News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by IggleSniggle on Monday July 06, 2020 @11:50AM (#23749151)
I think many folks here didn't actually read the article, which addresses some of these questions. Dopamine is a learning marker that is a precursor to rewards. The first time you get the big reward, there is no dopamine, but you also might not remember it particularly well. The next time you are engaged in a behavior the previously gave you a reward, you get a hit of dopamine which helps you pay extra attention to the details surrounding the reward hit.

That is, it is the habit drug. It helps you remember the precise nature of recurrent rewards, and presumably is "intended" to help you get better are arriving at the reward.

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by jariel on Monday July 06, 2020 @03:05PM (#23751505)
So this is very insightful.

Is this why activities associated with bad 'dopamine habits' are so strongly correlated with said the bad habits that involved dopamine?

After having quit smoking, I find myself desperately wanting to do the 'break thing' whereby you stop what you're doing, take 5 minutes to just stand, relax and and enjoy the moment for a second while ignoring the stress.

I honestly don't even think I want the cigarette, just everything else about that experience.

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by giantrobot on Monday July 06, 2020 @03:36PM (#23751835)
I think that's adjacency rather than dopamine specifically. Unfortunately for you the "break thing" is adjacent to "cigarette". For whatever time you did the "break thing" with a cigarette you encoded a lot of behavioral and environmental memories together. So even after the chemical addition to the nicotine fades you're still associating the desirable "break thing" aspects with a cigarette.

Parallel universe you (possibly with a goatee) that did the "break thing" but never smoked during a break will want to take a break but has no association with cigarettes or smoking. Their desire for a break remains, maybe with the same strength, but with no desire for a cigarette.

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by buu700 on Monday July 06, 2020 @06:01PM (#23753299)
On a related note, this just reminded me that back in college, whenever I felt like taking a break from working, I would suggest to my smoker friends that we take a "smoke break" despite that I've never smoked a cigarette in my life.

(In hindsight I probably shouldn't have been encouraging a harmful drug addiction, but it was more tongue-in-cheek than anything.)

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by k__ on Monday July 06, 2020 @12:43PM (#23749690)
Ah, so the idea isn't that dopamin makes you feel good, but that "when" you feel good dopamin tries to help you to get this feeling quicker the next time in that context.

Makes much more sense now, thanks!

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by 488643689 on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @02:30PM (#23762444)
Dopamine is part of pleasure too, but most importantly it's "anticipation of reward" or how long you can focus on an action until your brain evaluates the result.

This is what's broken in ADHD and why people affected profit from increasing dopamine with some stimulants.

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by hnick on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @10:33PM (#23766377)
Is there a known opposite? A drug/chemical that teaches us "don't do that"? I assume there is something more than just the pain and memories we get from touching a hot pan, but I've never heard it given a name.
Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by Igelau on Monday July 06, 2020 @01:14PM (#23750045)
> many folks here didn't actually read the article

I've seen some dreck on PsychologyToday. After the author used a weak metaphor as an excuse to lead the article with Kim Kardashian's bust, and slammed other opinions as "kindergarten brain science", I didn't bother to see if there was anything subtle or worthwhile here. It's not the fault of readers if most of them were alienated quickly and bailed out. It's the fault of poor writing and editing that were indicative of time being wasted.

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by fortran77 on Monday July 06, 2020 @06:11PM (#23753391)
> I think many folks here didn't actually read the article

On Hacker News? Not likely. Everyone's a well informed 10xer who doesn't just go shooting his mouth off with the first thought that pops into his mind.

Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by lucas_membrane on Monday July 06, 2020 @10:51PM (#23755227)
Why would a HN reader read a Psychology Today article? About half the articles in there look like they have to be wrong, and most of the remainder are unconvincing. The HN comments are not always faultless, but they are reliably redolent of authority. I'll always take the straight line path to the dopamine.
Re:Dopamine is not addictive (2017) by james_s_tayler on Tuesday July 07, 2020 @01:00AM (#23755842)
I've learned to avoid Psychology Today.