People on HN have no problem being optimistic. I was optimistic when I tried the product. I spent a good hour or so with several people on several devices in different locations using the app. We encountered problems, no instructions, confusing UI, the inability to see photos from users you were sitting next to, and in general we all felt that there was no useful feature in the app. We didn't get the app, then when we heard about the $41M in funding... we REALLY didn't get the app.
Speaking for myself, my comments were based on my experiences of using their product, the information they released to the press and my opinions based on the words of their employees. I don't think anyone could ask for much more from a group like HN.
That said, they set themselves up for it-- I'm amazed that (through a combination of common sense and user-testing) they couldn't anticipate the backlash. They should have either launched something that amazed/delighted users or stayed stealthy until they could. A private beta, some user testing, and a survey or two should've alerted them that they had an app that would confuse/alienate users. The funding or 2-star offering wouldn't have resulted in this kind of backlash alone, but together... Ugh.
They've now got years of runway-- Here's hoping the hole they've dug is small compared to the mountain they're going to climb.
I don't think it helps anything that they've had tons of press and the only things that have come up are 1) Bill Nguyen is awesome 2) they recreated some technology from the Dark Knight. If Bill's such an awesome leader, and they have 27 awesome people, and $41M, why is the app still horrible (interface, experience, data mining, etc.) at launch?
I'd honestly be happy for them if it takes off and it's the next big thing. And Sequoia usually gets it right, so I think everyone's just curious to know what's so great about this company and this app. But, we just aren't convinced yet.
Second, I found it difficult to enjoy the ride when the product, as released, was buggy and difficult to understand in both UI and user proposition.
I wish Hacker News members, who have zero vested interest in other people's startups, would be a bit more optimistic when it comes to publishing comments. Between Color, and various YC startup launches here - the place feels rather mean spirited, frankly.