News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by obblekk on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:38AM (#23723887)
I’m surprised that free market enthusiasts don’t see zoning laws as a limitation of freedom, even though it’s probably the most direct limitation by government today.

There could be so much innovation in solving the NIMBY problem. Make a cash payment to neighbors while construction is happening to compensate for the nuisance, give them equity in your new building if their view is damaged, obligate builders to also build bus stops/bike lanes/whatever to make the streets navigable with high density, mixed use construction with privacy to avoid strangers.

So many problems that people have with construction can be solved and incentives aligned if people had the ability to try to convince their neighbors.

Instead we’ve ended up with city councils that have high incumbency rates because voting in city elections is cumbersome requiring you to convince the whole city to change zoning rather than just your neighbors.

And I’m surprised politically liberal people aren’t even more in favor. So many people want to move to the west coast but can’t due to cost of living. Instead they move to the south and southwest. Even if California got a million staunch republicans, the state would vote democratic overall and get more electoral votes. In fact, I wonder if some of our political polarization is the consequence of reduced mobility due to high housing costs for new people.

I’m hopeful the millennial generation fixes federal housing policy. That alone would be a meaningful contribution to society.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by fennecfoxen on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:44AM (#23723945)
If you’re surprised they’re not, it’s because you’re not looking. The actual free market enthusiasts condemn it extensively.

Go over to reason.com and search for their zoning coverage. Go to the AEI and find their report calling for the abolition of single family zoning. (I’d send you links, but I’m on a phone.)

The main difference between them and the more left-leaning types who hate single family zoning is that they’re not too big on replacing it with other zoning.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by voisin on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:59AM (#23724082)
> I’d send you links, but I’m on a phone.

Off topic but I feel like this all the time too. What do you think would have to change about your phone to not feel like this? Voice commands? UI changes?

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by zbrozek on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:08AM (#23724148)
Finding stuff is a little slower and harder because of the small screen. Selecting text (e.g., to get a reasonably-sized URL) is massively painful. Copy-and-paste with long presses is finicky (often you end up moving the selection by mistake). Bleh. Forget it.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by snarfy on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:40AM (#23724440)
Compared to a PC, copying and pasting on a phone is physically laborious. Switching to the app, selecting the text, switching back, possibly fiddle with the cursor position and then finally pasting by waiting for the phone to interpret a long press as a paste command. It all sucks.

It would be nice if I could enter copy/paste mode, and when in that mode I had a mouse cursor that I could move by holding my finger above the screen (so I can see the cursor), and basically use my finger like a virtual mouse during the cut/paste operation.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:11PM (#23725670)
On android you can tap and hold the spacebar to slide the cursor around.

I'd love to have a phone case with a flip down physical keyboard and a dot like on a ThinkPad. Think, old school game boy.

For the rest of my problems,we just need better integration and customization. My last two phones have pop out drawers pinned to the sides. This can be taken much further to provide instant access to the clip tray, contacts,messages,emails, bookmarks, calender, password manager, and on and on. But no. I get notifications from the top, which has the customizability of a closed source terminal. From the bottom I have a barebones task bar. And I can pin 5apps to a pinned button that I can dock up and down either side. Can't even change its color tough. My current phone is leagues more powerful than my first smart phone, but my first was more usable and customizable.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by voisin on Friday July 03, 2020 @05:05PM (#23727635)
On iPhone you can either press and hold space bar (older iPhones with a physical home button) or press and hold the empty space below the space bar (newer iPhones with FaceID) to slide the cursor around with accuracy.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by fennecfoxen on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:56AM (#23724547)
I'm off the phone now. Let's taste a sample of free market enthusiasts inveighing against zoning. These are just some of the ones that were easy to find:

American Enterprise Institute ("a public policy think tank dedicated to defending human dignity, expanding human potential, and building a freer and safer world. The work of our scholars and staff advances ideas rooted in our belief in democracy, free enterprise ...")

