News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by lallysingh on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @12:41PM (#23760957)
I think this comes down to a lack of trust in good-faith debate. People don't trust that someone "from the other side" will actually have the empathy and generosity required to have a good-faith discussion on a topic.

Also, I believe that we're constantly hearing so many voices trying to convince us one way or another, that our own discussions on those topics end up being attempts to convince others. That would explain "safe spaces" to some degree -- people don't want the pressure of having someone else try to convince them of something they don't agree with.

Some of it just the two-party system. The points don't matter, just which side of the line each person is on. I wonder if more parties would help depolarize the situation. I'm really not sure.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @01:08PM (#23761352)
> That would explain "safe spaces" to some degree -- people don't want the pressure of having someone else try to convince them of something they don't agree with.

In my experience, it's more that people don't try to convince. Hell, the people who need safe-spaces, and the people they're trying to be "safe" from, don't even share the underlying epistemic assumptions that would allow them to "convince" each-other of anything less clearly observable than the sky being blue. The latter group, the people who other people need to be "safe" from, usually just scream, berate, harass, and often resort to violence.

(Note that I've avoided identifying "which side" is which. The answer is: it depends which side is dominant in your particular area. Boston and San Francisco and Brooklyn are left-dominant. Middle America is right-dominant.)

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by tsimionescu on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:44PM (#23762618)
No place in the US is left-dominant (this is true of most of Europe as well). There are right-dominant areas and centrist-dominant areas. Left discourse (think Chomsky) is extremely rare and almost never accepted in the media.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by rayiner on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @05:10PM (#23764110)
This is untrue when applied to social/cultural political issues. For example, the prevailing view during the Democratic primaries that undocumented immigrants should get universal healthcare coverage is to the left of nearly every EU country. Trump’s order required enhanced scrutiny of immigrants from certain Muslim countries is tame compared to Macron’s plans to essentially nationalize Islam. (And Macron is the left candidate—his far-right opponent is now receiving 45% of the support in polls.) Canada’s point-based immigration system, supported by the left and the right there, which heavily weighs English language fluency, would be denounced as irredeemably racist by the mainstream left in the US. What we are seeing in the media now, with attacks on the country’s founding documents and historical figures, would be utterly condemned in say France.

On social issues, our left is as far left as anywhere else in the developed world.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by tptacek on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:14PM (#23766018)
Hold on. That might have been the prevailing view counted by the candidates on stage, but it's not the prevailing view of the Democratic electorate, or of the nominee (Biden "supports" urgent care for undocumented immigrants, but does not support enrolling them in a national health plan). There was a crystal healer shaman on the stage for several of the debates; you can't just do this by roll call.

I agree with you in spirit, that we're further left than the American left realizes. But on this particular, I think you're wrong.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by rayiner on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:51PM (#23766185)
That’s fair. My point wasn’t to really assert a conclusion about the Democratic Party as a whole, but rather to show that there is a robust social left in the US. To my knowledge, only two Western countries extend universal (rather than emergency) care for undocumented immigrants.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @10:43PM (#23766414)
The broad US support for this is at least in large part as a response to the enormous levels of undocumented immigrants present as a result of what is widely seen (across the political spectrum, though for different reasons) as an incredible failure of the US immigration system. You can’t meaningdully assess position on an ideological spectrum based on comparing preferred policy responses without considering the differences in the objective circumstances to which the policy responses are directed.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by tptacek on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @10:47PM (#23766434)
There isn't broad support for this as a policy. Everyone knows about this issue because it's one of the least popular potential Democratic policies, with a strong majority in opposition, which is why Biden doesn't support it.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @10:58PM (#23766493)
> There isn't broad support for this as a policy.

Feel free to read it as “as broad as it is”, different polling from around the same time toward the end of when it was an active issue varied widely (I can find different polls from about the same time putting it at 30% and 11% support), and the exact breath of support isn't really relevant to my point.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @01:37PM (#23772185)
>To my knowledge, only two Western countries extend universal (rather than emergency) care for undocumented immigrants.

Not to derail, but extending public health care to undocumented immigrants in a pandemic just makes sense. Undocumented doesn't mean vaccinated, so there's a clear public interest in minimizing the absolute number of COVID-19 carriers, no matter their legal status.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by tsimionescu on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @07:32PM (#23765452)
You're right that on issues of theoretical minority rights, the left-most position is actually pretty common in the US (gay rights, trans rights, feminism, we are all equal regardless of the color of our skin).

But even on the actual practical side of those rights, this is not true. Discriminatory policing practices, reparations for slavery, abortion rights for women, and others have very commonly held right-wing positions even among democratic voters and politicians.

And calling Macron left-wing is funny, especially since the election had a very clear divide: Le Pen for the (extreme) right, Macron for the center (even center-right), and Melanchon for the left (he won slightly less votes than Le Pen, while being universally derided and ignored in the press).

