News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by smichel17 on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @07:25AM (#23758024)
DNT also needs an equivalent "Do Track" header (dnt: 0?). That way people who want to opt in without clicking boxes can, and lack of the header can't be misconstrued as consent.

edit: uallo points out below that this is the specification. I didn't realize because none of the browsers implement it.

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by uallo on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @08:11AM (#23758340)
> dnt: 0

Yes, that is exactly how it was specified:

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Headers/DN...

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by qwerty456127 on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @07:30AM (#23758060)
Although I'm very anti-tracking, I don't think the don-not-track policy should be the default. This is not going to work this way. The whole DNT thing has actually been killed by Microsoft setting it on by default. Let the people who don't care to go and toggle the checkbox in the browser settings be tracked. It also should be possible to set the DNT field on per-domain basis.
Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by Pesthuf on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @08:16AM (#23758375)
It absolutely shouldn't. Advertisers STILL cite that Microsoft incident as the reason they don't support DNT, even though this happened 8 years ago. Just goes to show how dishonest they are. Ironically they don't ignore DNT - they use it as part of their fingerprinting...

I think if DNT was per Domain, advertisers would let your browser make a bunch of requests to different domains and check for which you have DNT set, which should give a fairly unique fingerprint...

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by corty on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:03AM (#23758749)
DNT wasn't killed by Microsoft. DNT was killed by advertisers looking for any reason to kill DNT. They just found Microsoft's default as their excuse to ignore DNT.
Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by Nursie on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @12:09PM (#23760635)
Do Not Track was always a joke. As if asking nicely ever worked with the ad industry.

The point of the law changes is that it becomes the website's responsibility to act properly, and ensure real opt-in.

If DNT was default off and was respected, most people would have never heard of it to switch it on. That's the only reason the ad industry even comment on it - it was designed to do nothing.

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by qwerty456127 on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @08:04PM (#23765674)
> The point of the law changes is that it becomes the website's responsibility to act properly, and ensure real opt-in.

Yet they still don't. They just manipulate the user into clicking yes without reading, again. I couldn't even find how to deny "the Oath" no matter how hard I tried.

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by Nursie on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @08:40PM (#23765862)
The Oath pages are the worst. Blatant violation.

Hopefully sometime it will be prosecuted. Until then treat as a big red flag.

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by freeone3000 on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @12:06PM (#23760614)
That seems very sour grapes - a major vendor said that it's gonna ship a browser with a setting configured, and everyone chooses to ignore that setting because it's common? That's pathologic thinking.
Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by dmitriid on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @11:39AM (#23760327)
Nothing to do with MS. Moreover, Safari is removing DNT because DNT is now used as an extra parameter in browser fingerprinting ... to better track users.
Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by Izkata on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @09:04PM (#23765971)
> I didn't realize because none of the browsers implement it.

It's in Firefox under Preferences -> Privacy and Security -> bottom of Enhanced Tracking Protection. Or just search for "do not track".

Privacy Badger has a separate setting (enabled by default) if you have that addon installed, and the header is sent if it's enabled in either place.

I know about these because I had a hell of a time at work adding Mixpanel to something. They respect this header. Unfortunately, I think it also means we underestimate the number of Firefox users we have.

Re:Dark patterns in GDPR consent boxes by smichel17 on Friday July 10, 2020 @11:57AM (#23792843)
Firefox lets you set 'DNT: 1' if you don't want to be tracked, using the setting you describe, but does not have a setting to send 'DNT: 0', indicating that you are okay being tracked. As a result, there is ambiguity about whether lack of a header means nothing or means "tracking is ok". If browsers let you broadcast your willingness to be tracked, advertisers wouldn't be able to make the (bad faith) argument that it's ok to track just because someone didn't set the header.