https://www.aei.org/op-eds/to-solve-the-problem-of-unafforda... (Dec 2019): "To solve the problem of unaffordable entry-level housing, abolish single-family zoning. Allowing 2-, 3- and 4-family structures amid single-family homes could add 10% to today’s housing stock"

https://www.aei.org/economics/a-different-take-on-americas-h... (2018): "Demand is too high, supply is too low, therefore role back regulations on land-use and zoning and allow the market to work. As Fisher put it, if cities start “allowing townhomes and duplexes and places that were originally single-family homes to be redeveloped into 20 unit buildings, I think you would see the market take care of itself."

https://www.aei.org/research-products/report/a-plea-for-beau... (2012): "Zoning contributes to the dereliction of the city when its local industries die and ensures that the central areas are not places of renewal, but at best museums and at worst vandalized spaces no one can use. In successful cities like Paris, New York, and Rome, workshops, apartments, offices, schools, churches, and theaters all stand side by side, with houses borrowing walls from whatever building has a boundary to spare."

Let's go over to Reason, a little more strident with their opinions. Their magazine bears the slogan, "free minds and free markets". And let us see how long they have opposed it. Looks like they've done so since... NINTEEN SEVENTY SIX. I was not alive in 1976. My parents were alive, but not old enough to vote. So let's take a look at the legacy our grandfathers' generation has left us.

https://reason.com/1976/01/01/the-case-against-land-use-plan... "WHO LOSES? The results of land use legislation will be particularly harmful to the less well-to-do, since they are least able to cope with higher prices."

"Section 509(d) provides that nothing in the Act shall be construed to "enhance or diminish the rights of owners of property as provided by the Constitution of the U.S. and the constitution and laws of the states in which the property is located." For Howard Hughes that may be comforting. But for the small landowner it is close to meaningless. No matter how wicked and confiscatory a regulation is, a bolt from heaven will not strike it dead. It can only be declared unconstitutional by a court of law, and this means that an owner must be in a position to use costly and lengthy court processes to sue for such a ruling. The situation faced by affluent owners would be entirely different from that of the less affluent."

They lost that round pretty badly, though. Within a decade the magazine had moved from forecasting the inevitable consequences to documenting them.

https://reason.com/1986/02/01/zoning-revolutionary/ "Zoning contributes to housing shortages and holds down commercial development; it adds paperwork and years and political shenanigans to land-use changes; and, ominously, it is used to exclude "undesirables.""

https://reason.com/1990/10/01/zoning/ "As zoning laws continue to keep the dream of affordable housing just that, a dream, one usually apolitical group is calling for a change. Habitat for Humanity International says zoning laws, along with prohibitive development fees, often undermine its nonprofit efforts to build "simple, decent" housing for the nation's poor."

https://reason.com/2013/05/07/zoning-kills-affordable-housin... "Zoning Kills Affordable Housing: How established homeowners use regulations to stop new low-cost homes." (Book review)

https://reason.com/2014/11/16/washingtons-beautiful-illegal/ "Washington's Beautiful, Illegal Tiny Houses: Architectural minimalism runs afoul of outdated regulations in the nation's capital."

https://reason.com/2015/07/26/zoning-out-the-poor/ "Zoning out the poor". In case you thought libertarians and free markets were all about pooh-poohing the poor.

https://reason.com/2017/05/25/residential-zoning-in-new-york... "Zoning Laws in New York, San Francisco, and San Jose Cut Americans' Wages by $8,775 / And they've made the U.S. economy 9 percent smaller than it would it otherwise be."

https://reason.com/2018/08/14/ben-carson-calls-out-zoning-re... "Ben Carson Calls Out Zoning Regulations for Driving Up Housing Costs: The HUD Secretary wants to revise Obama-era housing regulations he says do too little to address the real drivers of housing costs."

https://reason.com/2018/12/10/progressive-minneapolis-just-p... "Progressive Minneapolis Just Passed One of the Most Deregulatory Housing Reforms in the Country: Urban liberals are won over to libertarian policies, if not libertarian politics."

https://reason.com/2019/02/08/zoning-makes-the-green-new-dea... "Zoning Makes the Green New Deal Impossible: A bad idea is made worse by its inability to grapple with local land use restrictions."

https://reason.com/2020/04/18/cant-afford-your-rent-blame-he... "Can't Afford Your Rent? Blame Herbert Hoover. The feds pushed cities to implement zoning restrictions. High prices and social inequality were the inevitable results."

https://reason.com/2020/07/02/empowered-by-excessive-regulat... "Zoning and other municipal regulations give busybodies a license to harass people they don't like and force others to conform to subjective standards as they see fit."