Note that I explicitly said that left-wing discourse is missing from the mainstream in the US AND Europe, and in fact this is true for most of the world in general, with only small pockets in South America and east Asia.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by jahaja on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @06:39PM (#23764984)
> And Macron is the left candidate—his far-right opponent is now receiving 45% of the support in polls.

A centre-right candidate doesn't become "left" just because there's a far-right candidate. Maybe in the US that rhetoric works, but not in the EU.

What poll are you referring to where Macron's far-right opponent received 45%? Le Pen has 26% - less than Macron - from what I can see [0].

[0] https://www.politico.eu/europe-poll-of-polls/france/

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by rayiner on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @07:02PM (#23765208)
> A centre-right candidate doesn't become "left" just because there's a far-right candidate.

He's the more left candidate for purposes of this comparison, which is to compare where the U.S. is relative to France. So if Macron is to the right of Trump on muslim immigrants (and I think it's fair to say he is), and 45% of French support a candidate that is even further right, I think it's fair to say the U.S. is well to the left of France on the issue.

I was citing a head-to-head matchup in the second round: https://www.ft.com/content/6d8b9c7a-412c-11ea-a047-eae9bd51c...

> A recent Ifop opinion poll put Ms Le Pen narrowly ahead of Mr Macron for an assumed first round of the 2022 election, and within a few percentage points of victory in the second round (45 per cent to his 55 per cent)

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by jahaja on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @07:36PM (#23765488)
Sigh, that's just so blatant cherry-picking. Macron is deeply unpopular for his neo-liberal "reforms" that caused the yellow vests protests, a head-to-head polling against other candidates would likely render similar results.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by rayiner on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @08:57PM (#23765940)
It’s not cherry picking. An American candidate that had said the things Le Pen has said would be completely unviable. There is a reason that Trump—who is concerned outside the American norms even among many Republicans—is always accused of using “coded language” and “dog whistles.” That’s because in the US, even the “right wing fascist” candidate can’t get away with saying the overtly racist things that European right-wing people can get away with.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by jahaja on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:04PM (#23765966)
You blatantly cherry-picked the 45% number, but you seemed to ignore that part of my reply. Also, why are you changing the subject to what's allowed to be said or not? Trump's madness wouldn't be viable in the EU either.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @01:36PM (#23772155)
>He's the more left candidate for purposes of this comparison, which is to compare where the U.S. is relative to France.

IMHO, the Democratic Party to En Marche is a fair comparison, but Our Revolution to En Marche is just silly. At that point, at least compare Our Revolution to the Parti Socialiste (a conventional European social-democratic party) and DSA to La France Insoumise (ie: the democratic socialist party founded by a former leader of the French Communists).

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by Animats on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @10:20PM (#23766318)
A centre-right candidate doesn't become "left" just because there's a far-right candidate.

Biden faces that. He's not a classic leftist, like Bernie Sanders, Ralph Nader, Gene McCarthy, or Hubert Humphrey, all of whom were presidential candidates. To today's GOP, Eisenhower and Reagan would be considered too far left.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by leftyted on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @03:38PM (#23763154)
> Left discourse (think Chomsky) is extremely rare and almost never accepted in the media.

It must really baffle you that Chomsky signed this letter.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by tsimionescu on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @07:49PM (#23765586)
Why would it? There is a real problem with lack of tolerance of opposing ideas and witch hunting, obviously on the right but also in the center and even on the left.

And I have seen a lot of people on the left raising this problem and discussing how this will ultimately be used against them when, even when today it is done for mlre left-leaning goals. I think Professor Chomsky is extremely well aware of how easily tools of censorship are wielded against the voices of the minority.

And note that a lot of the grand-standing and calls to boycotts on these issues is coming from liberals, not leftists.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @01:33PM (#23772130)
I wasn't talking about "the media", but you're just being silly if you can go to a meeting of the Cambridge or Somerville City Councils (a majority of the latter are DSA members or allies, IIRC), or get involved in San Francisco's local politics, and think the Left (ie: the kind of Left that references Chomsky) is an insignificant force in those local contexts.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by Fellshard on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @01:01PM (#23761257)
It's also experiential - people reaching out in good faith for debate have consistently had their hand chewed up in return; and then a whole audience that sees that exchange and cements their opinions further. I'd argue the problem is often the choice of venue, and the expectation that internet strangers are truly going to come to a debate in good faith, but it still sets a consistent tone.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by pdonis on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:18PM (#23762303)
> The points don't matter, just which side of the line each person is on

That's because it isn't just about ideas, it's about power. Politics and government now are not about coming to consensus solutions that everyone, or at least everyone but a small minority who just wants to game the system, can live with. Politics and government now are about imposing on everyone whichever set of ideas gets a slim 51% majority. That isn't the way it was supposed to work.

I personally would like to see a Constitutional amendment that would require a 2/3 majority in both houses of Congress to pass any legislation, and a 3/4 majority required to override a Presidential veto. That would at least require some amount of bipartisan consensus, and therefore some amount of actually somewhat reasonable debate instead of just shouting back and forth, before a public policy was imposed on everyone.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by mcguire on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:23PM (#23762367)
"That would at least require some amount of bipartisan consensus, and therefore some amount of actually somewhat reasonable debate..."

