Re:Android openness withering as Google withholds Honeycomb
by kenjackson on Friday March 25, 2011 @01:59PM
(#2369558)
Why do they have to use GPLv3 to be open source? Apache, BSD, MIT, are no longer open source licenses?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Android openness withering as Google withholds Honeycomb
by jpk on Friday March 25, 2011 @02:08PM
(#2369594)
The GPLv3 has provisions specifically for preventing the locked bootloader deal seen on most phones today.
Re:Android openness withering as Google withholds Honeycomb
by kenjackson on Friday March 25, 2011 @02:21PM
(#2369640)
But surely for Honeycomb this isn't necessary. If Motorola wants to lock the bootloader then they can do so. This doesn't prevent Samsung or Archos from using the Honeycomb code. It just prevents people from rooting and modifying code that runs on Motorola's device, which is their perogative given that there is no end to HW manufacturers for Android products.
Re:Android openness withering as Google withholds Honeycomb
by cube13 on Friday March 25, 2011 @03:28PM
(#2369932)
It's necessary if it's GPLv3. The anti-Tivolization clause means that the manufacturer needs to provide the ability for the user to sign their code.
From a support point of view, I cannot see any reason why any hardware manufacturer would go along with GPLv3 software. It adds a level of complexity that just doesn't make much sense to deal with, because it's not the manufacturer's best interest to support ANY code, just the code that they have put on the device.
Re:Android openness withering as Google withholds Honeycomb
by lukeschlather on Friday March 25, 2011 @04:32PM
(#2370223)
The GPLv3 doesn't require you to support custom builds. It just requires you to let people use them. The code doesn't have to be signed at the hardware level. Heck, all you have to do is replace the splash screen on bootup with a "warning unsigned code detected, this device may have been compromised."
And as far as supporting any code, most manufacturers of processors do in fact support running any code you like on them. Especially the dominant Intel-compatible personal computer, where Apple themselves support running any operating system you like.