necessarily inflationary.

Re:Full Employment by Unsimplified on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:59AM (#23777678)
Incorrect. The use of discarded product by non-market flows has no effect on market price.
Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:18AM (#23777761)
You’re putting the cart before the horse: price came first, then the product was discarded.

The risk that these potatoes might be dumped into the market pushed prices down. If you magically take this risk away, it doesn’t matter by which mechanism, that threat goes away and price responds.

If I’m another potato farmer and all of a sudden all those extra potatoes are teleported somewhere else, I will in all likelihood raise my prices.

Even the most progressive theorists would not debate this. It’s basic aggregate supply and demand.

Re:Full Employment by Reelin on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:36AM (#23777843)
> If I’m another potato farmer and all of a sudden all those extra potatoes are teleported somewhere else, I will in all likelihood raise my prices.

There seem to be two different scenarios being conflated here.

You describe producers acting in response to the risk of future price changes.

It seems to me that others in the thread are describing a scenario where product is discarded because the price has already fallen so far that it is no longer profitable after accounting for various processing costs (ie things such as packaging and transportation).

In the latter scenario, if someone were to foot the bill for the redistribution itself there should be no direct effect on that specific part of the market. This assumes of course that the producers aren't compensated for the redistributed good (so it isn't significantly different than simply disposing of it). It also assumes that people don't resell or otherwise barter the product they receive (it's food and they're presumably starving so that assumption seems fairly reasonable in this case). (And of course there are bound to be countless indirect effects on the market as a whole.)

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:10AM (#23778011)
> It seems to me that others in the thread are describing a scenario where product is discarded because the price has already fallen so far that it is no longer profitable after accounting for various processing costs (ie things such as packaging and transportation).

I understand what people are saying. Unfortunately this just isn’t how things work. If there were a way for this to occur, prices would respond. Ultimately markets aggregate information and package it up in a single metric we call price. If all of a sudden there was a new future demand for some good, no matter how you frame it, prices will respond.

Re:Full Employment by Reelin on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:39AM (#23778167)
In the limited case where redistribution is equivalent to disposal from the perspective of the producer, and the food goes directly to people who are otherwise starving (ie literally incapable of purchasing food) I just don't see how that can be the case.

Obviously this includes a number of assumptions which might not hold. The redistributed product can't reenter the market. It must only go to those who otherwise could not have purchased it or an equivalent in the near term. The total value being redistributed must be insignificant relative to the market as a whole (to limit secondary effects). Etc.

> markets aggregate information and package it up in a single metric we call price

In terms of the movement of information, product that would otherwise have been destroyed seems irrelevant. Consumers who were otherwise incapable of consuming seem irrelevant. Am I missing something?

Re:Full Employment by ianleeclark on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:26AM (#23777799)
> It’s basic aggregate supply and demand.

Okay, so then we have absolutely no idea in which way the demand curve will curve then. If the demand curve can be any polynomial, then we have no clue if this will happen or not.

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:36AM (#23777844)
What? Nothing I said has anything to do with the demand curve. This is all supply side. We hold the demand curve constant for any such analysis.

But it’s irrelevant anyway: a basic tenet of economics is that people are, in aggregate, utility maximizers. So yes, we do have an idea of some fundamental properties of the demand curve and it cannot simply be any polynomial.

Re:Full Employment by ianleeclark on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:58AM (#23777955)
> We hold the demand curve constant for any such analysis.

And this is the portion that I'm critiquing. You're holding it as a constant curve sloping downwards.

> So yes, we do have an idea of some fundamental properties of the demand curve

Okay, sure, it relies on there being people who have demand for some commodity.

> it cannot simply be any polynomial

"Any polynomial" might be overselling it, but we can't assume it's sloping downwards.

Re:Full Employment by mlthoughts2018 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @09:45AM (#23780106)
It’s not free to transport and distribute the product though. If the surplus has driven down price, the supplier may also be facing a lack of revenue that means any extra cost on transport is too much to bear, even if they really wish they could donate the discardable surplus.

Additionally they may be able to count the discarded product in a business loss category that yields a better tax write-off or qualifies them for assistance in a way that straight donation doesn’t.

To me your example feels like a Chesterton’s Fence scenario where government involvement is responsible for disincentivizing the common sense option of donating a surplus.

