If you really want to give the finger to China, dispense with the one China policy.
Living here in the valley, I wonder what’s the difference between aggressively progressive places and aggressively conservative places like a small town in Arkansas? To me, they are both intolerant of opposing views, don't think for themselves and subscribe to extremely strong stances.
Being a centrist, I feel like I am exiled in this country by all sides. The stronger one's view, the more burden is on them to prove their view with data, successive chain of logic and reasoning. I am constantly wary of my own views because either circumstances change, my understanding improves or new data is available. This is the HN way.
I think the US would make a huge leap forward if different political opinions we're viewed with "I disagree with you" versus "your beliefs mean youre a bad person".
This idea that Trump is somehow harder on China is laughable.
Trump has been screaming China loudly, but his actions amount to barely a whimper, and the cost has been paid overwhelmingly by Americans.
TPP on the other hand would have actually been effective by giving American companies 4-5 alternative countries they could relocate their operations too, with the added incentive that the TPP requirements would have protected their IP from being stolen like it is in China. And it would have cost the US nothing, because the relocated businesses were not in the US anyways, but were in China.
In fact, the added diversity of countries to manufacture would have probably made it even more of a win for the US.
The idea that Trump has been anything but a massive gift for China is ridiculous. There’s a reason China has ramped up its aggressiveness worldwide towards the end of the Trump admin (although they are probably clearly overreaching, but they realize this might be their last chance to make hay without the US doing anything).
Trump did go all out with his Trump card, trade and tariff.
But he can do so much more without playing this card to this extent.
Fear is what motivates people, the ideal that China would subject to all around 25% tariffs would put Xi on the edge. But Trump actually just went and realized the consequences because he thought he could.
Now the fear factor is gone. Surprisingly little had accomplished. Decoupling is sealed. CCP headliners had proved their view of US is always right and controls the narrative.
And the means to further escalation on the table is war.
Pretty unwitty and wasteful if you ask me.
There absolutely nothing logical about supporting a policy that superficially looks like a policy you support but has entirely different goals.
> Trump's trade war was an attempt to pressure China to reduce the trade deficit and help him in the 2020 election.
Yes, I support this view, although I don't support his re-election.
> If anything, Trump admires dictators who violate the human rights of their citizens.
Agreed, this was absolutely reprehensible and don't forget Russia.
I honestly have no energy to debate anymore. And this is not something I want to get into right now, the point was about being tolerant to other's views and try to understand why they think that way.
This is not rational in any explanation.
https://wjla.com/news/nation-world/rising-political-tension
Punched in the face for wearing a hat in Russian. The assailant couldn't read it, but attacked once the wearer told him the translation:
https://www.thedailybeast.com/man-beaten-up-in-california-re...
And here is seven pages of a Political Violence Report, official congressional record:
https://docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU00/20190409/109266/HHRG...
Here are three more, including an 81 year-old man:
https://www.bostonherald.com/2019/02/28/maga-hat-wearing-vic...
This was a serious beating, an art gallery owner:
https://abcnews.go.com/US/york-city-gallery-owner-attacked-w...
Citing the Berkeley assault, this guy wrote and app to help conservatives find safe places to dine out:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/03/11/need-safe...
This is attempted murder:
https://abcnews.go.com/US/man-arrested-allegedly-driving-van...
I searched for the same document produced during the Obama administration and could not find one. From that I infer that during his administration, neither conservative nor liberal politicians saw political violence as enough of a concern to list it and enter into the permanent record of the United States Congress.
Political violence and oppression was one of the primary motivators for the United States to seek independence from England. We are going backwards.
The down-voters are hurt and clueless.
>I had pretty unpleasant pushbacks during lunch breaks and then I stopped discussing things all together.
This is the weakness of American individualism. Some form of organization is necessary to achieve anything meaningful here. This is a job for regulation/trade policy. Attempting to shame individual companies or "the public" is at best pointless, and at worst a distraction from a real solution.
There's a pretty funny example here from the tech world: web search, google, and microsoft. What has been achieved by google abandoning the Chinese search market? It sure as hell isn't respect for that decision. Far more vitriol (even at the level of US congress) has been directed at google over this than microsoft, who operate bing in China!
Don't get me wrong, google deserved the criticism over dragonfly. But where is the outrage over microsoft operating bing under China's censorship policies? This is why organization/regulation is required: people are really bad at maintaining a coherent position even in the absence of market pressures, which are massive in the case of trade with China.