Yes, yes, I know you want a secure source of income. Well, try think about ethics first, if not only.
Unless you're a founder, having a five-year startup exit strategy that pays out similarly to the income you could have obtained in a straightforward manner in finance is a microsoft/google/facebook/twitter-style long shot. And, the latter two haven't even IPO'd yet to allow full vested share liquidity...
All my friends consider it a fairly soulless industry. Though they joke about patent troll/NPE firms in the way most techies joke about financial firms.
A bank/VC that gives a loan/investment to small business/startup. That's finance. Hardly unethical.
Allowing people to get a car today while paying for it over time (instead of paying upfront). Hardly unethical.
Yes, there are bad actors in finance as there are in every space. Don't the Zyngas and others of the world via their offers engage in "ethically questionable" tactics?
Ultimately, we live in a pretty free agent society and if Wall St can pay more (no matter the reason), the rational engineer whose primary motivation is money should take that job. There is nothing wrong with that. The engineer who is motivated by money and other factors (building something valuable, being his/her own boss, etc) also has avenues a la doing a startup.
If the financial industry had actually had to bear the consequences of the risks they take in the same way that entrepreneurs do, the decisions would be rational. As it is, the finance sector is protected by the government whereas startups are not.
Merely commenting on your point as to why the "finance sector is protected by the government whereas startups are not".
If you don't seriously expect Facebook to get bailed out it's not a particularly meaningful thing to bring up.
But nevertheless, I'll go back to my original point. If the gov't thought that Facebook (or any startup) presented systemic risk, it'd likely get bailed out. I'll leave it at that.
I believe that there's a systemic problem with the industry and its role in society and that it is damaging our future prosperity.
Yes, any sufficiently powerful institution could, in principle pose such a problem, but why distract ourselves with imaginary problems when we have a real one sitting in front of us?
Bah. The mistakes will be repeated and the bailout question will arise again. And it will be worse next time.
We should have had the guts to say "fail and die." It would have sucked, but not as much as crushing debt and a sequel.
Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase etc. deal with an inordinate amount of the world's liquid assets. If they had failed, the problems wouldn't have been a few quarters of negative GDP growth--we could have seen the collapse of financial markets everywhere along with prolonged global depression. Should we have had the guts to deal with that too?
If we've merely postponed this problem and are waiting for Round II, then yes, we should have had the guts to have a depression resulting from irresponsible investments rather than a depression resulting from irresponsible investments AND governments up to their nostrils in debt.
1. Financial institutions cannot transfer funds between each other as usual and they cannot accurately predict who might fail next, so they pull back credit access. Spreads blow up as money supply decreases, causing a sharp decline in equipment investment and a big rise in consumer interest rates. Shit gets worse from there.
2. Banks die and, in conflict with everything we know about liquidity, money continues to flow perfectly. Banks are not afraid of failure so credit flows freely.
What do you see as more likely? Can you sum it up in a one-word answer?
However we're still in serious trouble because of the moral hazard created. Banks have been given the greenlight to take similar risks again because they know they'll be bailed out in future.
Frankly, without also taking steps to force banks back into smaller entities that we can afford to let fail, all we've done is compound the problem and delay it until later when it will be worse.
And then there are those who say, let me do a few years on Wall St and then I'll pursue the startup thing. What happens during that time is they lose their entrepreneurial edge (they become corporate dull) or they take on a lifestyle (nice house, cars etc = high fixed costs) which makes startup life less feasible.
Of course, in startup land, you have your occasional stellar upside scenarios a la Zuckerberg, but if economics is the main motivator, Wall St is a logical, rational choice esp if you work to live (and not live to work).
I say all of this as an NYC startup who feels this pain at times (although I think it is overblown and more of an excuse). I just don't think bellyaching about it achieves much.