Re:Full Employment by leetcrew on Thursday July 09, 2020 @11:03AM (#23781035)
it's not just the distribution of currency; it's the distribution of food itself. a lot of food waste happens because the cost of transporting and storing it would result in a net loss.
Re:Full Employment by kortilla on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:19AM (#23777469)
The problem is that all consumption levels stay the same but the production costs surge because a bunch of people aren’t working to help produce supplies. The only way inflation doesn’t occur is if all of the unemployed people were doing useless things that nobody wanted in normal times, which is not how most of the worlds markets function.
Re:Full Employment by woah on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:28AM (#23777520)
How many people do you need to grow potatoes?
Re:Full Employment by leovailati on Thursday July 09, 2020 @10:03AM (#23780330)
Exactly that! As I read the article, I kept thinking "this guy is not following the money".

The author's ultimate assumption is that money supply is somehow decoupled from accumulation. People receiving money from the government and using it to buy their basic needs may not drive inflation because their labor is not being procured by anyone else AND those basic goods they are buying would not be produced otherwise. However, the constant money stream will drive accumulation on the other side of the economy.

The owners of capital (or the 1%, however you may want to call them) would become unimaginably wealthy in a scenario like this. And it would be hard to prevent that. A super wealthy class is already a big problem today. Imagine the influence that group would have in politics if they had 10x the purchase power they have today.

Another problem that I believe exists with instituting a UBI through money creation (e.g., MMT) is lack of innovation and market disruption. It essentially puts a tax on innovation. In order to hire people you now have to be able to afford to pay more than the government and still have sufficient funds to fight well-established mega corporations.

Re:Full Employment by noelherrick on Friday July 10, 2020 @12:39AM (#23788212)
But think about this: if you're a startup founder, you can get co-founders for so much cheaper and more easily. If your buddy and you both know you have UBI, you can start a business without risking that much. The next hires can be lured with equity - this is a great thing because people have emotional and professional ownership in startups, but the one to three founders generally have all the equity. What if UBI forced those founders to both distribute equity and alongside that, the responsibility for the company? I think it would benefit all parties. Talking to founders, those first months and years are stressful as heck - I would wish that on nobody for any price. We can do better.

Think about startups before financing. Loans with interest used to be considered immoral - it's prohibited in the Bible. If you wanted to start a business, you had to save or find a lender that would let you take money and then just wait for you to give it back. And if you didn't pay it back, the lender could put you in prison. No wonder people didn't do that very often. Even with these new ways to fund a startup, you could lose your job and with it your income and healthcare coverage. What if that risk just went away? Of course some people would waste it, but think of all those folks that would turn their lives into hackathons until they struck gold.

Re:Full Employment by leovailati on Saturday July 11, 2020 @01:23AM (#23799742)
I am actually in favor of a UBI, as long as it is truly universal. That means money every month, no questions asked.

I agree with your point: under a true UBI, workers would be able to seek their passions, do whatever they like to do. Doesn't matter if the position is risky or if the pay is low. Worst case scenario, if anything goes wrong, people can fall back on UBI and have their basic needs covered.

In my comment I meant to talk about the guaranteed government job thing that the article mentioned. In that case workers wouldn't have the kind of mobility or guarantees granted by UBI. Startups would actually be competing with the government for people.

I apologize I misused the term UBI before (which is what caused the confusion.)

Re:Full Employment by ivalm on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:48AM (#23778215)
Inflationary policy in a deflationary market doesn’t lead to inflation (see US or Japan). There are lots of issues but I don’t think inflation is one we need to worry about.
Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:49AM (#23778222)
Again, this is not what I said. Inflationary policy in a deflationary market is still inflationary.
Re:Full Employment by ivalm on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:58AM (#23778262)
But irrelevant to the point he is making? He clearly intends to claim that the outcome is not inflationary.

I agree that in many points the article is not written carefully (and sometimes straight up wrong... Ca has no vent shortage, current thermal load doesn’t melt ice caps, zootonic pandemics even with current covid are not world shattering)

Re:Full Employment by wz1000 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:08AM (#23777405)
You're missing the point. There is no inflation taking the no automation stage as a baseline.

I.e. the scenario is workers spending $X of their employer granted salaries on goods they produce vs spending $X of basic job salaries that machines produce

Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:33AM (#23777553)
No, I’m not. You’re making a very simple argument of an extremely complex issue. That only holds up in a world of unlimited resource. As long as energy and raw materials are finite, the above does not hold.

More importantly, you’re conflating two things: we needn’t necessarily print money. Let’s presume your comment were correct. Nonetheless, in the absence of such monetary policy, consumption would plummet and deflation would reign. Thus, it is still inflationary.