What you would get would be a lot of back-room deals and strange bedfellows. Like now, only more so.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by pdonis on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:37PM (#23762525)
I'm not so sure. The back-room deals that go on now are not about getting the other side to vote for things they really don't want to vote for, as much as horse trading on which bills come up for a vote vs. getting stuck in committee or tabled. It would be harder for either side to get any value out of that if a 2/3 majority was required to pass a bill--back-room deals can't get that many votes to switch in the opposition party about something that's really contentious.

That's not to say that any bill that gets enough bipartisan consensus to pass a 2/3 vote must be good; plenty of bills that have passed in the past with that much consensus have been bad. But I think it might change the dynamics in at least something like the right direction.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @12:36PM (#23771525)
That's because the tools in place to override a tabling are the 2/3 vote tools.

Make everything 2/3 vote and you increase the need for the dealings that override the current 2/3 vote tools.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by pdonis on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @01:10PM (#23771869)
Which tools are you talking about?
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @01:22PM (#23771984)
Bills can be forced out of committee to the floor via a discharge petition (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discharge_petition), but it requires a 2/3 vote.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by gurumeditations on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:22PM (#23766053)
A) a 2/3 requirement would mean nothing gets passed, benefitting the only party that gains by obstructing legislation, the Republican Party

B) it doesn’t matter how high the bar is set when one side refuses to do their half of bipartisan responsibility (see impeachment)

When people are strictly divided, the barrier to pass something should be lower so that elections change things again. A government that can’t act might as well not exist. There’s no point in holding elections if legislators never pass any change. The liberal values that make the West free depend on civic engagement.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by pdonis on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @11:33PM (#23766649)
> a 2/3 requirement would mean nothing gets passed

Plenty of laws have been passed with that much of a majority.

> When people are strictly divided, the barrier to pass something should be lower so that elections change things again.

No, when people are strictly divided, they should try different things locally instead of having one side's preferred policies simply imposed on the other--much less having things flip again for everyone every time the party in power changes. That means it should be harder to pass Federal legislation that is binding on everyone, not easier. Federal legislation should only be passed if it has broad enough support to make it worth attempting to impose on everyone. Policies that don't have that kind of broad support throughout the country simply should not be enacted at the Federal level. They should be tried out on a smaller scale, in a state or locality where there is broad enough support.

> The liberal values that make the West free depend on civic engagement.

Civic engagement at all levels. Using the Federal government as a bludgeon to impose one side's policies on everyone is not "civic engagement". It's tyranny. Which is exactly what we set up the United States of America to protect against.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @04:33PM (#23763709)
I think a big part of it is the public space. Let's say I'm on X side of a debate. I can, in good faith, try to talk to someone from side Y. I might find some such person, or even several.

The problem is, if we're talking in a public forum, anyone can come up (from side X, side Y, or both) and jump in not in good faith. And so I get, as Fellshard said, my hand chewed off, not by the person I was talking to, but by a bunch of drive-by conversation-killers.

Under current conditions, I don't think a real conversation can happen in public (which includes social media).

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by bovermyer on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @12:46PM (#23761030)
Your first point sounds accurate to me.

I think what we're seeing is the solidification of identity in such strong and unyielding terms that anything that threatens that identity immediately triggers a basic survival instinct. At that point, rational discourse is not possible.

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @11:03AM (#23770569)
Correct. Rational discourse has already happened, for decades. We appear on the cusp of a structural shift, and in that span of time rational discourse isn't welcome.

People talked about whether the US should enter World War I for years before the German navy targeted US merchant vessels. After the decision to enter, speaking out against the militarization was grounds for arrest. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/fiery-socialist-chall...

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by 082349872349872 on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @01:07PM (#23761349)
We have more parties than the US and are less polarised[1]. I recommend more parties, but don't see any incremental way the US could get them.

[1] but then again, we had a mid-nineteenth century religiously-motivated civil war and it only killed a few hundred people. So maybe we support a plurality of parties because we're less polarisable, and not the other way around?

(rather than having a fabric of society, prone to ripping, having a dense irregular felt of society, of tocquevillean overlapping voluntary associations, FTW?)

Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by etrautmann on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @01:57PM (#23762053)
Ranked choice voting would help considerably
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by rayiner on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @05:02PM (#23764032)
We don’t want to convince each other, we want to destroy each other.
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by shadowgovt on Wednesday July 08, 2020 @11:04AM (#23770578)
handwave I think it's more "disempower," in general. There's nearly no doing open shooting, but people out in the streets are extremely disinterested in a conversation about "Maybe cops aren't so bad, you guys."
Re:A Letter on Justice and Open Debate by anonms-coward on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @12:47PM (#23761042)
People not willing to venture out their echo chambers is bad, but much better than being hell bent on taking away the livelihood of others for bad tweets.