That last one was literally posted yesterday, just to show you that they're still doing it.

Oh, and one more classic, just to consider it in light of current events: https://reason.com/1984/10/01/telecommuting-will-the-plug-be... "Telecommuting: Will the Plug be Pulled? ... The prospect of such a dramatic increase [in telecommuting] has not been universally welcomed."

""Those of us who plop down our Apples in the office at home or in the rec room are probably not in any danger of violating any local ordinances," commented former Labor Department assistant secretary Donald Elisburg recently. "But if the work stations spread and it becomes popular, there may be more consideration of local zoning laws as to whether such installations are permitted.""

"Yes, zoning laws. In general, local zoning laws already regulate any work done in the home in some manner and often require home businesses to obtain permits. Thus far, such laws have rarely been used against telecommuters. Chicago is an exception. Its city code stipulates that except for certain professionals, who may use their residences for "consultation, emergency treatment, or performance of religious rites," all home work is taboo when it involves the "installation or use of any mechanical or electrical equipment customarily incident to the practice of any such professions. [...] "The law is one of the nation's most restrictive," [Professor William Toner] told me. "It's structured so that there's a good chance it would be illegal for Saul Bellow to write a Nobel Prize–winning novel at home.""

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:24PM (#23725762)
Excellent work. Thanks for putting all this together.
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by megiddo on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:44AM (#23723942)
If it helps. I'm a free market type.

We've been railing against zoning regulations for decades.

Here's an article from Mises.org (about as free-market as you can find) from 2010 railing against it:

https://mises.org/library/zoning-laws-destroy-communities

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by treis on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:31AM (#23724861)
>Make a cash payment to neighbors while construction is happening to compensate for the nuisance, give them equity in your new building if their view is damaged, obligate builders to also build bus stops/bike lanes/whatever to make the streets navigable with high density, mixed use construction with privacy to avoid strangers.

Half of what you say is indistinguishable from zoning (the transit part). The other half runs into the problem of people not agreeing to the compensation.

The reality is that what you do on your property impacts my property and utilizes public resources. There has to be some mechanism to regulate that and enforce those regulations. The problem isn't the concept of zoning but how it has been applied.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by xkde on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:45AM (#23723957)
> I’m surprised that free market enthusiasts don’t see zoning laws as a limitation of freedom

We do.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by gumby on Friday July 03, 2020 @11:12AM (#23724695)
> I’m surprised that free market enthusiasts don’t see zoning laws as a limitation of freedom...

They do, not just in academia as other comments have observed, but in practice (consider Houston)

[dead]
Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by erichocean on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:52AM (#23724018)
Robert Conquest’s First Laws of Politics:

Everyone is conservative about what he knows best.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by ip26 on Friday July 03, 2020 @01:16PM (#23725700)
IMO there is a lot of intellectual dishonesty among many self professed free market enthusiasts. For example, a dogged insistence that externalities don't actually exist, or wait they could exist but in practice never will, or maybe they do exist but will never be large, actually it doesn't matter, the important thing is that we don't do anything about them.

I wanted to call myself libertarian-minded for a while but the practice just doesn't seem to match the fundamental principals.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by briandear on Friday July 03, 2020 @09:45AM (#23723959)
> I’m surprised that free market enthusiasts don’t see zoning laws as a limitation of freedom

I do. However, I grew up in Houston which doesn’t have zoning. When I lived in Jersey City about 8 years ago and was working on the Steve Fulop campaign, I was amazed at how vicious zoning and variance fights could become. Zoning and the fights over it are exceptional hotbeds of corruption.

Re:It’s Time to Abolish Single-Family Zoning by h2odragon on Friday July 03, 2020 @10:44AM (#23724457)
This dude got famous after a zoning fight: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marvin_Heemeyer