But back to real world, cloth masks is what we got.
There is an asymmetry between healthcare workers and the public - in a hospital, you have one non-infected person surrounded by a lot of infected people, while elsewhere, it's the opposite.
I see a lot of people wearing surgical masks, and having just googled and read a page on 3M's site, it mentions:
"Surgical/procedure or “medical” facemasks are designed to help keep spit and mucous generated by the wearer from reaching a patient or medical equipment. Some surgical/procedure masks do contain filter media but as they may not be designed to form a seal to the face, and have not been certified to meet all of the performance standards of a respirator, they should not be used to help reduce exposures to airborne particles"
I feel like this is a simple difference that people can't comprehend due to a very primitive equation of protecting oneself and protecting others. There is a difference and it should inform our behavior.
Edit: to clarify, I meant to contrast the N95 masks with a valve, that seem to make more sense for health care workers, with the surgical masks that seem to make more sense for the public.
So the protection that unfitted cloth masks provide, and it is some, isn't as much as you'd think against the primary mechanism of spread. Wear an unfit mask and sing and it's as bad as normal singing.
I'm not arguing for not wearing bad masks when it's all you have. I'm saying it's super important that everyone starts getting real masks so we don't have to keep doing shelter-in-place every time spread goes exponential in an area again.
Singing propels droplets further (as does any heavy/forceful breathing), and choirs tend to sit close together. Six feet likely isn't enough for a choir.
As for meatpacking, I've heard several interviews with workers that indicated the plants were only handing out one mask per shift, and they'd pretty quickly get contaminated by gore from the work, meaning in practice folks weren't wearing masks.
No, every exhalation is aerosol and filled with particles from your body. They slip by the mask's edge and through it's seams. No mask that isn't airtight can stop those particles.
Droplets are emitted when you cough or sneeze and are much larger. Droplets are like boulders, aerosol like marbles. Viruses are tiny compared with aerosols and ride on both aerosols and droplets.
"239 Experts With 1 Big Claim: The Coronavirus Is Airborne" https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/04/health/239-experts-with-1...
>The W.H.O. has resisted mounting evidence that viral particles floating indoors are infectious, some scientists say. The agency maintains the research is still inconclusive.
There needs to be a strong and lasting push for increased N95 mask production or at least purchasing. Pretending that ineffective unfit masks (of any material!) can fill the role of real masks does real damage and needs to stop. If everyone could rotate a set of N95 masks when indoors then spread could really be stopped.
Even a synthetic/cotton/synthetic mask would be quite effective if they'd just incorporate metal nose bridge with foam.