Re:How well do cars do in crash tests they're not optimized ...
by titzer on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @12:31AM
(#23697767)
It is a difference in kind: VW dynamically detected and adapted behavior to the test. It would never operate in that way under normal conditions. The water heater example was completely static: it always behaved the same way, under test or not.
Re:How well do cars do in crash tests they're not optimized ...
by esrauch on Wednesday July 01, 2020 @02:50PM
(#23705013)
People obviously disagree since I was downvoted but I don't really see the black-and-white difference between the two.
In both cases there was an intentional design change to deliberately changed mislead a measurement, and the final product does not match the intended thing. Both adversarially directly cause the consumer's purchase to not be the intended item; no one gets a car that has emissions measured and no one gets a heater that has the efficiency measured.
I think the difference between what they did and this is only a difference in degree and not kind though, right?