Yes there is. If you set a precedent that you're going to cave whenever someone says they are offended, you're going to attract trolls pretending to be offended so they can have a laugh at your expense[1]. The whole master/main controversy might be genuine, but it's only a matter of time before 4chan comes up with another word/phrase for whites to be guilty about, and therefore need to be changed.
I just did some changes in a project I'm doing, and it's like 5 or 10 minutes work in my case.
Now do a multimillion lines of code, with non-statically checked codebases, multiple kinds of interface technologies and protocols, dynamic languages which can compose variable names, including "yeS_this_is_master", etc.
I know it's doable. But it has a cost.
Never in my life even for a second I had any connotation between words master and slave used in IT and any derogatory meaning for anybody. I don't remember a single instance in the past 20 years when I could possibly link any utterance of these words in IT setting to any kind of discrimination, derogatory meaning.
These words are just statement of facts, describing relationship. If not these, there will be other words to state exact same relationship with exact same meaning. Contrast this with the N word which is clearly derogatory.
Are we going to be renaming colors, too? Am I going to find a new name for the color of my car?
If you care for black lives, cooperating to find and work on an actual solution seems to me much more worth your while and shooting in everything that moves is wasting time at a critical point when time is of the essence.
These kinds of moves are only going to entrench the opposition, giving more arguments against and achieve nothing.
Neither can Master Wayne, according to Alfred, who is as polite as a school master. Of course, the Dark Knight did not have a masters degree, nor the spirituality of a Zen master, nor the concentration of a chess master. I am a certified dive master. I was close friends with several build masters. Of the great masters, Monet is my favorite. I hope to master my fear. Seinfeld fans still joke about being masters of their domain.
No downside indeed. Might as well sail into the sun on a three-master.
Uh. "Workers" has slave connotations. Employees. Wards of the State of Private Prisons. Hard Labor = Slave Labor. Are pregnant women now offended? WoMAN. I mean FeMALE. Damn this is hard..
But the comments here so far don't seem to do that, they seem to just be against this, with no alternative.
Top comment from an earlier discussion on this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23501861
Allowlist/denylist are perfectly fine if everybody uses them. But fragmented blocklist/denylist/etc sucks.
A lot of the suggestions for master/slave don't illustrate the same relationship between components, roles.
My concern is that this is motivated by the politician’s fallacy.
Is this the last remaining piece of racism in our society? No.
In my own experiences, being actively welcoming provides a level of safety that silence will not, because the status quo is that it is not safe for me to be myself, even if I might plausibly be accepted among my specific peer group.
Overall, these are small changes (what github is doing notwithstanding), and the amount of time onlookers have spent whinging about them far exceeds the time spent making the changes.
No, this won't address the most pressing systematic abuses by minorities, but it does make one of the most lucrative careers less actively hostile to them.
I can easily see how some people might be made uncomfortable by the existing wording, but more importantly, I can see no downside to changing it.
It will be a very small amount of work for a very small amount of time and then everything will carry on as normal. If this helps make programming more inclusive, even in a small way, then I'm all for it.