Re:Full Employment by wz1000 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:12AM (#23778026)
Again, you are missing the point. Yes, it is inflationary, but the inflation caused will not be the end of the world. As you admit, most of it will simply counteract the deflationary effects of unemployment and full automation.
Re:Full Employment by zozbot234 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:21AM (#23778648)
If the CBs are missing their inflation/nominal income target, they can monetize deficits while not creating more inflation/nominal income flow than is warranted.

This of course gets into the matter of why we would want CBs to create inflation in some circumstances: the simple answer is that it makes the economy a lot more predictable if they do. When the flow of nominal incomes grinds to a halt, prices throughout the economy have trouble adjusting downwards in response, so we get a recession and widespread unemployment. Stability is what matters here, not just minimizing inflation at all costs.

Re:Full Employment by bob33212 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:04AM (#23777379)
Say that 100k truckers making 50k a year lost their jobs to self driving trucks, which cost 10k year. If the government paid those people 40k a year the demand and purchasing power for food would not change for those 100k people.
Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @03:30AM (#23777821)
Yes, it would absolutely. Purchasing power is (roughly) the ratio of production divided by the money supply. If supply of money goes down, purchasing power goes up and vice versa.

In your example, these truckers have stopped producing goods (services in this case). That means that production has gone down. If the supply of money remains fixed, there is more money chasing fewer goods and services. This drives prices up.

Said another way: if those truckers had less money (or no money) then they wouldn’t be competing with other buyers for goods, and prices would fall (purchasing power increases).

This is an extremely simplistic analogy and ignores other forces such as velocity and trade balances, but illustrates the point.

Re:Full Employment by function_seven on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:07AM (#23777397)
Sure, but the robot truck owners are also getting 40K additional per year, no? Or if they're not completely capturing the marginal difference between a human driver and a robot driver, someone elsewhere is, right?

Maybe the 40K labor savings is actually offset by a 37K a year replacement to the labor force, who also now enjoy lower prices on all shipped goods. (Assuming there is still real competition in shipping)

Re:Full Employment by bob33212 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:21AM (#23777478)
The 40k goes to the profits of the shipping companies, which goes to the dividends of the stock owners, who are generally spending the dividends on investing in more stock.

In theory shipping prices would go down immediately, but in the real world it could take years for competitors to force the industry to lower costs by the full 40k.

Re:Full Employment by function_seven on Thursday July 09, 2020 @02:30AM (#23777535)
I'm a bit out of my depth here (I always am when it comes to macroeconomics or monetary theory).

Let's say that the equity holders of the various shipping companies keep the $40k savings all for themselves, and use those profits to buy more stock. Isn't that still going to drive inflation? The price of shares will continue to rise solely due to more money chasing them. And every buyer of stock is giving money to a seller of stock on the other side, who will then do what with that money? If it's capitalizing a new company, then the money will be spent into the economy. If it's buying existing shares, then the seller will now have cash to spend.

Either way, the money is still an active participant in the money supply. Meanwhile the government is creating new money each year to offset the salary losses of the displaced truckers. What used to be a 40K transfer from employer to employee is now a $40k diversion to other uses at the employer's end, and $40k of brand new money on the employee's end.

Re:Full Employment by wz1000 on Thursday July 09, 2020 @06:08AM (#23778589)
From the article

> The 30% who are working under federal jobs programs will have working lives completely decoupled from the workings of the market. The movements of markets – particularly financial markets – will be irrelevant to everyone except for a group of weird, chart-watching, twitchy nerds who fulfill the boring job of capital allocation to an increasingly irrelevant section of the economy.

And earlier

> That money is mostly chasing the same goods that were available before the crisis (rent, groceries, and debt service) so it’s not crowding out other buyers and causing inflation (inflation occurs when more money chases the same goods, so buyers get into bidding wars that drive up prices – when the same quantity of money is chasing the same quantity of goods, there’s no inflation).

Re:Full Employment by cameronbrown on Thursday July 09, 2020 @08:03AM (#23779248)
Market competition will force prices down long-term. If they're not, that's a problem and there's probably an anti-trust suit somewhere that needs implementing. Also - investing in stock isn't a bad thing, because it's redistributing capital to entrepreneurs who are taking risks to make things better for everyone.
Re:Full Employment by zumachase on Thursday July 09, 2020 @04:13AM (#23778037)
Another commenter rightly noted that inflation is only partially driven by supply of money. The other factor is velocity of money, which is how quickly money is “recycled” within the economy. If that 40k is now going to investors who have a much lower propensity to spend it (likely) then velocity drops and so does inflation.
Re:Full Employment by fulafel on Thursday July 09, 2020 @12:13PM (#23781760)
Those people are already being provided necessities in richer countries paid from state issued debt, surely that causes inflation too according to your train of thought?